Rav Dov Landau, Rav Moshe Hillel Hirsch Issue Sharp Letter Against Musical Selichos Events
Leading gedolim, headed by Rav Dov Landau and Rav Moshe Hillel Hirsch, have issued a strongly worded letter opposing the growing practice of holding musical Selichos events, calling on the public not to attend such gatherings and urging municipal and government authorities not to fund or support them.
The letter, released ahead of the Yemei Hadin, is addressed broadly to the yirei Hashem and carries the heading “Zochalim v’ro’adim miyom bo’echa” — “Trembling and quaking at the day of Your arrival.”
The gedolim say that musical Selichos gatherings, which have become increasingly prevalent in recent years, undermine the fundamental purpose and atmosphere of the days leading up to Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur.
“On the eve of the Days of Judgment 5786,” the letter begins, before addressing what the gedolim describe as a troubling development: “Recently, an inappropriate phenomenon has begun in which ‘Selichos events’ are held with musical instruments. These Selichos events are contrary to the entire elevated nature of the days of Selichos established by Chazal for repentance, regret and self-examination, to purify and sanctify oneself in preparation for the coming Days of Judgment, and to merit being inscribed and sealed for a good life and peace.”
The letter warns against transforming the solemn institution of Selichos into a form of entertainment and says that such gatherings can also lead to serious problems involving standards of kedushah and tznius.
“G-d forbid that an exalted and sacred concept established by Chazal should be transformed into an entertainment event and musical performance, aside from the serious breaches of sanctity and modesty that accompany these events.”
The gedolim then issue a clear directive to the public, invoking earlier warnings issued by leading Torah authorities.
“Therefore, we hereby join and strengthen that which the Gedolei Yisrael, zt”l and shlit”a, have warned, that one should, G-d forbid, not participate in such events.”
The letter also directs an explicit appeal to government and municipal officials, urging them “not to support or fund these events through the authorities or in any manner whatsoever.”
Particular emphasis is placed on protecting the sanctity of shuls and batei medrash. The letter states: “And certainly such events should not be held in the sanctuaries of Hashem, the miniature sanctuary, synagogues and study halls. Likewise, prayers and Hallel should not be held accompanied by musical instruments.”
Concluding with a bracha that the Jewish people remain faithful to the traditions handed down through the generations, the gedolim write: “And may Hashem elevate us higher and higher to adhere to the tradition of our fathers, and inscribe us and seal us for a good life.”
{Matzav.com}
