Phuket Governor Orders Investigation Into Chabad Operations Amid Cemetery Controversy
Thai authorities have launched a comprehensive review of Chabad’s activities in Phuket, with the provincial governor ordering officials to examine land ownership, construction permits and business licenses connected to Chabad of Patong. The development comes just days after a large Rosh Hashanah meal for Israeli travelers was canceled and amid a separate controversy involving a Jewish cemetery in Thailand.
Phuket Governor Chotnarin Kerdsom reportedly instructed relevant government agencies on Tuesday to complete the investigation within seven days.
The review will examine the ownership of the property used by Chabad of Patong, how the land was acquired, permits governing its use, construction approvals and licenses associated with commercial activities at the site.
Authorities will also examine corporate shareholder records connected with the Chabad operation to determine whether there is any overlap or business connection with a company involved in the establishment of a Jewish cemetery in Thailand’s Chachoengsao province.
The investigation follows heightened attention surrounding Chabad activities in Thailand in recent days.
On Friday, a large Rosh Hashanah meal organized by Chabad of Patong for approximately 2,000 Israeli travelers was canceled at the last minute. The cancellation came after a pro-Palestinian demonstration was held in the area for several hours.
Separately, Thai authorities have been examining issues surrounding a Jewish cemetery project. Thai Deputy Interior Minister Phonphirun Suwanchawee recently addressed the matter after authorities said that the company behind the project had been established by three Israeli nationals who also hold Thai citizenship and were registered as owners of the land.
Officials in Phuket are now seeking to determine whether there are corporate or business connections between that company and Chabad of Patong.
Phuket Vice Governor and provincial spokesman Ronnarong Thipsiri confirmed that the governor had directed government agencies to conduct an extensive review. According to the report, officials will inspect ownership documents, land-use permits, construction approvals and licenses governing commercial activities.
Thai officials emphasized that the investigation itself does not constitute a finding that Chabad or anyone associated with it violated the law.
Authorities also stressed that the review is not directed against any particular nationality, religion or community. Rather, they said, its purpose is to determine whether the activities being conducted and the ownership and use of the properties comply with Thai law.
Rabbi Nechemia Wilhelm, a longtime Chabad shliach in Thailand, responded by expressing confidence that the investigation would establish that Chabad’s operations are fully legal.
“We have been in Thailand for 30 years, and throughout all these years we have personally experienced the special hospitality of the Thai people, the mutual respect and the peaceful coexistence here among people of all religions and nationalities. We have always felt that we and our activities are respected, and we have great appreciation for the Thai people and the authorities of the kingdom,” Rabbi Wilhelm said.
“Our Chabad Houses are completely legal in every respect. We are very careful to abide by the laws of the country, to respect the local authorities and the citizens of Thailand, and therefore we have full confidence that the matters currently being examined will also be reviewed objectively and that everything will be found to be in order.”
The Phuket investigation comes as Chabad and Thailand’s Jewish community have also been dealing with a separate, sensitive issue involving a Jewish cemetery near Bangkok.
The cemetery had been purchased approximately five years ago by members of the Jewish community and Chabad in Bangkok. In recent months, however, difficulties arose with local authorities after officials declined to renew the cemetery’s burial license.
On Friday morning, shortly before Rosh Hashanah, Chabad representatives received a letter from the regional governor ordering them to vacate the cemetery, which contained four graves, by Tuesday.
Faced with the short deadline and the sensitive nature of relocating Jewish graves, Rabbi Wilhelm contacted ZAKA Chief Operating Officer Chaim Weingarten and requested the organization’s assistance.
Plans were made to transfer the graves to a new burial plot purchased by Rabbi Yosef Chaim Kantor, the chief rabbi of Thailand’s Jewish community.
Immediately after Shabbos, and following halachic consultations with ZAKA rabbonim, Weingarten and ZAKA volunteer Berale Yakubowitz traveled to Bangkok to assist with the operation.
A joint delegation of ZAKA representatives, Chabad rabbonim and members of the local Jewish community subsequently carried out the transfer. Participants included Rabbi Yosef Chaim Kantor, Rabbi Nechemia Wilhelm, Rabbi Eliezer Ashkenazi, Yossi Goldberg and Davidi Haddad.
After hours of painstaking and highly sensitive work, the four graves were transferred intact to their new resting place. Those involved said the operation was conducted with careful attention to kavod hameis and all relevant halachic requirements.
The investigation in Phuket is now expected to proceed separately, with Thai authorities given seven days to review the documentation surrounding Chabad of Patong and determine whether its properties and operations comply with local law.
{Matzav.com}
