New York City’s finances are already underwater, with a massive shortfall looming well before any new policy agenda takes shape, the NY Post reports.
City Comptroller Mark Levine warned Friday that the city is on track to face a combined $12 billion budget deficit over the next two fiscal years, likening the severity of the situation to the financial collapse of 2008.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani seized on the bleak forecast to renew his call for higher taxes on the wealthy, even as Levine’s figures indicate that runaway spending — not weak revenue — is driving the crisis.
According to Levine, the city is confronting an “extremely unusual” $2.2 billion gap in the current 2026 fiscal year, which ends in June.
The outlook worsens dramatically in the following year. For fiscal 2027, the comptroller projected a $10.4 billion deficit — and that estimate comes before Mamdani releases his first full budget as mayor.
“This is far beyond what we saw last year and I believe in any year since the 2008 financial crisis,” Levine said during a briefing at the Municipal Building.
“We’re not going to sugarcoat this. This is a challenging budget outlook to have a mid-year gap. Again, this is quite unusual to have a gap of the scale that we’re projecting for next year,” he said.
“[It’s] something we haven’t seen outside of an economic slowdown in New York City,” Levine added. “Certainly not in an environment where we have such strong tax receipts.”
In fact, Levine noted that city tax revenues climbed by nearly 7% during fiscal year 2026, underscoring that the deficit cannot be blamed on a faltering economy.
“This wasn’t caused by a bad economy — it’s the result of budgeting decisions from the previous administration that we must now deal with,” he said.
Mamdani is expected to unveil his first mayoral budget proposal by February. His platform includes roughly $10 billion in new initiatives, such as universal child care and free bus service, proposals that rely heavily on anticipated state support funded by higher taxes on affluent individuals and corporations.
Governor Kathy Hochul, however, has repeatedly rejected the idea of raising taxes on the wealthy, even as she endorsed universal child care in her State of the State address earlier this week.
Following that speech, Mamdani publicly broke with the governor over tax policy, and he did so again after Levine released his projections.
“As I said on Tuesday, we believe raising taxes on the wealthiest New Yorkers and corporations will be necessary,” Hizzoner said in a statement Friday.
Mamdani placed responsibility for the $12 billion deficit squarely on his predecessor, accusing former Mayor Eric Adams of gross fiscal mismanagement.
The mayor also took aim at his political rival Andrew Cuomo, arguing that the former governor and Albany lawmakers routinely treated New York City as a source of cash for statewide needs.
“We have long said that what we are inheriting is not just an administration that exhibited incredible fiscal mismanagement, but also a decades-long effort from former Governor Cuomo to pilfer from city coffers at each and every turn,” he said.
“And what that has left this city with is, as described by the comptroller, not only a fiscal hole, but frankly, a relationship between city and state, where the city contributes 54.5% of the state’s tax revenues, but only receives 40.5% in return.”
Levine, who previously served as Manhattan borough president, also laid blame on the Adams administration, saying it masked financial problems by relying on one-time funding maneuvers and repeatedly underestimating actual costs.
While tax revenues have steadily increased year after year — reaching $81.4 billion in fiscal 2025 — city spending rose even faster, according to the comptroller’s review.
For years, the city has added new programs without cutting or scaling back those with lower impact, said Andrew Rein, president of the Citizens Budget Commission.
“The result is spending growth twice the rate of inflation,” Rein said in a statement. “City spending would be $14.5 billion lower today if it had tracked inflation.”
Rein noted that his organization projects a smaller — though still substantial — $8 billion gap for fiscal 2027, but said the underlying problem remains.
He argued that Mamdani’s first priority should be a comprehensive review of city programs, trimming those that fail to deliver results. Rein also urged the state to repeal costly school class-size mandates.
“It is important that New York deliver high-quality cost-effective services,” he said. “That requires making smart but tough choices—prioritizing what works and shrinking what doesn’t—before turning to the easier option of raising taxes.”
Levine’s office found that the budget crunch was exacerbated by repeated underestimates of major expenses by Adams-era officials.
For fiscal 2026 alone, the city underbudgeted $795 million for rental assistance, $727 million for employee overtime, and $630 million for homeless shelters, the comptroller reported.
In total, $3.8 billion in expenses were left out of the current year’s budget, with those costs expected to balloon in future years.
Adams spokesman Todd Shapiro pushed back, saying the former mayor inherited enormous fiscal burdens following the COVID pandemic and later absorbed billions more during the migrant crisis.
“Despite these unprecedented challenges, Mayor Adams led a historic comeback,” Shapiro said.
“Blaming Mayor Adams for long-standing structural budget gaps and fiscal pressures ignores the reality of what this administration took on and what it has delivered.”
Levine’s projections do not include the potential cost of expanding the City Fighting Homelessness and Eviction Prevention Supplement, known as CityFHEPS, a rental assistance program that Adams had opposed expanding.
The City Council overrode Adams’ veto in 2023, dramatically broadening eligibility for the program.
Depending on future court decisions, implementing the expansion could cost between $6 billion and $20 billion, according to the comptroller.
If the city’s deficit exceeds $100 million, the state’s Financial Control Board — created after New York City’s brush with bankruptcy in the 1970s — could step in.
Cuomo spokesperson Rich Azzopardi rejected Mamdani’s accusations, disputing claims that the former governor bears responsibility for the city’s fiscal woes.
“As usual, Zohran Mamdani’s claims are untethered from the facts,” Azzopardi said in a statement, pointing to increased state aid for city schools under Cuomo and noting that the state “absorbed billions in New York City Medicaid cost increases.”
“If Mamdani thinks the system is unfair, he’s had five years in office to do something about it.”
{Matzav.com}