Criticism of IDF Draft Policy: Claims Army Ignores Hundreds of Chareidim Seeking to Enlist While Expanding Arrests
Amid an expanding wave of arrests targeting Torah students classified as draft evaders, sharp criticism has been leveled at the IDF’s enlistment policy, with claims that the army is overlooking hundreds of chareidi men who have expressed interest in serving.
Speaking on the program “Hafuch Al Hafuch,” hosted by Rabbi Moshe Ben Loulou, commentator Kobi Segal accused the military of maintaining a gap between its public statements about manpower shortages and its actions on the ground. He argued that while enforcement against yeshiva students has intensified, the army has been slow to absorb chareidim who have volunteered to enlist.
Segal pointed to an IDF framework known as “Keilim Shluvim,” designed to integrate chareidim into driving roles in either regular or reserve service. According to him, approximately 500 chareidi men have registered for the program but remain without a concrete response. He said the pilot phase was deemed successful, yet those who signed up are still waiting. “There is a project in the IDF called ‘Keilim Shluvim’ to integrate chareidim into driving positions — about 500 soldiers who want to enlist,” Segal said, adding that in practice “they are simply waiting.”
He noted that the IDF Spokesperson’s Unit responded by saying that the candidates had registered but were not formally accepted. Segal expressed frustration that individuals actively seeking to serve remain at home without a clear explanation.
He further argued that the ongoing crisis surrounding the draft law may in some ways serve the army’s interests. “It’s good for the IDF that there is this crisis over the draft law — they show everyone that they are making arrests,” he said. The program’s host added an anecdote about a young man with a medical condition who was arrested despite, according to the account, not being eligible for enlistment in the first place. Judicial intervention was reportedly required to secure his release.
Segal summed up his position bluntly: “There are 500, and the IDF doesn’t want them — apparently it’s good for them that there is a crisis.” He said the situation highlights what he described as hypocrisy in the military’s conduct and raises serious questions.
In response, the IDF Spokesperson stated: “The ‘Keilim Shluvim’ program is a framework for training reserve personnel for driving roles in the IDF. This framework is intended for chareidi reservists while preserving their way of life. The program is part of a series of steps taken by the IDF to maximize available manpower and thereby reduce, as much as possible, the existing gap. The first pilot recently concluded, and in light of its success, it was agreed to formulate an expansion plan that will be approved in the near future by the relevant authorities. The report refers to the scope of raw potential for the program based on candidates who approached. As part of the process and in accordance with the agreed scope, responses will be provided to interested candidates who meet the required conditions.”
{Matzav.com}