LEFT-WING UPSET IN LA: ‘Los Angeles’ Mamdani’ Ousts Karen Bass as Jewish Leaders Sound Alarm Over Israel Stance
Democratic socialist Nithya Raman has defeated Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass in a stunning political upset, becoming the city’s next mayor and immediately drawing concern from Jewish organizations over her positions on Israel, the anti-Israel boycott movement, and rising antisemitism.
The Associated Press projected Raman’s victory Thursday, with the Los Angeles City Council member receiving 429,450 votes, or 52.1%, compared with 394,796 votes, or 47.9%, for Bass. With approximately 76% of ballots counted, Bass conceded the election, ending her bid for another term.
Raman, 45, has drawn comparisons to New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani because of their shared democratic socialist politics and controversial positions concerning Israel. Both have received support from the Democratic Socialists of America, reflecting the growing influence of the party’s progressive wing in major American cities.
The mayor-elect faced criticism from Jewish community leaders during the campaign, particularly following a September 29 mayoral forum at the Skirball Cultural Center. At that event, Raman defended the movement to boycott Israel, describing it as a “legitimate form of peaceful protest”. She also defended accusing Israel of “genocide” and her appearance on a program hosted by streamer Hasan Piker, who has been accused of antisemitism.
Bass took a different position at the forum, rejecting the allegation that Israel had committed “genocide” and expressing opposition to the boycott movement.
Following Raman’s election, Jewish Federation Los Angeles joined 35 Jewish organizations and congregations in congratulating the incoming mayor while pressing her to address the concerns that emerged during the campaign.
The organizations “called on her to rebuild trust with Jewish Angelenos that was strained during the campaign, starting with proactive steps against antisemitism.”
Their statement pointed specifically to Raman’s use of the term “genocide” in reference to Israel and her “ambiguous position on the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement,” saying those positions “call into question how she will prioritize the Jewish community’s most pressing concerns.”
Rabbi Noah Farkas, president and CEO of Jewish Federation Los Angeles, said Raman must take concrete steps to reassure Jewish residents that their safety and concerns will receive serious attention.
“Our community cannot accept continued rhetoric that harms Jews,” Farkas stated, according to JNS. “As mayor-elect, she has both an opportunity and a responsibility to address these issues through meaningful engagement and clear commitments.”
“Mayor-elect Raman will take office at a moment when our community is experiencing an unprecedented level of antisemitism,” he continued. “At the Jewish Los Angeles Mayoral Forum in September, she said every Angeleno deserves to feel safe, including Jewish and Israeli-Americans. We call on her to fulfill that commitment.”
Rabbi Pini Dunner, senior rabbi of Young Israel of North Beverly Hills, was considerably more critical, calling Raman “an antisemite.”
“She may not admit to it, but she is someone who has no consideration for the feelings of Jews when it comes to Israel,” Rabbi Dunner told JNS.
“She’s joined the very extreme elements of the progressive movement in its way of dealing with the issues of Oct. 7 and the war in Gaza, the war in Iran,” he said. “Everything is about pleasing her crowd, not about dealing with the real issues at hand.”
Rabbi Dunner predicted that Raman would do a “dreadful job” as mayor, adding, “It’s going to be to the detriment of all of us and of California.”
Not everyone in the Jewish community viewed the election with the same level of alarm. Mitchell Schwartz, a longtime Democratic campaign operative and founder of the Jewish Solar Challenge nonprofit, said he was less concerned about Raman’s victory, despite her statements concerning Israel.
“She did say ‘genocide,’ but I imagine she’ll stick to local issues. I can’t imagine her getting involved in Israel or things like that,” Schwartz said. “I certainly hope not.”
Schwartz also questioned the comparison between Raman and Mamdani, who has advocated arresting Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
“She’s not Mamdani.”
“I don’t believe she’s anti-Israel, but I do think she mouths some of the more silly things coming out of the Democratic Socialists of America.”
Raman’s victory was also a major rejection of Los Angeles’ Democratic establishment. Bass entered the race with support from Governor Gavin Newsom, Kamala Harris, Nancy Pelosi, and other prominent Democratic figures, but faced mounting dissatisfaction over homelessness, housing costs, and her administration’s handling of the devastating January 2025 wildfires.
Raman campaigned on promises to accelerate housing construction, reduce street homelessness by half before the 2028 Los Angeles Olympics, and overhaul aspects of city government. Her victory makes her the first challenger in more than two decades to defeat a sitting Los Angeles mayor.
In another indication of the divisions surrounding her Israel positions, the Democratic Socialists of America’s national leadership considered withdrawing its endorsement of Raman because she had not explicitly embraced a boycott of Israel. Just one day before the election, the organization’s national political committee voted 14-13 against rescinding its support.
Raman, who has previously condemned the October 7 Hamas attacks and affirmed Israel’s right to exist, has maintained that her political independence will take precedence over the demands of the socialist organization. She has also pledged to protect Jewish and Israeli-American residents of Los Angeles.
The mayor-elect is expected to take office next month, succeeding Bass as the leader of America’s second-largest city.
{Matzav.com}
