Blanche Confirmed by One Vote: Senate Hands Trump Ally Control of Justice Department
Todd Blanche won Senate confirmation as attorney general in a razor-thin vote early today, officially placing President Donald Trump’s longtime attorney at the helm of the Justice Department after months of political infighting and a contentious confirmation battle that divided even Republicans.
The Republican-controlled Senate approved Blanche by a 50-49 vote, making him the second attorney general confirmed since President Trump returned to office last year. Blanche, who had already been serving as acting attorney general, now assumes the role permanently as the administration continues pursuing its law enforcement priorities, including investigations involving Trump’s political adversaries.
Following the vote, Blanche wrote on social media that he was “deeply honored by the trust and confidence President Trump has placed in me,” adding that he was “grateful” to senators for working late to confirm him.
His confirmation followed weeks of intense debate that underscored bipartisan concerns about placing one of Trump’s closest confidants in charge of a department that has traditionally operated with independence from the White House.
Despite Republican control of the chamber, Blanche prevailed by the slimmest possible margin after Sens. Susan Collins of Maine and Lisa Murkowski of Alaska broke with their party to oppose him, joining every Democratic senator in voting against his nomination.
Blanche’s path to confirmation became unusually complicated after several Republicans objected to a controversial agreement resolving Trump’s lawsuit against the Internal Revenue Service.
To ease those concerns, Blanche formally pledged in writing that the Justice Department would scrap Trump’s proposed $1.8 billion compensation fund benefiting the president’s allies—including individuals involved in the Jan. 6, 2021 Capitol attack—and would also eliminate provisions designed to protect Trump and his family from future IRS tax audits.
Those assurances ultimately persuaded Republican Sen. Bill Cassidy to cast the decisive vote in Blanche’s favor. Cassidy argued that no other nominee would be better positioned to lead the department under Trump and suggested Blanche’s experience defending the president could actually strengthen his ability to resist inappropriate pressure from the White House.
“This is not a referendum on President Trump. It is a decision regarding Mr. Blanche in very specific circumstances,” said Cassidy, who lost his primary this year to a Trump-backed challenger.
Illinois Sen. Dick Durbin, the ranking Democrat on the Senate Judiciary Committee, urged lawmakers to reject the nomination, warning that confirming Blanche would be a “serious mistake.” He appealed to senators not to place themselves on what he called the “wrong side” of history.
“If there is ever a moment in history when we need an Attorney General above reproach, who is clearly dedicated to ending corruption, even at the highest level of our government, it’s right now,” Durbin said.
The confirmation battle revolved largely around Blanche’s close relationship with President Trump, a connection critics repeatedly argued could compromise the Justice Department’s independence.
Blanche assumed leadership of the department on an acting basis after Trump dismissed Pam Bondi in April. He quickly moved to implement several administration priorities, including accelerating investigations involving Trump’s perceived political opponents and unveiling a settlement that established a $1.8 billion “Anti-Weaponization Fund” for individuals claiming mistreatment by the criminal justice system while also providing Trump and certain family members protection from IRS audits.
That settlement nearly derailed Blanche’s nomination before he formally withdrew the compensation fund in writing following pressure from Republican Sens. John Cornyn of Texas and Thom Tillis of North Carolina. Their agreement with the Justice Department cleared the way for the Senate Judiciary Committee to advance Blanche’s nomination earlier this week.
Even after the revised agreement, several Republicans remained uneasy over both the proposed compensation fund and the tax audit protections that had been included in the original settlement.
Murkowski announced shortly before the vote that she would oppose Blanche alongside Collins, saying the nation requires an attorney general “who will check the worst impulses of this administration.”
A former federal prosecutor in New York, Blanche gained national attention as one of President Trump’s lead defense attorneys, including during the New York hush money case. He also represented Trump in the federal criminal prosecutions brought during the Biden administration, experiences Blanche has cited as firsthand evidence of what he believes was the weaponization of the justice system against the president.
Blanche joined the Justice Department last year as deputy attorney general under Bondi, overseeing daily operations while serving as the department’s public face on several major initiatives, including the release of millions of investigative documents tied to disgraced financier Jeffrey Epstein.
Democrats contend Blanche has consistently placed loyalty to President Trump above institutional independence, pointing to investigations involving Trump critics such as former FBI Director James Comey and sweeping personnel changes that have resulted in thousands of employees leaving the department through firings, resignations, and voluntary departures during the Bondi-Blanche tenure.
Supporters counter that Blanche’s background as a federal prosecutor, combined with the trust he developed with Trump during years of legal representation, makes him especially qualified to explain legal limits to the president while advancing administration priorities. Republicans have also credited him with efforts targeting violent crime, illegal immigration, drug trafficking, and transnational criminal cartels.
Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley strongly endorsed the nomination before the vote, declaring that Blanche has led the department effectively as acting attorney general. “Mr. Blanche is the right choice,” he said.
Whether Blanche will succeed where Bondi struggled remains uncertain. Trump removed Bondi after repeated resistance from judges, grand juries, and career Justice Department officials complicated efforts to pursue criminal cases against several of the president’s political opponents.
Soon after taking over the department, Blanche authorized an indictment against former FBI Director James Comey, accusing him of threatening the 47th president by posting a photograph of seashells arranged to display the numbers “86 47” on social media. Comey’s legal team has asked the court to dismiss the charges, alleging prosecutors misled the court, submitted inaccurate information, and concealed important evidence.
Blanche has also selected Joseph diGenova, a former Reagan-era Justice Department prosecutor, to oversee a Florida-based investigation examining whether former law enforcement and intelligence officials coordinated over the past decade to undermine President Trump. However, it remains unclear whether that investigation will ultimately produce criminal charges.
