Goldknopf Holocaust Analogy in Knesset Draft Debate Triggers Broad Political Backlash
Sharp reactions rippled through the Knesset on Sunday night after comments made by MK Yitzchak Goldknopf of United Torah Judaism during a heated session of the Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee focused on the proposed conscription legislation.
In the committee session, Goldknopf had addressed the sanctions included in the draft law and likened them to “a yellow star for Torah students,” a statement that immediately sparked outrage across party lines.
Opposition leader Yair Lapid responded with a deeply personal rebuke, addressing Goldknopf directly. He said that his father wore a yellow star in the Budapest ghetto because there was no Jewish army to defend him, and that his grandfather was forced to wear one before being murdered in a concentration camp. Lapid charged that the comparison trivialized the Holocaust and demeaned the sacrifice of IDF soldiers, describing the remarks as damaging and profoundly offensive.
Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich also weighed in forcefully, saying there is no place in the coalition for leaders who are “disconnected, insensitive, and who repeatedly harm Israeli society, IDF soldiers, and Torah students.” He stressed that Goldknopf is no longer part of the mainstream coalition and is not expected to return.
Smotrich added that IDF soldiers are those standing on the front lines against antisemitism and its contemporary expressions. He said the Religious Zionist camp believes it is possible to unite Torah learning with military service and is committed to showing that the chareidi public can do so as well.
Committee chairman MK Boaz Bismuth of Likud publicly distanced himself from the analogy. While expressing “great respect for Torah scholars and the chareidi community,” he said the language used “crosses a line” and has no place in such a discussion.
Diaspora Affairs Minister Amichai Chikli issued his own sharp criticism, calling the comparison a sign of extreme political detachment. He said that equating draft-related sanctions with the yellow star reflects a profound disconnect and added that the public deserves more responsible leadership, particularly on matters so sensitive to Jewish history and national unity.
{Matzav.com}
