Bnei Brak Man Accused of Spying for Iran Alleges Prison Abuse by Israeli Jailers
Asher Binyamin W., a 25-year-old resident of Bnei Brak who is facing charges of spying for Iran, claims that he and other inmates have been subjected to abuse by the Israel Prison Service. The allegations were first reported by Army Radio.
According to W., prison guards have thrown stun grenades at inmates even when there was no disturbance taking place. He further alleges that prisoners have been beaten, forcibly restrained, ordered to kneel, and threatened by guards pointing rifles at their heads.
Israel’s High Court of Justice ruled on Sunday that W.’s petition regarding the alleged abuse should be heard by the Tel Aviv District Court.
The allegations come months after W. sought a renewed hearing on his detention, arguing that a major investigative error by the Shin Bet significantly undermined the prosecution’s case against him.
In February, approximately 15 months after his arrest and the filing of national security charges against him, W. petitioned the Tel Aviv District Court for a review of his detention. He is accused of passing information to an Iranian agent.
His defense argued that the Shin Bet made a critical error in analyzing computer data, resulting in a flawed timeline that substantially altered the evidentiary picture and ultimately led prosecutors to amend the indictment.
W.’s attorneys, Elad Ret and Noam Barkovitz of the Public Defender’s Office, contended that the evidence supporting his detention had effectively collapsed. They pointed to an incident in which W. allegedly photographed the home of a nuclear scientist near the Weizmann Institute and transmitted the images to a foreign contact. The original indictment claimed that W. knew the homeowner was a professor of nuclear physics.
According to a report by Ynet, prosecutors based that allegation on computer records indicating that W. had searched the scientist’s name on Google before taking the photographs, suggesting he knew the target’s identity in advance. The defense, however, maintained that W. consistently told investigators he had no idea who lived at the home when he took the pictures and only searched the scientist’s name after returning home. They argued that investigators dismissed his explanation without adequately examining it.
A forensic expert retained by the defense concluded that investigators failed to account for Israel’s time zone when extracting the computer data, creating a three-hour discrepancy between the actual search time and the time listed in the indictment. After correcting the timestamps, the Google search was shown to have taken place at 5:50 p.m.—after the photographs had already been taken.
As a result, Ynet reported that prosecutors amended the indictment, revised the factual allegations, and reduced the most serious charge. Instead of accusing W. of providing information to an enemy with the intent of harming Israel’s security—a crime punishable by life imprisonment—he is now charged with the lesser offense of providing information that could have benefited an enemy.
{Matzav.com}
