Netanyahu Summons Katz and Zamir Amid Escalating Public Clash
Israeli Prime Minister Bibi Netanyahu has called an urgent clarification meeting with IDF Chief of Staff Lt. Gen. Herzi Halevi and Defense Minister Yisroel Katz, following a high-profile and increasingly bitter dispute between the two senior officials.
The confrontation erupted after Katz sharply criticized Zamir over the chief of staff’s internal conclusions regarding IDF failures during the October 7 attacks. According to reporting by journalist Yaron Avraham, Katz’s office accused Zamir of basing key personnel conclusions on investigative material that, in their view, was not yet fully validated.
Sources close to the defense minister argued that the chief of staff relied on interviews and assessments they considered “unfit” to serve as the basis for personal conclusions. They further charged that Zamir had failed to thoroughly review the “Yericho Wall” contingency plan and insisted that any sanctions issued should also apply to senior officers who served prior to October 7.
According to Channel 12 News, associates of the chief of staff rejected Katz’s accusations. They said that although the minister was not notified in advance about the publication of the findings, he received the full Turjeman Committee report ahead of time. The reason he was not brought into the process directly, they claimed, was to ensure that the investigation remained free of political involvement and external pressure.
Separately, Kan News reported that Zamir fears Katz’s public criticism could have serious political repercussions, potentially even paving the way for steps to dismiss him.
The tensions escalated sharply earlier in the day when Zamir issued an extraordinary public statement responding to Katz’s remarks. He said that he learned only Monday morning—via media reports—about changes the defense minister planned to make to the review team he established upon assuming office, even as the chief of staff was leading a surprise general-staff exercise on the Golan Heights.
Zamir emphasized that the Turjeman Committee’s report was created solely for professional military use, describing it as a seven-month effort involving 12 current and former senior officers. He argued that questioning the report’s integrity was unwarranted and that a 30-day review by the Defense Ministry comptroller could not replace the depth or scope of the committee’s work.
The chief of staff also noted that one of his first decisions following the report was to order an in-depth reassessment of the “Jericho Wall” defensive plan. He stressed that the IDF is the only state body that has deeply investigated its failures surrounding the October 7 attack and taken responsibility for them. If any additional review is deemed necessary, he added, it should be conducted by an independent external commission rather than by entities tied to the political echelon.
Regarding personal recommendations made in the report, Zamir said these were internal IDF command decisions that do not require ministerial approval. He rejected suggestions that the criteria for these decisions were uneven or politically influenced.
Zamir warned that freezing IDF senior appointments for another month would damage the military’s readiness. He vowed to continue holding placement discussions as planned and to forward them to the defense minister for approval as required. He also highlighted ongoing IDF operational successes, noting that in the past 48 hours alone, the military had eliminated Hezbollah’s chief of staff and dozens of militants in Gaza.
He concluded by emphasizing that the large-scale surprise drill initiated Monday on the Golan Heights was part of the IDF’s broader effort to internalize lessons, restore readiness, and strengthen operational preparedness.
About an hour later, Katz issued a brief, restrained response, saying: “I value the chief of staff, who is well aware that he is subordinate to the prime minister, the defense minister, and the government of Israel. I do not intend to conduct a media debate. The Defense Ministry comptroller will present his findings within 30 days, and only afterward will I formulate my decisions on appointments, as required by my role and authority.”
The prime minister is expected to meet both men soon in an effort to resolve the dispute and restore calm at the top of Israel’s defense establishment.
{Matzav.com}
