Bnei Brak Bais Din Rejects Peleg Yerushalmi Activists’ Petition: “Violence Must Be Handled by State Authorities”
A request filed by activists from Pelegh Yerushalmi was dismissed this week by the Bnei Brak Bais Din after the group sought to block elected officials from filing police complaints over recent incitement and threats.
The bais din’s senior dayanim made it clear in a written response that issues involving violence fall under the exclusive jurisdiction of state authorities—not a bais din.
The petition had been submitted to the Badatz of Bnei Brak, headed by Raavad Rav Yehuda Silman and Gaavad Rav Sariel Rosenberg. Activists demanded that the court prevent chareidi public representatives from going to civil courts and police over what they described as “incitement” against Members of Knesset in the lead-up to the draft law’s advancement.
In a formal letter released by the dayanim, the court firmly rejected the appeal.
“In regard to the recent rise in incidents of violence—both physical and verbal—directed at public representatives, and in response to questions as to why the bais din is not intervening, we clarify that the bais din does not deal with matters of violence, for which the proper avenue of response is through the authorities,” the letter stated.
A brief review of past rulings shows that the court based its response on a precedent issued by the bais din once led by Rav Nissim Karelitz zt”l. In that ruling, Rav Karelitz wrote unequivocally that when individuals engage in ongoing degradation of Gedolei Yisroel and the chareidi community, their conduct places them in the halachic category described in Choshen Mishpat 388:12—those who “cause distress to the public.” In such cases, Rav Karelitz ruled, it is permissible “to hand them over, imprison them, or fine them,” and therefore permitted bringing claims against them in civil courts.
Among the signatories to that earlier ruling are Rav Nissim Karelitz zt”l and Rav Dovid Zvi Ordentlich zt”l. A third signature stands out sharply in today’s context: that of Rav Zvi Friedman, a prominent figure within the Peleg Yerushalmi. He signed the ruling permitting recourse to civil courts—contradicting the faction’s present claim that the bais din must intervene to block such complaints.
Just yesterday, Shas and United Torah Judaism filed a police complaint against a senior Peleg Yerushalmi activist, Tzvi Roth, accusing him of grave incitement to violence and even hints of murder against chareidi Members of Knesset.
According to the complaint, harsh statements were broadcast on faction-affiliated phone hotlines, including comparisons to Nazis and references to physical harm and arson. Rot allegedly urged listeners “to view elected officials as enemies from within,” while discussing scenarios of attacks against them.
Chareidi parties say these statements reflect a dangerous escalation. “Recently we saw attempted lynching incidents and break-ins at the homes of MKs,” they said. “The line between protest and violence has been dangerously blurred.”
{Matzav.com}
