Turmoil in Ger: Are the Chassidus’s Deepest Secrets at Risk of Being Exposed?
A dramatic crisis has erupted within Ger amid growing fears that highly personal and sensitive conversations of tens of thousands of chassidim may have been recorded — and could, in the worst-case scenario, become public.
According to a report published this morning in Haaretz, the alarm was triggered during a private din Torah in Bnei Brak, when a relative of Rav Yitzchok Broide — the Gerer Rebbe’s close personal secretary — suddenly produced an audio recording of a private conversation taken from the chassidus’s internal hotline.
That hotline is a dedicated phone line through which Gerer chassidim leave voice messages for Rav Broide, who then conveys the questions to the Rebbe. For years, this system has been relied upon by tens of thousands of families to discuss their most delicate and confidential matters, trusting that the information remained between them, Rav Broide, and the Rebbe.
According to the report, the recording was produced only after that family member lost the initial stage of the din Torah. He then hired new representatives, who claimed to possess new evidence that could overturn the ruling — the recording from the hotline. This immediately led to a terrifying possibility: that not only that one conversation was captured, but potentially every single message ever left on the hotline.
Even after an appeal, the dayanim upheld their original decision. But the revelation sent shockwaves through the chassidus, as chassidim grasped that it may be possible that all their confidential messages — matters involving family struggles, shidduchim, medical issues, and other deeply private concerns — may have been preserved somewhere without their knowledge.
Attorney Shlomo Elbaum, a member of the Bnei Brak city council, told Haaretz: “I heard about what happened in the beis din. I looked into it with reliable sources and I heard that everything is true.”
Elbaum added that, as someone who was once part of Ger and used the hotline himself for personal matters, he is deeply worried that everything may have been saved and could one day be misused. “This is a massive breach of public trust, and everyone should be shaken by it, especially since we have no idea who is the responsible party holding the recordings.”
A current Ger chossid expressed his own sense of betrayal, saying: “I feel exposed and betrayed. It shook me to my core. Rav Broide was supposed to be the greatest guardian of our secrets. We all trusted him and saw him as a faithful messenger. I hope it stays that way.”
Rav Broide himself responded that he has no knowledge of any recordings being stored:
“I don’t know anything about recordings being kept. I’m not involved in the business dealings of my relatives or what they say in beis din. Someone mentioned it to me, but I’m not involved.”
Regarding responsibility for the hotline, he said: “I am not the owner of the phone line. They gave me a phone number, and that is what I work with. I don’t know anything beyond that. In any case, no one discusses truly personal matters here — only surgeries, shidduchim, things like that. Who is responsible for the line? I have no idea. This is the first time I’m hearing that the calls may have been recorded.”
Ger’s official statement to Haaretz denied any possibility that the hotline can be recorded:
“From our internal review, there is no ability to record calls on the line in question.”
{Matzav.com}
