CONFUSION: IDF Statement Contradicts Netanyahu’s Policy on Hostages
IDF Spokesperson Brigadier General Effie Defrin delivered a public briefing Monday evening from the Gaza border, addressing the next stage of military operations underway in the Gaza Strip.
During his remarks, Defrin emphasized that the central aim of the ongoing campaign is the safe return of the hostages being held by Hamas, framing this goal as inseparable from dismantling the terrorist organization—an apparent contrast to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s statement asserting the destruction of Hamas as the primary mission.
“We have a structured plan, we are making progress, and we are moving on to a new and more intensified phase of the operation in Gaza. The objective of the operation is the return of our hostages, the dismantling and decisive defeat of the Hamas regime. These are two goals that are intertwined.”
He outlined the next phase of military actions, which will involve relocating much of the civilian population of Gaza to safer zones, presumably to limit civilian casualties as operations target Hamas-controlled areas. The military campaign will be marked by sustained air assaults, targeted killings of terrorist leaders, and the destruction of Hamas infrastructure.
“The operation will include a wide-scale operation involving the movement of the majority of the Gaza Strip’s population in order to protect them in a Hamas-free zone. The operation will include continued airstrikes, elimination of terrorists, and dismantling of terrorist infrastructure. We will replicate the model implemented in Rafah in other areas of the Strip as well.”
Defrin added that a massive call-up of reserve troops is already underway, with tens of thousands of reservists being summoned to service. He acknowledged the burden placed on soldiers and their families and promised that the IDF would provide as much clarity and support as possible.
“A large-scale reserve mobilization has been carried out for the operation, we have issued call-up orders to tens of thousands of reservists. The reserve mobilization was carried out after a thorough analysis of our needs, and with a deep understanding of the strain on our personnel. We are working to provide greater clarity for our reservists, along with a tailored support system for them and their families. The reservists are the backbone of the IDF, and we honor and appreciate their contribution. We will continue to support them. The reserve mobilization at this time is difficult and complex, but it is being carried out in order to bring back our hostages, achieve a decisive outcome, and end the war.”
He accused Hamas of grossly underestimating Israel’s resolve and once again placing Gazan civilians in harm’s way. He cited recent incidents of Hamas operatives looting supplies intended for civilians, worsening the humanitarian crisis.
“Hamas misjudged – and continues to misjudge – our determination. Hamas is the one who initiated the vicious attack against us, Hamas is the one harming the Gazan population, Hamas is the one bringing destruction and devastation. Just this week, we saw Hamas looting stores and stealing food from the population. Hamas is the one starving them.”
The spokesperson stressed that the IDF would stay relentless in its pursuit of the operation’s goals and underscored that Israel is currently engaged in a multi-front conflict, requiring national unity and widespread mobilization.
“The IDF will continue to act with determination to achieve the objectives of the war. We are in a war like no other, a multi-front war with seven open fronts. We will be wherever there is an enemy, continuing to act to protect the residents and serve as a barrier between the enemy and our citizens. For this, we need the mobilization of everyone.”
Addressing the press directly, Defrin issued a pointed statement about his communication strategy, making it clear that updates would come based on necessity, not convenience.
“I will continue to speak, directly and matter-of-factly, to answer, to explain, and to reflect. I will speak to you when necessary, not when possible! We have set a principle – our actions will speak. So let our actions speak.”
Pressed by reporters about the messaging inconsistency between military and political leadership, Defrin clarified that the military’s approach aligns with the government’s directives.
“We believe that the action we are taking is the best method to implement the strategy established by the political echelon. The goals of the war are the return of the hostages and the toppling of Hamas’s rule.”
National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir, however, issued a sharp rebuke to the IDF spokesperson, emphasizing that policy decisions rest solely with elected officials and not with the military.
“IDF Spokesperson, you are once again confused to think that the army is above politicians. In a democracy, it works differently: the politicians decide, and the army executes. The top and primary goal is the downfall of Hamas, and only through that can we safely return the hostages. Failure to achieve this primary goal could lead, God forbid, to more murders and hostages in the future. This is what the politicians have decided, whether you like it or not.”
{Matzav.com Israel}