OCTOBER 7 OUTRAGE: Mamdani Doubles Down on Israel Genocide Accusations as Jewish Leaders Condemn His Anniversary Statement
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani on Thursday refused to retreat from his controversial remarks marking the third anniversary of the October 7 Hamas massacre, repeating accusations that Israel is committing genocide in Gaza and defending a statement that drew sharp condemnation from Israeli officials and Jewish leaders.
During a press conference, Mamdani invoked the genocide allegation six times while addressing criticism of his October 7 anniversary message, which acknowledged the Hamas terrorist attack and the murder of more than 1,100 Israelis but devoted considerable attention to accusations against Israel involving genocide, apartheid and war crimes.
The mayor also defended his appearance Wednesday evening at a memorial gathering for victims of the conflict, where anti-Zionist demonstrators confronted him and called him a “traitor.”
“I was proud to attend last night’s vigil, as I did last year, to listen to testimonies of family members of those who were killed,” Mamdani said Thursday.
“As for those protesting me, I am the mayor of New York City and this is what I signed up for,” he added.
Turning to the controversy over his anniversary statement, Mamdani described the October 7 massacre as “unthinkable devastation” before again accusing the Israeli government of using the terrorist attack to justify its military operations in Gaza.
He alleged that “the Israeli government used and continues to use that day, those war crimes as a justification for an ongoing genocide.”
Mamdani maintained that the suffering of Israelis murdered by Hamas and Palestinians killed during the subsequent war should both be recognized.
“There must be room to mourn the lives of the more than 1,100 Israelis that Hamas killed three years ago. There must be room to mourn the 74,000 Palestinians the Israeli government has killed since,” he stated.
The Palestinian casualty figure cited by Mamdani was presented without distinguishing between civilians and terrorists killed during the fighting.
The mayor insisted that his public statement and participation in the vigil reflected the continuing impact of the conflict on New Yorkers.
“The statement, the attendance, it all speaks to a reckoning with horror and a horror that devastated the lives of New Yorkers three years ago and it also continues to devastate New Yorkers today,” Mamdani added.
His refusal to withdraw the accusations came after a wave of criticism over his original October 7 message, with Israeli representatives and Jewish officials accusing him of exploiting the anniversary of the Hamas atrocities to advance allegations against Israel.
Among the most forceful responses came from Israel’s ambassador to the United States, Yechiel Leiter, whose son Neria is recovering in the hospital from critical injuries suffered in a terrorist vehicle-ramming attack.
“It’s actually hard to find a sentence in Mamdani’s post that isn’t a lie,” Leiter wrote in response to the mayor’s statement.
Leiter argued that Mamdani’s account distorted the circumstances of the war and failed to acknowledge the full extent of Hamas’s responsibility for the atrocities that began the conflict.
“Let’s be clear: the only attempted genocide in this conflict was perpetrated by the barbarians he supports, Hamas, who butchered, raped, and murdered in the most horrific ways imaginable,” Leiter stated.
The ambassador also rejected the mayor’s characterization of Israeli military operations and accused Hamas of deliberately placing Palestinian civilians in danger while diverting humanitarian supplies intended for Gaza residents.
“There is no genocide, ethnic cleansing, or famine in Gaza. Hamas embeds itself among, behind, and beneath the people of Gaza, knowing that the IDF will not, ever, intentionally target civilians. It robs its own people of the humanitarian aid that Israel has facilitated into Gaza since the war began.”
The dispute has renewed scrutiny of Mamdani’s longstanding positions on Israel, which became a central source of controversy during his campaign for mayor and have continued to generate criticism since he took office.
On October 8, 2023, just one day after Hamas terrorists invaded southern Israel, murdered civilians and abducted hostages, Mamdani issued remarks that drew criticism for focusing on Israeli policies rather than unequivocally condemning the massacre.
His refusal during the mayoral campaign to condemn the slogan “globalize the intifada” also provoked concern among Jewish organizations and elected officials, who argued that the phrase invokes violence against Jews and Israelis.
Mamdani has defended his positions as expressions of support for Palestinian rights, while critics have accused him of applying a double standard to Israel and failing to adequately address the fears of Jewish New Yorkers.
Those tensions intensified after he entered City Hall.
On his first day as mayor, Mamdani rescinded several executive orders issued by his predecessor, Eric Adams, including measures relating to Israel.
He subsequently became the first New York City mayor to boycott the annual Israel Day Parade, breaking with a longstanding tradition of mayoral participation in the major public celebration of support for Israel.
The mayor also drew criticism during his campaign when he pledged that the New York Police Department would arrest Israeli Prime Minister Bibi Netanyahu if he visited New York, citing an arrest warrant issued by the International Criminal Court.
Following a legal examination conducted by his administration, however, Mamdani acknowledged that New York City lacks independent authority to enforce the international court’s warrant.
{Matzav.com}
