More than two and a half years after the devastating collapse that shocked the neighborhoods of Meah Shearim and Bais Yisrael, the Yerushalayim District Attorney’s Office has filed an indictment against a contractor accused of causing the death of a Mir Yeshivah bochur through negligence.
The indictment, filed Tuesday, charges 49-year-old contractor Iman Hamad of eastern Yerushalayim with causing death by negligence in connection with the collapse that claimed the life of Yitzchok “Itzik” Steinberger z”l.
In a significant development, authorities have simultaneously closed the case against the property owner, concluding that there was no basis for criminal charges and fully clearing him of any wrongdoing in the tragic incident.
Construction Failures Allegedly Led to Disaster
According to the indictment, submitted by attorney Ronit Shentzer Yaakobi of the Yerushalayim District Attorney’s Office, renovation and expansion work at the aging residential structure was carried out in a dangerously negligent manner despite having received the necessary building permits.
Prosecutors allege that the contractor erected concrete forms on only one side of a newly constructed wall, while relying on the old existing wall to support the opposite side of the pour.
As a result, according to the indictment, the aging structure was unable to withstand the enormous weight and pressure of the fresh concrete. The weakened wall ultimately collapsed, sending tons of concrete and debris crashing into an adjacent room.
The tragedy occurred during the month of Teves 5784 at a building on Rechov Baal Shem Tov.
At the time of the collapse, Yitzchok Steinberger z”l, a 25-year-old talmid of Yeshivas Mir, was asleep in his bed.
The wall collapsed directly onto the room, trapping the bochur beneath the rubble.
Rescue Workers Encountered Horrific Scene
Investigators determined that massive quantities of wet concrete and construction materials poured into the room, nearly completely covering the bochur.
Hatzalah, Magen David Adom, and other emergency personnel who rushed to the scene described an exceptionally difficult rescue effort.
According to reports from the time, rescuers were forced to insert their hands into freshly poured concrete in an attempt to reach and extract Yitzchok z”l.
Despite desperate efforts by emergency crews, he suffered catastrophic head injuries and severe crushing wounds. He was later niftar from his injuries at the hospital.
Prosecution Alleges Series of Serious Safety Violations
The indictment outlines what prosecutors describe as numerous significant failures in the execution of the construction project.
Among the allegations is that the contractor failed to properly assess the load created by the concrete pour and neglected to verify whether the existing structure was capable of supporting the added pressure.
Prosecutors further claim that he failed to install proper support forms on both sides of the wall, contrary to accepted construction and engineering standards.
In addition, the indictment alleges that the entire volume of concrete was poured at once and at excessive speed, rather than in stages that would have allowed the structure to stabilize and reduced the risk of collapse.
The tragedy occurred during a complex renovation project in one of Yerushalayim’s oldest and most densely populated neighborhoods, where construction work often requires extraordinary caution due to the age and condition of the buildings.
Warnings Reportedly Issued Before Collapse
According to reports published after the disaster, local residents had raised concerns about conditions at the construction site and had reportedly contacted municipal authorities responsible for dangerous structures.
Those warnings were allegedly issued months before the collapse occurred.
Nevertheless, the work continued until the fatal accident.
The decision to indict only the contractor follows a lengthy investigation lasting more than two years. During that time, several individuals were questioned, including suspects investigated for offenses related to negligence and construction activities allegedly carried out despite concerns raised by professionals.
The case will now proceed in the Yerushalayim District Court.
The tragedy cast a pall over the broader Torah and chesed communities. Yitzchok z”l was the son of longtime ZAKA Tel Aviv volunteer Reb Simcha Steinberger and the grandson of the well-known baal chesed Reb Moshe Steinberger.
{
Matzav.com}