ZINGING ZOHRAN: Netanyahu Tears Into Mamdani at UN: ‘You Can’t Silence Me — You Can’t Silence the Truth’
[Video below.] Israeli Prime Minister Binyomin Netanyahu used the world stage at the United Nations on Thursday to deliver a blistering attack on New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani, accusing the mayor of spreading falsehoods about Israel, contributing to an atmosphere in which Jews feel increasingly unsafe in New York, and attempting to silence the Israeli leader during his visit to the city.
The extraordinary confrontation came during Netanyahu’s address to the UN General Assembly, where the Israeli prime minister devoted a significant portion of his speech to Mamdani, who has repeatedly accused Israel of genocide in Gaza, called Netanyahu a war criminal and previously campaigned on a pledge to have him arrested if he came to New York. Mamdani subsequently acknowledged that New York City does not have the legal authority to carry out such an arrest.
Netanyahu began the section while rejecting accusations that Israel committed genocide during its war against Hamas.
“To all those that are spreading these lies about my country and about our brave soldiers, whether they sit in this hall or in the office of the antisemitic mayor of New York, I say this: Shame on you. Shame on you for distorting the facts. Shame on you for inverting victim and aggressor. Shame on you for spitting in the face of truth.”
Netanyahu then addressed Mamdani directly by name.
“Mr. Mamdani, since you were elected mayor of this city, many Jews no longer feel safe in New York. They talk to me. They tell me: ‘This isn’t the city we remember. It changed so quickly.’”
Netanyahu’s charge that Mamdani has made Jewish New Yorkers less safe was an accusation by the prime minister, not an independently established finding. Local coverage of the speech similarly reported that Netanyahu blamed Mamdani for worsening the climate confronting Jews in the city.
Netanyahu then laid out a series of allegations against Mamdani and people with whom the mayor has associated.
“It’s no wonder. You praise criminals convicted of supporting Hamas. You count as friends people like Hasan Piker, who said America deserved 9/11. Some friends you have.”
Netanyahu continued:
“You invite into your home a Palestinian journalist who filmed Hamas terrorists beating and torturing Israeli hostages and later admitted that he refused to publish the videos in order to protect – you guessed it – the terrorists. Your wife liked a post praising the October 7th massacre. She liked another post saying Tel Aviv shouldn’t exist. You refused to condemn any of that. You falsely and repeatedly accuse Israel of genocide.”
Those were allegations made by Netanyahu in the course of his political attack on Mamdani; they should not be read as independently adjudicated findings about the mayor or his associates. Reuters, while reporting Netanyahu’s broad attack, specifically characterized his allegation that Mamdani supports Hamas as false.
Netanyahu then turned to Mamdani’s efforts to oppose his presence in New York.
“Mr Mamdani, you tried to stop me from coming here. You tried to silence me. Well, you can’t silence me; you can’t silence the truth.”
The remarks capped several days of increasingly bitter exchanges between the two men.
Before Netanyahu arrived in New York, Mamdani again described the Israeli prime minister as a “war criminal” and “the architect of a horrific genocide against Palestinians.” Netanyahu rejects both the genocide accusation and the war-crimes allegations against him.
Netanyahu had responded even before leaving for the United States, releasing a video promising to confront Mamdani from the UN podium.
“Shame on you for inciting riots against New York Jews. I’m coming to the U.N. I’m going to tell the truth about our heroic soldiers, and I’m going to tell the truth about you,” Netanyahu said in that video.
Mamdani fired back at the time, saying Netanyahu’s accusations were untrue and repeating his own allegations against the Israeli leader.
“Well, we all know that what the prime minister said in that video is not true,” Mamdani said. “What we do know to actually be the truth when it comes to the prime minister is that he is the subject of an International Criminal Court warrant for alleged war crimes and crimes against humanity. And as the prime minister, he is the architect of the horrific genocide against Palestinians.”
The ICC issued arrest warrants for Netanyahu and then-Defense Minister Yoav Gallant in November 2024, alleging war crimes and crimes against humanity connected to the Gaza war. Israel rejects the allegations and disputes the ICC’s jurisdiction.
At the UN on Thursday, Netanyahu directly linked the dispute with Mamdani to his broader argument that Israel has been falsely portrayed as the aggressor since the October 7 Hamas massacre.
“Here’s a simple truth. Israel didn’t commit genocide; Israel prevented genocide,” Netanyahu declared.
He then took his attack on Mamdani considerably further.
“That’s exactly what Mr. Mamdani’s Hamas buddies would have done to us had we not stopped them. They would have killed every last one of us.”
Netanyahu argued that the rhetoric surrounding Israel is not confined to diplomatic or political debate, but contributes to antisemitism and physical threats against Jews.
He warned Mamdani that “the lies you and other antisemites spread about the Jews and the Jewish State have real consequences.”
“In New York, Jews are threatened on the way to synagogue. Jews have been stabbed in the streets. Jews are demonized, targeted simply for being Jews.”
Netanyahu then broadened the argument beyond New York, citing antisemitic attacks against Jews in a number of cities around the world.
“Jews have been murdered in Sydney, Manchester, Montreal, Boulder, Colorado. They’ve been attacked in Los Angeles, London, Paris, Berlin, Washington DC.”
“The antisemites of the world want to terrify our people,” Netanyahu continued. “I have news for them. The days when Jews were defenseless victims, marched to the slaughter – those days are over.”
The attack on Mamdani was particularly striking because Netanyahu delivered it from UN headquarters in Mamdani’s own city, during the prime minister’s first New York visit since Mamdani became mayor in January. Reuters described the dispute as one of the major themes of Netanyahu’s appearance and reported that the prime minister used his speech to directly confront Mamdani over the mayor’s rhetoric about Israel and Netanyahu.
Mamdani had campaigned on a promise to seek Netanyahu’s arrest if the Israeli prime minister entered New York, citing the ICC warrant. He later acknowledged that he had determined that a New York mayor lacks the legal authority to execute such a warrant, though he has continued urging federal authorities to act against Netanyahu.
The mayor has also continued to describe Israel’s conduct in Gaza as genocide, a characterization Netanyahu forcefully rejected throughout Thursday’s speech.
Netanyahu’s message to Mamdani ultimately became part of his larger argument that Israel will no longer accept what he views as the demonization of the Jewish state without responding publicly and forcefully.
This time, standing just miles from City Hall, Netanyahu made the confrontation personal.
“Mr Mamdani, you tried to stop me from coming here. You tried to silence me,” Netanyahu said.
“Well, you can’t silence me; you can’t silence the truth.”
WATCH:
{Matzav.com}
