KILL ALL THE JEWS: New York Man Accused of Threatening Lakewood Jewish Charity, Then Turning on FBI Agents
A 33-year-old upstate New York man accused of making chilling antisemitic threats against a Jewish charitable organization in Lakewood, New Jersey, has been arrested on federal charges after allegedly threatening FBI agents who attempted to question him about the calls.
Dylan Daniell, a resident of La Fargeville in Jefferson County, allegedly contacted the Lakewood nonprofit repeatedly in May, expressing a desire to murder Jews, including by placing them in gas chambers. Months later, when federal investigators arrived at his residence to question him, prosecutors say he responded with threatening statements and subsequently sent an intimidating message to one of the agents.
Daniell appeared in federal court on October 9 before U.S. Magistrate Judge Mitchell Katz in the Northern District of New York. He was ordered held pending a detention hearing scheduled for October 15.
Federal prosecutors have charged Daniell with threatening federal law enforcement officers with the intent to impede, intimidate or interfere with their official duties. If convicted, he could face a maximum sentence of 10 years in federal prison.
According to a criminal complaint filed October 8, the investigation began with a series of disturbing telephone calls received by an unidentified Jewish nonprofit organization in Lakewood on May 17.
During one of the recorded conversations, the caller allegedly declared, “I would like to put all the Jews in a gas chamber and kill them.”
In another call, the individual stated, “I would like to blow up Israel and kill all the Jews.”
The caller also allegedly made a specific reference to Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu, saying, “I would like to kill Benjamin Netanyahu and all the Jews.”
The threatening remarks prompted an FBI investigation, with agents working to determine the identity of the person responsible for the calls.
According to the FBI affidavit, investigators traced the telephone number used to contact the charity through law enforcement records and information associated with a Cash App account, ultimately connecting it to Daniell.
The FBI’s efforts to interview Daniell culminated in a confrontation outside his La Fargeville apartment on October 7, according to the complaint.
Two federal agents initially arrived at the residence but found that Daniell was not home. They subsequently attempted to contact him by telephone.
At approximately 12:30 p.m., Daniell returned to the property in a vehicle and emerged “accompanied by an adult female, a dog and an infant child,” the court documents state.
When the agents approached and identified themselves as FBI personnel, Daniell allegedly responded with an obscene remark and a series of threatening statements.
Among other things, he reportedly declared that the “only good cop is a dead cop,” before warning the agents to “get the f\*\*\* out of here before I pull something out on you.”
The agents departed the property following the confrontation, but prosecutors allege that Daniell’s threatening behavior continued after they left.
Approximately four hours later, one of the investigators received a text message from the same telephone number that had been used to contact the Lakewood charity.
“You ever come to my house again, you will not like it,” the message stated, according to court records. “That’s not a threat. That’s a promise to all you tyrant, pedophile FBI agents.”
The alleged threats against the agents became the basis for the federal criminal charge filed against Daniell the following day.
The Justice Department announced his arraignment on October 9 at the federal courthouse in Syracuse, where Magistrate Judge Katz ordered him detained pending further proceedings.
In addition to a possible 10-year prison sentence, Daniell faces a fine of up to $250,000 and as many as three years of supervised release if convicted. Any sentence would be determined by the court under federal sentencing law.
First Assistant U.S. Attorney John A. Sarcone III issued a forceful warning following the arrest, emphasizing that threats directed at federal investigators would be prosecuted.
“Threatening law enforcement officers is not a joke,” Sarcone stated. “It is not something that we will brush aside, and it will not be tolerated.”
Sarcone further warned that individuals who believe they can intimidate federal officers must recognize that such conduct carries serious legal consequences, pledging aggressive prosecution of those responsible.
Craig L. Tremaroli, special agent in charge of the FBI’s Albany Field Office, also condemned the alleged conduct, describing the initial calls to the Jewish charity as deeply disturbing and the subsequent threats against investigators as an additional serious offense.
Tremaroli said the FBI would continue taking action against individuals who threaten violence, particularly against officers carrying out their responsibilities to protect the public.
The case is being investigated by the FBI with assistance from the New York State Police. Assistant U.S. Attorney Matthew J. McCrobie is handling the prosecution.
Although the investigation originated with the antisemitic telephone calls to the Lakewood organization, the criminal complaint presently charges Daniell with threatening federal law enforcement officers. Prosecutors have not announced separate criminal charges arising directly from the calls to the charity.
Daniell remains in federal custody ahead of his October 15 detention hearing. The allegations against him have not been proven in court, and he is presumed innocent unless convicted.
