MAMDANI’S NY: Mayor’s Lazy Response To Two NYPD Shootings Draws Blowback, Including from an Angry Commish Tisch
Mayor Zohran Mamdani is already drawing criticism over what sources describe as a delayed and lukewarm reaction to two police-involved shootings in one night — a response that has also sparked tension with NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch, The NY Post reports.
Despite being briefed by Tisch shortly after each incident Thursday — which occurred about six hours apart — Mamdani waited roughly 16 hours before issuing a public statement. The delay stood out given that he had retreated from his earlier “defund the police” rhetoric during the mayoral campaign.
When the statement finally appeared Friday morning, it further inflamed anger inside the department by highlighting that an “internal investigation” would take place — language some police officials felt subtly suggested misconduct, even though such reviews are standard procedure.
“I know many are eager for answers,” Mamdani wrote on X. “The NYPD is conducting an internal investigation — I will work with Commissioner Tisch to ensure this is as thorough and swift as possible.”
Multiple sources said Tisch appeared visibly upset later Friday morning and was seen striding out of City Hall following a meeting with administration officials, as Mamdani was fielding questions from reporters about his slow response.
“I take it very seriously the language that I use, and I think that in a situation such as this, you have to be very intentional in what you share,” Mamdani said later at an unrelated appearance at Brooklyn College, where he distributed free tickets to the “Under the Radar” Festival ” theater festival.
Just days earlier, the mayor had rushed to the scenes of two separate five-alarm fires — one in Queens and another in The Bronx — delivering on-the-ground updates alongside FDNY leaders.
But Mamdani did not appear at either of Thursday’s violent emergencies. The first unfolded shortly before 5:30 p.m. at Brooklyn Methodist Hospital, where a blood-soaked man armed with a broken piece of a toilet barricaded himself inside an eighth-floor room with an elderly patient and a security guard.
Police said officers repeatedly deployed Tasers against the suspect — identified as Michael Lynch, 62, a former NYPD officer who left the force in the 1990s — during a tense standoff in the blood-splattered room.
When the stun devices failed to stop Lynch, officers fired their weapons, authorities said. Lynch was later pronounced dead.
The second shooting happened around 11 p.m., when officers patrolling Manhattan were flagged down at what appeared to be a road rage confrontation.
According to officials, a man later identified by sources as 37-year-old Dmitry Zass exited a BMW and appeared to be holding a gun.
Police opened fire, striking Zass, who was pronounced dead at a nearby hospital.
Investigators later determined that the weapon Zass was holding was a replica Sig Sauer handgun, according to an image released by the NYPD.
Sources said Zass’ parents had called 911 earlier, reporting that he was attacking his father with a gun. They also obtained an order of protection against him earlier the same day, according to those sources.
Details of both shootings were known to Mamdani for hours before he posted his statement on X at 9:44 a.m.
“Last night’s shootings at Brooklyn Methodist Hospital and in the West Village are devastating to all New Yorkers,” he wrote, without noting that one individual was violently out of control after multiple Taser deployments and that the other appeared to be brandishing a realistic-looking firearm.
He then added: “I know many are eager for answers. The NYPD is conducting an internal investigation — I will work with Commissioner Tisch to ensure this is as thorough and swift as possible.
“These tragedies are painful, whether they take place steps from our home or miles away. They are a reminder of the immense work that must be done to deliver genuine public safety — work Commissioner Tisch and I are undertaking together every day,” Mamdani concluded, offering no explicit words of support for the officers involved.
Sources familiar with the day’s events criticized the mayor’s vague and delayed messaging, noting that NYPD leadership had been in constant communication with City Hall — including Mamdani, First Deputy Mayor Dean Fuleihan, senior staff, and the communications team — sharing real-time updates, images, and briefings.
One source said Mamdani’s reference to “genuine public safety” was baffling.
“I don’t know what else would be ‘genuine public safety’ other than protecting an elderly patient and a security guard from a person with a sharp weapon,” the source said.
The mayor’s emphasis on an internal investigation also puzzled law enforcement officials, who said such reviews are routine in officer-involved shootings.
“When the NYPD holds a press conference for an officer involved shooting, we always provide preliminary information to make clear that the Force Investigation Division will be handling the investigation,” an NYPD spokesperson said. “FID always investigates these incidents and we always state this.”
Tisch’s own public comments later Friday were viewed by some as an indirect rebuke of Mamdani’s response, as she focused squarely on the officers’ actions and courage.
“Officers were engaged in two police-involved shootings, and there is every indication that their actions were nothing short of heroic,” she posted on X at noon, shortly after her City Hall meeting.
While several sources described Tisch as visibly angry as she left City Hall, another person who saw her afterward said she did not appear upset.
The controversy erupted just eight days into Mamdani’s term and quickly prompted comparisons to early clashes between the NYPD and one of his favorite former mayors, Bill de Blasio.
“Week two and Mamdani has already betrayed the cops, this is his de Blasio moment,” a former City Hall staffer said.
Meanwhile, the state Attorney General’s Office of Special Investigation announced it would review the road rage shooting, noting that it “assesses every incident” in which police actions may have resulted in a death.
{Matzav.com}
