Bnei Brak Officials Face Backlash Over Miami Trip; Deputy Mayor Menachem Shapira Responds
A delegation of senior Bnei Brak municipal officials—led by Mayor Chanoch Zeibert and his deputy, Menachem Shapira—traveled to Miami last week, sparking sharp criticism from residents. The trip, described by critics as a “luxury vacation at the public’s expense,” was conducted in first class and carried an estimated price tag that many insisted was unacceptable for a publicly funded delegation.
While the mayor has not yet issued a response, Deputy Mayor Menachem Shapira chose to address the growing controversy in a conversation with Kikar HaShabbat, offering a detailed explanation of the trip’s purpose.
Shapira, who serves as Deputy Mayor and Chairman of the Planning and Construction Committee, said, “I will be returning early this week from the United States following a professional work visit, together with a delegation headed by Mayor Chanoch Zeibert, joined by the city’s CEO, the Halachic Committee CEO, and his deputy.”
According to Shapira, the visit was not a leisure trip but rather a key stage in advancing one of the largest municipal infrastructure and recreation projects in Bnei Brak’s history: a 350-dunam municipal attractions park, carrying an estimated cost of 180 million shekels.
“This project represents a historic planning milestone,” he explained, “and will provide the residents of Bnei Brak with a modern, unique recreation space that is fully suited to the character and needs of the chareidi community.”
Shapira added that the project will include a 15,000-seat amphitheater, a state-of-the-art ropes park, a karting complex, extreme-sports installations, large-scale play areas, and more than five kilometers of uninterrupted cycling paths.
One of the central claims raised by critics was that there was no justification for such an expensive overseas trip. In his response, Shapira argued that the unusual scope of the project—and the halachic, logistical, and safety requirements unique to the city—demanded direct examination of technologies, safety systems, and operational models.
“As part of the advanced planning stages,” Shapira said, “the delegation participated in the IAAPA convention in Orlando, the world’s leading professional exhibition in the field of recreational installations.” He noted that the delegation held meetings with top international companies regarding advanced safety systems, cutting-edge equipment, and specialized solutions appropriate for the chareidi public over the long-term operation of the park.
Addressing concerns about the cost of the trip, Shapira emphasized, “I joined the professional visit after being in the United States for a private family event. This visit is another essential stage in leading one of Bnei Brak’s most significant municipal projects. It reflects a deep commitment to developing world-class infrastructure while maintaining unwavering consideration for the needs and sensitivities of our residents.”
{Matzav.com}
