143 CHAREIDI DRAFT AVOIDERS RELEASED: Police Say IDF Failed to Collect Detainees as Planned Arrest Operation Is Postponed Again
A newly disclosed Israeli government document reveals that 143 individuals wanted by military authorities for failing to report for service were detained by police and subsequently released because military personnel failed to arrive to take them into custody within the required time. The disclosure comes as a major operation to arrest chareidi draft avoiders has been postponed for the second time amid disagreements between the IDF and Israel Police.
The findings emerged from an October 14 meeting chaired by Deputy Attorney General Gil Limon, whose office is preparing an update for the Israeli Supreme Court concerning enforcement of military conscription requirements among the chareidi population.
According to the document, which was circulated Monday and reported Tuesday, police recorded 143 cases between July 1 and October 12 in which individuals identified as draft avoiders were encountered during routine police activity but were ultimately allowed to leave.
Under the existing arrangement between the police and the IDF, civilian officers who encounter someone wanted by military authorities are required to contact the Military Police and wait up to 30 minutes for military personnel to arrive.
If the Military Police fail to appear within that period, the individual is released rather than transferred into military custody.
That is precisely what occurred in the 143 cases documented by police, according to the report.
The individuals were instead given notices instructing them to report to military recruitment authorities.
Representatives of the Military Police disputed the figures during the meeting, saying they were unfamiliar with the 143 cases cited by civilian police.
Limon described the number as unusually high and warned that it could indicate serious problems in the implementation of the agreement between the two law enforcement agencies.
The document instructed Israel Police to provide military authorities with details of the incidents so that the IDF could investigate the discrepancies, identify failures and determine how to prevent similar occurrences.
The agencies were ordered to provide an update by November 1.
The report also disclosed that only 14 draft avoiders were recorded as having been arrested during random encounters with police over the same three-and-a-half-month period.
The document did not fully clarify the relationship between those 14 arrests and the 143 cases in which detainees were released.
Meanwhile, a planned joint operation targeting individuals wanted for failing to report for military service has been delayed for a second time.
The operation had been scheduled for October but was postponed after Israel Police demanded that the IDF provide several hundred additional soldiers to assist with the enforcement effort.
Police officials argued that the extra personnel were necessary to manage the anticipated security challenges and public disturbances that could accompany large-scale arrests in chareidi neighborhoods.
The IDF rejected the demand, maintaining that the proposed arrangement was impractical and inconsistent with the division of responsibilities between the military and civilian police.
Military representatives insisted that the IDF is responsible for carrying out the arrests, while Israel Police must handle crowd control, public disturbances and the maintenance of public order.
Limon sided with that interpretation, stating that civilian police cannot condition their participation in enforcement operations on the deployment of hundreds of soldiers to perform policing duties.
The government document criticized the continuing delays and warned that enforcement operations could not remain suspended indefinitely.
“The situation described does not meet the state’s obligation to combat the phenomenon of draft evasion,” the document stated.
The IDF and police were instructed to develop a workable arrangement allowing coordinated arrest operations to resume, with a detailed progress report required by November 1.
Although large-scale joint operations have been delayed, the military said its police units continue conducting targeted arrests in various locations each week.
However, the government document observed that the number of arrests resulting from those activities remains limited.
The IDF said that dozens of draft avoiders had been arrested in recent weeks through targeted operations and enforcement at border crossings.
The disclosure comes amid continuing demonstrations against the arrest of yeshiva bochurim, including protests in Yerushalayim and Bnei Brak.
On Tuesday morning, five yeshiva bochurim wanted by military authorities were detained by civilian police near the Ein Zeitim junction in the Yerushalayim area.
According to Israeli media reports, Military Police personnel failed to arrive within the required half-hour period, and all five were released with instructions to report to a recruitment office.
The incident occurred on the same day that dozens of Chabad bochurim returning from New York were detained at Ben Gurion Airport over their military-service status.
The government document also raised questions about enforcement at Israel’s border crossings.
According to figures presented during an earlier meeting, more than 200 individuals wanted by military authorities were arrested during September.
In 64 cases, individuals were detained at Ben Gurion Airport upon returning to Israel after apparently leaving the country without being identified as subject to military-service enforcement.
The Population and Immigration Authority reported that those cases had been referred to police for investigation into suspected border-related violations.
Police representatives, however, said they were unaware of receiving the reports.
The conflicting accounts are expected to be examined at another meeting involving the Population Authority, the IDF and Israel Police.
Another unresolved issue concerns the criteria used to determine which individuals wanted by military authorities are arrested at border crossings and which are permitted to travel or return home.
The Deputy Attorney General’s office had previously requested a written explanation of those criteria in August, but the IDF had not yet supplied the document.
Military authorities were again instructed to provide the information before the next scheduled meeting.
The findings are expected to form part of the state’s response to the Supreme Court in proceedings concerning implementation of its ruling on chareidi military conscription.
The state is scheduled to submit its update to the court on Wednesday, October 21.
{Matzav.com}
