“I’LL DO EVERYTHING TO AVOID THE ARMY”: French-Born Yeshiva Bochur Barred From Visiting Parents Refuses to Compromise on Draft
A chareidi yeshiva bochur who moved to Eretz Yisroel from France at the age of 13 says he has been unable to see his parents for an entire year because of restrictions imposed on him over his military draft status, but insists that he will not compromise on his commitment to remaining within the yeshiva world.
In an interview conducted on the streets of Yerushalayim by photographer Shlomi Cohen, the young man, identified as Rafael, described the personal hardships he has endured since being classified by Israeli authorities as a military draft evader.
Rafael explained that his designation has prevented him from leaving Israel, while his parents, who live abroad, are unable to travel to visit him.
“I haven’t seen my parents for an entire year because of the draft law,” Rafael said. “They cannot come here, and they won’t give me permission to travel abroad to see them.”
Despite the painful separation from his family, Rafael said he has no regrets about his refusal to enlist.
Asked how he feels about being officially classified as a draft evader in Israel, he responded that he takes pride in maintaining his position.
“I’m proud of it,” he said. “It feels good knowing that I’m doing what I need to do, but it feels less good when you see how our own people are behaving.”
The interview comes amid growing controversy over the status of thousands of chareidi yeshiva bochurim who face military enforcement measures as Israeli political leaders attempt to negotiate a new arrangement governing military service.
One proposal being discussed in political circles would distinguish between full-time yeshiva students, who would continue receiving exemptions or deferments, and young men who study only part of the day or combine learning with employment, who could be required to enlist.
Rafael, who acknowledged maintaining a more flexible daily learning schedule, firmly rejected such an arrangement, arguing that young men who remain connected to a yeshiva environment should not be forced into military service simply because they are not learning throughout the entire day.
“I don’t agree with that,” he said. “Once a person keeps himself within a yeshiva framework, even if he learns for an hour or two a day and puts on tefillin while davening with a minyan, once he goes into the army, the army will bring him down to places that the rabbonim have forbidden us to go.”
He maintained that the issue extends beyond the number of hours a young man spends learning each day. In his view, remaining within a Torah environment provides essential spiritual protection, and removing a bochur from that framework could jeopardize his religious observance.
“All they want from us is to continue learning and maintain our framework,” Rafael explained. “When a bochur succeeds in controlling himself and maintaining boundaries, that is where he needs to remain. I will do everything not to go to the army.”
The young man also rejected suggestions that specialized military programs designed for chareidi recruits, including the IDF’s Chashmonaim track, could provide an acceptable alternative.
Rafael said he had personally consulted rabbonim about those programs and was advised against participating.
“I asked rabbonim, and they told me that it is not suitable and not right to go there,” he said. “I don’t rely on my own ’emunah’ that I won’t fall, because the yetzer hara is strong and can bring anyone down. Therefore, my obligation is to remain in a place that protects me.”
{Matzav.com}
