“Shame on You—You’re Voting Against the Torah”: Porush Delivers Emotional Knesset Address Defending Lomdei Torah
United Torah Judaism MK Meir Porush delivered an emotional and highly unusual address in the Knesset on Monday during debate over the Basic Law on Torah Study, speaking directly to the tens of thousands of yeshiva students and kollel yungeleit across Israel. Opening his remarks in a deeply personal tone, he said, “Dear yeshiva student, dear kollel scholar, the next few minutes are dedicated to you.”
Addressing those immersed in full-time Torah study, Porush declared, “I am speaking to you, the yeshiva student who begins his day at six-thirty in the morning, and after prayer and breakfast bends over the Talmud and lectern almost continuously until eleven at night. To you, who ignores the background noise, casts aside the vanities of this world, and plunges into the sea of the Talmud. Your melody, the sound of Torah echoing through the halls of the yeshivas—they are the heartbeat of the Jewish people.”
He then turned to the thousands of kollel scholars who devote themselves to Torah despite financial hardship. “I am speaking to you, the kollel scholar who survives on just a few shekels, living far below the poverty line. To you and your family—to your devoted wife, who carries the burden of the home and earning a livelihood so that you can continue occupying your place in the study hall. You who sacrifice yourselves to learn Torah despite deprivation, living on bread with salt and measured amounts of water, seeking neither fame nor applause nor honor from anyone—except the honor of the Torah.”
Reflecting on the challenges facing Torah scholars, Porush said they have endured years of relentless attacks. “For the past three years you have been trampled. They have turned you into a punching bag. Cruel campaigns of incitement, hostility, and hatred have been directed at you, as though you, God forbid, are the problem facing the country rather than the secret to its existence.” He continued, “They are trying to break your spirit. They pursue you and arrest you in the streets, impose economic decrees upon you, and label those who uphold the world as ‘draft dodgers.’”
Porush stressed, however, that the value of Torah study does not depend on government recognition. “The truth is that you do not need the recognition of the Knesset. The holy Torah survived empires, kingdoms, and decrees long before this building was established, and it will endure forever. It is not the Knesset that gives validity to the Torah. Rather, it is the Torah that grants this nation its right to exist and its right to the Land of Israel.”
Nevertheless, he described the legislation as an important public declaration. “Still, something unusual is happening today. A majority of Knesset members are standing up and declaring clearly that Torah study is a foundational value of the heritage of the Jewish people,” he said. “Today the Knesset is doing itself a favor by acknowledging that it is the Torah that has safeguarded the Jewish nation throughout the generations.”
Porush explained that while the importance of Torah should be self-evident, today’s political climate has made such legislation necessary. “Unfortunately, even what should be obvious sometimes requires reinforcement. In a generation of confusion, when there are those trying to disconnect a person from the source of his spiritual life, this law tells every kollel scholar and every yeshiva student: You, who sit and learn, are performing the greatest and most important act for the eternity of the Jewish people.”
In the closing moments of his address, Porush sharply rebuked opposition lawmakers preparing to vote against the bill. “Shame on you. Hatred has blinded your eyes. Even the military’s professional Shakedi Committee, which was established after the horrific October 7 massacre, acknowledges the obvious.”
Quoting from the committee’s findings, he said, “Protecting the core values of the haredi world means protecting Torah scholars whose full-time occupation is Torah study (those who study three daily sessions).”
He concluded with a forceful condemnation of the opposition: “What the army understands out of genuine and existential necessity, you refuse to understand because of cheap populism. Today you are not voting against the coalition—you are voting against the holy Torah. Shame on you.”
Monday marked the opening of a five-day legislative marathon in the Knesset, with the Basic Law on Torah Study becoming the first major bill to come before the full chamber. At the same time, the coalition is advancing legislation that would freeze the arrest orders issued against yeshiva students.
{Matzav.com}
