SHACKLED LIKE A CRIMINAL: Outrage as Yeshiva Bochur Arrested Over IDF Draft Is Brought to Hospital in Handcuffs and Leg Irons
A disturbing incident involving a yeshiva bochur arrested over his failure to enlist in the IDF has sparked outrage in Eretz Yisroel after he was brought to a hospital emergency room with his hands and feet shackled, despite being in custody over a military draft violation rather than a violent offense.
The incident occurred at Hillel Yaffe Medical Center in Hadera, where the bochur was escorted by military personnel while restrained with handcuffs and leg irons. Photographs of the young man sitting in the hospital while shackled circulated widely Monday, prompting sharp criticism of the treatment being given to yeshiva students arrested amid the ongoing confrontation over chareidi military conscription.
According to a report by Channel 14 journalist Yehuda Aharoni, the incident came to light after another person waiting in the emergency room noticed the bochur being brought inside under guard.
The witness described his astonishment at seeing a visibly chareidi young man restrained in a manner generally associated with dangerous criminal suspects.
“I see a yeshiva bochur coming in, handcuffed at his hands and feet, as though he were the worst criminal,” the witness recounted.
The man said he managed to speak briefly with the bochur while they were sitting near one another, quietly asking why he had been arrested.
According to the witness, the young man explained that his arrest was connected to his status as a yeshiva student who had not reported for military service.
“He tells me that his only crime is that he learns Torah,” the witness said.
The bochur reportedly resides in Kiryat Malachi, although the witness was unable to determine which yeshiva he attends.
The conversation was cut short when the personnel accompanying the detainee noticed the exchange and moved him to another location in the hospital.
The witness said that even an Arab individual who observed the scene appeared taken aback by the sight of the handcuffed bochur and offered him words of encouragement.
“Be strong. They’re arresting you only because you learn Torah. Kol hakavod,” the man reportedly told the detainee.
The account drew considerable attention in the chareidi community, particularly because of the contrast between the nature of the alleged offense and the extensive physical restraints used while the bochur was receiving medical attention.
According to the IDF, the bochur had been taken into custody the previous Friday at the Taba border crossing, where he allegedly attempted to leave Eretz Yisroel despite an active order prohibiting his departure from the country because of his unresolved military draft status.
Following his arrest by military police, he was transferred to a military detention facility. The army said the young man requested medical attention upon arriving at the facility and was subsequently examined. Medical personnel then determined that he should be transported to the emergency department at Hillel Yaffe Medical Center.
Responding to the controversy, the IDF defended the use of restraints, maintaining that the decision had been made in accordance with established procedures and security assessments.
“The shackling was carried out in accordance with regulations, based solely on a professional decision. Security measures are determined according to the professional considerations of the detention authorities, in order to ensure the safety of the detainee and those around him,” the IDF said in a statement translated from Hebrew.
The military did not publicly identify any specific threat posed by the bochur that necessitated restraining both his hands and feet during his hospital visit.
The incident prompted the human rights organization B’Tsalmo to intervene, with its director, Shai Glick, sending an urgent letter to Defense Minister Yisrael Katz, IDF Chief of Staff Eyal Zamir, and senior military legal officials.
Glick demanded the immediate removal of the restraints and an investigation into the decision to transport and hold the bochur in the hospital while shackled.
In his letter, Glick described the incident as “cruel, humiliating and disproportionate conduct that constitutes a severe violation of the detainee’s fundamental rights and human dignity.”
He argued that the young man was being held over a military service issue and had not been accused of violence or any offense that would ordinarily warrant such extraordinary security measures.
“This is a yeshiva student who is not a criminal offender, is not accused of violent crimes, does not endanger human life, and there is no reasonable basis to fear that he would attempt to escape while lying in a hospital and requiring medical treatment,” Glick wrote.
B’Tsalmo maintained that restraining a patient with both handcuffs and leg irons should be reserved for exceptional circumstances involving serious security risks. The organization warned that the treatment of the bochur raised concerns about possible abuse of authority.
The organization called for disciplinary action against those responsible if an investigation establishes that the restraints were unjustified. It also demanded clear instructions to prevent similar incidents involving other detainees.
“If this grave injustice is not corrected immediately, we will not hesitate to act through all the legal and public means available to us,” Glick warned.
Copies of the letter were forwarded to chareidi Knesset members, the Israel Medical Association, the Knesset Health Committee, and the office of the health minister.
The Israel Medical Association’s ethical guidelines state that detainees and prisoners should ordinarily receive medical treatment without restraints and that shackling in a medical setting should be employed only when less restrictive alternatives are insufficient.
{Matzav.com}
