Dispute Over Elad Yeshiva Escalates as Building Is Seized; ‘Hakol Hachodosh’ Winner Briefly Detained
A municipal enforcement operation in the city of Elad on Thursday led to the seizure and removal of the main beis medrash of a long-operating yeshiva, during which Elchanan Inbal—winner of the “Hakol Hachodosh (The New Voice)” competition and son of the yeshiva’s rosh yeshiva—was briefly detained.
In an interview with Emes News, Inbal described what unfolded at the scene and accused the Elad municipality of heavy-handed, one-sided conduct and a lack of dialogue. He said the institution is a small yeshiva ketanah with a dormitory that has been operating in the city for nearly nine years and currently serves about 40 students. “This is the yeshiva of my father, Rabbi Yaron Inbal, who has been active in Elad for 25 years as a mechanech and community leader. For two years we’ve been trying to speak with the municipality, to meet and reach an arrangement, and they simply ignore us,” he said.
According to Inbal, the yeshiva followed accepted procedures over the years and submitted requests for formalization in the past. “We submitted a first request, a second request—the process was moving forward. Since the new mayor took office, nothing has moved. No one in the complex received permits, but for some reason they chose to act only against us.”
He added that the compound includes five other yeshivos and additional mosdos, some of them significantly larger. “There are six yeshivos there, some with hundreds of students. Each occupies four to six dunams. If this is really about a road alignment, why act against only one yeshiva?”
Municipal officials, for their part, said the issue involved the placement of structures without an authorized allocation and an encroachment on land designated for infrastructure. Inbal rejected that claim. “They’ve been talking about this road for ten years. If they want to regulate it, talk to us. Come and say: You have an alternative plot. There’s a solution. But they don’t talk. They just demolish.”
During the operation, the yeshiva’s central beis medrash—an edifice that Inbal said had stood on the site for about two years—was seized and removed. “It was a proper, well-invested, beautiful beis medrash. That was taken entirely. The other structures—trailers used as a dining hall, classrooms, kitchen, and restrooms—have remained for now,” he said.
Regarding his detention, Inbal said, “I was detained while trying to stop the demolition. In the end I was released, and I was told, ‘אשריך שנתפסת על דברי תורה – Blessed are you for being seized over matters of Torah.’ They understood there was no criminal offense here.”
Looking ahead, Inbal said no final decision has yet been communicated by the municipality and expressed hope for a change in approach. “We hope the Elad municipality will come to its senses and choose dialogue over force. This is a place of Torah, students, an entire community. It’s not something you erase with a truck.”
In a statement responding to residents’ inquiries, the Elad municipality said: “The removal activity currently being carried out in the area of the Maran Road exit is intended to clear a structure that was placed there illegally. The structure blocks the planned route of the city’s new exit road, and its removal is necessary to begin paving work expected to start soon for the benefit of residents. It is important to clarify: this is not an evacuation of a yeshiva.”
{Matzav.com}
