ANTISEMITISM ADMISSION: UN Rapporteur Francesca Albanese Apologizes, Says She Misunderstood Meaning of Term
UN Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese apologized Monday after acknowledging that she had incorrectly understood both the origin of the word “antisemitism” and the meaning of a term used for certain Jewish prisoners in Nazi concentration camps.
⠀
“I sincerely apologize,” Albanese wrote on X. “I misread the term ‘Muselmann’ (Muslim) used in Nazi camps for prisoners at the brink of death, wrongly inferring that the term antisemitism originally meant hatred of all Semitic peoples. In fact it was coined specifically to denote hatred of Jews.”
⠀
The apology followed earlier remarks by Albanese in which she asserted that Jews being led to their deaths in Nazi concentration camps were sometimes referred to as “the Muslims.”
⠀
“In fact, when they were being taken to the gas chambers, there are some accounts of life in the concentration camps saying that Jews were called ‘the Muslims.’”
⠀
Albanese made the assertion as part of a broader argument in which she contended that the term “antisemitism” had not originally referred specifically to hatred of Jews, but rather encompassed hostility toward all people she characterized as “Semitic.”
⠀
“When the word ‘antisemitism’ was coined, it referred to anyone who was not European and who came from the Middle East,” Albanese said, adding that the term only became associated specifically with Jews because they constituted the largest non-Christian minority in Europe at the time.
⠀
The term “Muselmann” was in fact used in Nazi concentration camps to describe prisoners who had become severely emaciated, physically depleted and close to death. According to Yad Vashem, the term referred to prisoners who could no longer stand upright; some scholars have suggested that its origin was connected to the posture associated with Muslim prayer.
⠀
The word “antisemitism,” meanwhile, was coined by German agitator Wilhelm Marr in 1879 as a term for hostility toward Jews, employing racial terminology that was presented at the time as having a scientific basis. Historically, the term has specifically denoted prejudice, hostility or hatred directed against Jews. In more recent years, some activists on the political left have argued for a broader understanding of the term that would encompass hatred directed at Arabs and Muslims as well.
⠀
Albanese has previously faced repeated accusations of antisemitism over her public comments. In February, several European Union foreign ministers condemned remarks she delivered at an Al Jazeera conference, where she said: “The fact that instead of stopping Israel, most of the world has armed, given Israel political excuses, political sheltering, economic and financial support … We who do not control large amounts of financial capitals, algorithms and weapons, we now see that we as a humanity have a common enemy.”
⠀
Albanese subsequently disputed interpretations of those remarks, insisting in an interview that she “never, ever, ever said ‘Israel is the common enemy of humanity,'” and describing the claims against her as “completely false accusations.”
⠀
Controversy surrounding Albanese’s statements about Israel and Jews predates the current war. Social media posts that surfaced in 2022 showed her referring to the “Jewish lobby” as exercising control over the United States.
⠀
Albanese rejected accusations at the time that her reference to the “Jewish lobby” was antisemitic, saying that her comments had been “mischaracterized”. She has continued to face criticism over subsequent statements and actions concerning Israel.
⠀
Following Hamas’s October 7, 2023 massacre in Israel, Albanese argued that the attack had to be considered in “context” and described it as a response to Israeli “aggression.”
