“We Were Shaken by the Death of Infants—So Why the Silence Here?” Lawmakers Tour Negev Amid Phosphate Mining Fight
Members of Israel’s State Comptroller Oversight Committee toured the Negev and held a professional briefing near the Sdeh Brir site, as opposition mounts to plans for phosphate mining that critics warn could endanger public health across the region.
The visit, led by committee chair Alon Schuster, followed a prior committee discussion seeking an opinion from the State Comptroller on the government’s policy regarding phosphate extraction at the site. Participating in the tour were Knesset members, leaders from Bedouin communities in the area, Arad Mayor Yair Maayan, and Arad city council members Yitzchak Gordon and Chaim Tzinterboim.
Committee members toured open areas adjacent to the proposed mining zone, observing firsthand the scale of the land involved and its proximity to residential neighborhoods and educational institutions. Following the field visit, lawmakers convened a formal committee session at the Al-Fura’a School complex, which sits near the planned mining area and operates under the authority of the Arad municipality. During the meeting, officials were presented with assessments indicating that more than 100,000 residents—including students in nearby schools—could be affected if the mining project moves forward.
The tour and hearing were conducted against the backdrop of claims raised in earlier committee deliberations that the mining plan is being advanced in contradiction to a 2022 government decision. That decision conditioned any progress on phosphate extraction on a comprehensive review of health and environmental impacts.
Schuster said the committee came to the area out of deep concern for proper governance. “In a functioning state, there must be order and responsibility,” he said. “It is unacceptable for discussions and decisions to move ahead on such a sensitive issue without thoroughly examining what it means on the ground.” He warned that the Sdeh Brir project could pose serious health and environmental risks to more than 100,000 Negev residents, citing potential dispersal of hazardous dust linked to severe respiratory illness, heart disease, and cancer, as well as the possible displacement of thousands of Bedouin residents.
Mayor Maayan, who guided the tour, emphasized what he described as genuine coexistence in the area. “Here, coexistence isn’t a slogan. It’s reality,” he said, noting that Arad was the only city to take in Bedouin residents during the war. Questioning the project’s rationale, Maayan asked why, if a mine is truly planned, no evidence has been presented to the Health Ministry proving there is no danger. “Human lives are being knowingly put at risk,” he said, adding that after failures to protect communities near Gaza, exposing more than 100,000 Arad-area residents to a proven health threat is unacceptable.
Maayan also raised concerns about the unresolved status of the Al-Fura’a community, saying its location has yet to be finalized. He called for immediate advancement of planning procedures for the settlement, noting that while the Education Ministry budgeted for a permanent school within Arad’s jurisdiction, the Bedouin Authority declined. “Today there are about 15,000 people in limbo,” he said, warning that it could take two decades to establish a regulated community, during which the population could double. “So where, exactly, is there room for a mine?”
Addressing the issue, Yitzchok Goldknopf said, “All of Eretz Yisrael was shaken this week by the deaths of two infants—and rightly so. Human life comes before everything. So why here, when there is a risk of sudden loss of life and the development of a large-scale health disaster, is there silence? Why wait to talk about it only after a tragedy occurs, G-d forbid? Everyone says this place is dangerous—so how can discussions even continue?”
MK Walid Al-Huashla urged unity, warning against politicizing the struggle. “There are ministers and lawmakers who come here to inflame tensions and deepen the conflict,” he said. “The Negev belongs to all citizens—Arab and Jewish alike. The fight against phosphate mining is a shared struggle, and it must be conducted together, as we live side by side, without sowing division or hostility.”
{Matzav.com}
