ELECTION FLOP: Chareidi Party Leader Admits Defeat After Winning Just 10,000 Votes, Vows to Return
Moti Leitner, chairman of the HaTzibur HaChareidi party, has publicly acknowledged his party’s failure in Israel’s Knesset elections, accepting personal responsibility for its disappointing showing of approximately 10,000 votes while declaring that he has no intention of abandoning his efforts to bring change to the chareidi community.
In an open letter to party activists released Thursday, Leitner admitted that his campaign had failed to translate widespread dissatisfaction with the established chareidi parties into sufficient electoral support. Although he maintained that tens of thousands of chareidim agreed with his party’s positions, many ultimately cast their ballots for non-chareidi parties rather than supporting his new political movement.
“I want to apologize. And to say thank-you. To apologize because we failed. I failed. We failed the test of results,” Leitner wrote.
“Alongside the vote of confidence from 10,000 voters, I failed to win the trust of tens of thousands of haredim who identify with our path and our message, but did not see us as their political home on Election Day and gave their votes to non-chareidi parties.
“I take responsibility for that, and we will do everything to be worthy of your trust next time.”
Leitner conceded that the campaign had made significant strategic errors, including its messaging and its failure to establish political partnerships that might have reassured potential supporters concerned about casting votes for a party unlikely to cross the electoral threshold.
“And yes, we also made mistakes. More than once,” he wrote. “There are things we could have done differently. There are messages we should have softened, sweetened, and refined, while others argue that we should have been harsher. There were alliances that could have eased the concerns of many supporters about wasting their votes.”
“We will conduct a genuine internal examination, thoroughly understand all the mistakes, as well as the major achievements we made along the way, and we will learn the lessons,” he promised.
Explaining why he had entered the political arena, Leitner said he believed longstanding problems within the chareidi community had gone unaddressed and that his campaign had been intended to force those issues into public discussion.
“I chose to take on a painful mission: to lift and shake out the rug under which we have swept some of the ills of our beloved community for decades,” he wrote.
“We brought painful discrimination to light. [And] the lack of a solution to the conscription issue, which led to the arrests of yeshiva students and the desecration of G-d’s Name that was caused,” he wrote. “We spoke openly about the disgraceful poverty that has become an ideology among us, sending hundreds of thousands of our people running between interest-free loan funds at the end of every month.”
Leitner also pointed to what he called “the humiliation of Torah scholars who dare to express a slightly different position,” and criticized what he considers insufficient preparation for parnassah among graduates of chareidi educational institutions.
His party’s positions, particularly its criticism of established chareidi leadership and institutions, generated considerable controversy during the campaign. Leitner nevertheless maintained that his movement had entered the race knowing that its objectives could not be achieved in a single election.
He expressed appreciation to those who had backed the party despite repeated warnings that their votes would be wasted, singling out its supporters, volunteers, campaign workers, fellow candidates and family members.
“To the 10,000 loyal voters who placed their trust in us despite everything: despite the pressure, despite the fears, despite everyone who said it was a waste of a ballot – you are the heart of this movement.”
The defeat was particularly striking given the expectations surrounding the party before the election. Leitner, who serves as deputy mayor of Beit Shemesh, had sought to attract chareidim dissatisfied with Shas and United Torah Judaism. His party had publicized polling suggesting that approximately 40,000 voters were already prepared to support it, with tens of thousands more considering doing so.
Instead, the party received fewer than 10,000 votes, falling far short of the 3.25% electoral threshold required to enter the Knesset. Its performance was especially weak in major chareidi communities, including Bnei Brak and Modi’in Illit, where it failed to make significant inroads among the established parties’ supporters.
Nevertheless, Leitner extended his congratulations to the successful candidates, including the representatives of the established chareidi parties whom he had challenged throughout the campaign.
“I congratulate those elected to the 26th Knesset, and foremost among them the haredi representatives, and wish them success and Divine assistance in their mission.”
He insisted that his political efforts should not be understood as a personal campaign against the existing chareidi leadership.
“Despite attempts by some to portray it otherwise, our struggle was never against anyone. It was for something. For our community, and for the entire people of Israel.”
Leitner also offered a tefillah that yeshiva bochurim be permitted to continue learning Torah without interference, alongside prayers for the safety of Israeli soldiers and security personnel.
“What we learned in the study hall, we know this morning as well: We are obligated to make the effort, and the outcome is in the hands of Heaven,” he wrote, citing the teachings of the Sages, “It is not your duty to complete the work, but neither are you free to desist from it.”
He concluded with a declaration that the election results would not bring his movement to an end.
“This journey did not end on Election Day. It has only just begun. I will yet rebuild you, and you [shall be] rebuilt. We will return.”
{Matzav.com}
