“Four-Finger” Emergency Signal to Debut at Satmar Event, Sparking Debate Over Effectiveness
A new safety method aimed at improving emergency response at large-scale gatherings in the United States is set to be rolled out at a major Satmar event, prompting discussion over whether it is a smart innovation or a formula for confusion.
The initiative is being introduced ahead of the massive maamad hachnasas sefer Torah of the Satmar Rebbe, Rav Zalman Leib Teitelbaum, scheduled for Lag BaOmer in Williamsburg and expected to draw tens of thousands of participants. At a special planning session for community organizers, one of the speakers, Reb Eizik Daskal, presented the idea and explained the reasoning behind it.
He noted that at crowded events, due to the noise and density of the crowd, Hatzolah volunteers often have difficulty hearing radio communications and then locating the exact site of an emergency, which can delay critical response times.
To address this issue, organizers, in coordination with emergency services, proposed a simple but effective solution: a uniform signal of raising four fingers during an emergency. Once noticed, others nearby repeat the gesture, forming a rapid “human chain” that visually guides responders to the exact location within seconds — without the need for shouting or radio contact.
The concept has quickly become a major talking point in the American chassidishe community, with organizers stating that “four fingers” will now be the standard signal at large gatherings. While the idea has been welcomed in the United States, some emergency personnel in Israel have raised concerns, warning that such a system could create confusion. They argue that if too many people lift their hands at once, it may be difficult to pinpoint where the incident is actually taking place.
A source within Brooklyn emergency services responded to those concerns, explaining to Matzav.com: “First of all, emergency volunteers are already positioned in multiple locations throughout the event, so the human chains are designed to remain localized and focused. In many cases, it involves no more than about 20 people raising their hands. Secondly, as the responders move closer to the scene, the chain gradually narrows until it converges on the exact location of the incident itself.”
It was also noted that on the same day, the traditional hadlakah of the Satmar Rebbe, Rav Aharon Teitelbaim, will take place in Kiryas Joel. However, the new system will not be implemented there at this stage, since that event draws a broader and more mixed crowd, including thousands who are not part of the chassidus, making it more difficult to introduce and standardize the method at this point.
{Matzav.com}