“Politics on the Backs of Reservists”: Edelstein Launches Frontal Attack Against the Charedim
Israel’s political system moved closer to a potential collapse Wednesday as Yesh Atid formally submitted a bill to dissolve the 25th Knesset, setting up a possible vote next week amid an escalating coalition crisis over the draft law and growing rift between charedi leadership and Prime Minister Binyomin Netanyahu.
At the same time, MK Yuli Edelstein, the former chairman of the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, delivered a forceful and unusually direct criticism of the charedi parties, accusing them of acting out of political interests rather than seeking a real solution.
“I told you already ten months ago that replacing the leadership of the committee would not change anything,” Edelstein said, referring to his removal as committee chairman, which he believes effectively ended any realistic chance of advancing draft legislation.
Edelstein, who was removed from his position after supporting a sovereignty bill in Judea and Samaria against his faction’s stance, said the Israeli public now understands who is acting in the interest of soldiers and who is driven by politics. “My greatest pride is that I prevented the evasion law,” he declared, adding that he will continue to push for a fair draft law even outside the committee.
Responding to his dismissal, Edelstein said, “If all my sins were that I stood by the Land of Israel and voted in favor of applying sovereignty in Judea and Samaria, then I am proud of it. Just as I am proud that I prevented evasion and that I am fighting for real charedi enlistment.” He added, “Even outside the Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, I will continue to fight for equal enlistment and for the Land of Israel.”
In one of his harshest critiques, Edelstein accused charedi leadership of having no genuine intention of resolving the draft issue, even at the cost of bringing down a right-wing government. Recent efforts to pass draft legislation have failed, despite Netanyahu’s assurances to charedi leaders that a final version would be presented. Delays ultimately stalled the process. A senior charedi figure acknowledged at the time, “It must be admitted, there will be no draft law in the current Knesset. We failed.”
Edelstein argued that charedi leaders would rather collapse the government than advance a draft law requiring yeshiva students to serve in the military or national service. He described the situation as “cheap politics” conducted at the expense of reservists and active-duty soldiers, vowing to continue advocating for what he sees as a balanced and equitable solution.
Despite speculation about divisions among charedi factions, reports indicate that Degel Hatorah and Shas are operating in full coordination on the issue of yeshiva students and share the view that Netanyahu has failed to meet his commitments. As previously reported, this breakdown led to a dramatic directive from Hagaon Rav Dov Landau, who declared that “the concept of a bloc no longer exists.”
According to accounts from a key meeting of Degel Hatorah representatives, Rav Landau instructed party members that from now on, the only consideration would be “what is good for charedi Judaism,” without regard for previous political alliances. He also stated that “we no longer have trust in Netanyahu,” a declaration that significantly undermines the stability of the current coalition.
The convergence of Yesh Atid’s bill and the loss of charedi backing for Netanyahu has left the government facing a serious challenge to its survival. With prominent Likud figures like Edelstein openly criticizing former coalition partners, the coalition’s ability to withstand a vote next week is increasingly uncertain.
Political parties are now preparing for the possibility of elections, with the draft issue expected to become a central campaign topic. Rav Landau’s directive means that future Knesset votes by charedi parties will be guided solely by what they see as beneficial for their community, rather than broader coalition considerations.
Edelstein’s remarks come at a time when the coalition is already under severe strain. The recent decision by Rav Landau is widely seen as marking the collapse of the longstanding political alliance between charedi parties and Netanyahu, raising the possibility that the government could fall in the near term and trigger early elections.
{Matzav.com}
