High Court Demands Answers on Enforcement in Chareidi School Networks; Gafni: “Hatred and Envy”
Israel’s High Court of Justice on Tuesday issued a conditional order requiring the state to explain within two months why it continues to fully fund chareidi schools that do not teach the complete core curriculum as required by law, and why it has not imposed sanctions or taken corrective action, including budget cuts for noncompliant institutions.
The order was issued in response to a petition filed in March 2025 by the Chiddush association, which called on the government to enforce mandatory core studies and apply financial penalties to schools in education networks affiliated with chareidi political parties.
During court hearings on the petition, significant deficiencies were revealed regarding implementation of the core curriculum in the chareidi networks. At a hearing held in January, a state representative acknowledged substantial gaps, including shortcomings in teacher training, institutional reporting, and non-participation in Meitzav standardized testing. It also emerged that the Education Ministry did not attend that hearing and failed to provide requested data.
Subsequently, and following a directive from the court, official data was disclosed for the first time indicating that 92 percent of schools in chareidi networks lack teachers trained to deliver the core curriculum at a level that meets regulatory standards. The findings further showed that the Education Ministry does not require these institutions to provide the full number of core-study hours mandated in state schools, and that most teachers in the networks do not hold academic degrees, despite receiving salaries accordingly.
The panel of justices — Daphne Barak-Erez, David Mintz, and Ruth Ronen — demanded that the Education Ministry clarify why, in light of these findings, it continues to fully fund the institutions; why it does not require the full core curriculum hours; why teacher training has not been properly regulated; why oversight relies largely on self-reporting and pre-coordinated visits; and why most schools do not participate in Meitzav exams or international assessments that evaluate student performance in core subjects.
The case also follows directives issued in September 2024 by Deputy Attorney General Avital Sompolinsky, who instructed the Education Ministry to tighten enforcement, strengthen supervision and oversight mechanisms, train teachers, and consider budget reductions where necessary. According to the petitioners, those directives were not implemented, prompting the current petition.
Degel HaTorah chairman Moshe Gafni responded sharply to the court’s order, stating: “It is clear to anyone with understanding the hatred of the High Court judges toward the chareidi public and chareidi education. Most of the students in the networks, the majority of whom are girls, study all subjects in the spirit of our forefathers and they are the most outstanding in the exams.”
“There is no logic in issuing orders against the chareidi networks, which as stated are the best in the education system. There is only one professional explanation — hatred and envy. Nothing more!”
{Matzav.com}
