ARREST NETANYAHU: Mamdani Calls on U.S. to Join ICC, Enforce Warrant Against Israeli Prime Minister
[Video below.] New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani has renewed his call for Israeli Prime Minister Bibi Netanyahu to face arrest under an International Criminal Court warrant, saying in a newly released interview that the United States should join the ICC and enforce all of its warrants — including the one targeting Netanyahu.
Mamdani made the comments during an appearance on comedian Theo Von’s popular “This Past Weekend” podcast, where the conversation turned to Netanyahu’s recent visit to New York for the United Nations General Assembly and Mamdani’s longstanding support for enforcing the ICC warrant against him.
Mamdani had repeatedly said before taking office that Netanyahu should be arrested if he came to New York. He has since acknowledged that New York City itself does not possess the legal authority to carry out the ICC warrant and that such an action would require the federal government.
During the podcast, Mamdani explained that conclusion while making clear that his underlying position has not changed.
“If I had my say, the US government would have joined the ICC, honored every single warrant that they’ve issued.”
Earlier in the discussion, Mamdani said he believes the United States should become a member of the International Criminal Court and argued that Washington should enforce warrants issued by the tribunal. The United States is not currently a party to the ICC’s Rome Statute, and Israel also disputes the court’s jurisdiction in the case.
Mamdani presented his support for the ICC as part of a broader argument about the rule of law, saying that when governments fail to enforce international rules, the public begins questioning whether those rules have any meaning.
He pointed to international institutions established in the aftermath of World War II and argued that a lack of enforcement undermines the concept of accountability and multilateralism.
The ICC issued arrest warrants for Netanyahu and then-Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant in November 2024. The court alleged that there were reasonable grounds to believe they bore criminal responsibility for alleged war crimes and crimes against humanity in connection with the Gaza war. Netanyahu and Israel have rejected the allegations and challenged the ICC’s jurisdiction.
The warrant does not accuse Netanyahu of genocide. Mamdani, however, separately repeated his own accusation during the Theo Von interview that Netanyahu is responsible for genocide in Gaza — a characterization Netanyahu and the Israeli government emphatically reject.
Mamdani described Netanyahu as “the architect of a horrific genocide.”
The mayor also addressed the distinction between his attacks on the Israeli government and his responsibility toward New York’s enormous Jewish population. He said Jewish New Yorkers should never be held responsible for decisions made by Israel’s government.
“No Jewish person in New York City is responsible for the actions of the state of Israel,” Mamdani said.
He argued that responsibility should instead be directed toward Israeli decision-makers and toward what he described as American complicity through U.S. military assistance to Israel.
Mamdani also reiterated his position that “critique of the state of Israel, the policy actions, the genocide, that in and of itself is not antisemitic.”
His comments came shortly after his administration unveiled a citywide strategy for combating antisemitism. The plan includes measures involving security for Jewish institutions, education about Jewish history and efforts to prevent antisemitic incidents. Mamdani has sought to draw a distinction between combating hatred directed at Jews and allowing fierce criticism of Israel.
The podcast appearance also gave Mamdani an opportunity to respond at length to Netanyahu’s extraordinary attack on him from the podium of the United Nations General Assembly.
During his UN address last week, Netanyahu directly accused Mamdani of spreading falsehoods about Israel and contributing to an atmosphere in which Jewish New Yorkers feel increasingly unsafe. He called Mamdani “the antisemitic mayor of New York” and accused him of inverting the roles of aggressor and victim in describing the Gaza war.
Netanyahu had previewed the confrontation before arriving in New York, declaring, “Shame on you, Mr. Mamdani,” while sharply criticizing the mayor’s positions on Israel and Hamas. Mamdani has rejected allegations that he supports Hamas.
Mamdani said he learned about Netanyahu’s remarks after returning from a meeting and described the episode as strange.
Asked whether Netanyahu’s criticism felt personal, Mamdani dismissed the idea that the dispute should be viewed as a personal feud between the two men.
“It’s not about me and him.”
Mamdani argued that Netanyahu was attempting to redirect attention away from his own conduct and Israel’s actions in Gaza.
“It’s about the fact that he’s the architect of a genocide.”
He then added: “And it’s like, yeah, if I was the architect of a genocide, I would probably talk about anything but that.”
Netanyahu, for his part, used his UN address to categorically reject the genocide accusation, calling it “the biggest lie of the century.” Israel maintains that its military campaign has targeted Hamas and other terrorist organizations following the Oct. 7, 2023, massacre and rejects accusations that its actions constitute genocide.
The escalating war of words between the Israeli prime minister and New York’s mayor has taken on particular significance because New York is home to the largest Jewish population of any American city and hosts the United Nations, making visits by Israeli leaders a recurring issue for City Hall.
Before Netanyahu’s latest visit, Mamdani acknowledged publicly that his earlier rhetoric about arresting the prime minister ran into a fundamental legal obstacle: New York City cannot independently execute an ICC arrest warrant. During preparations for the General Assembly, his administration instead worked with federal and local law-enforcement agencies to provide security for visiting foreign leaders.
Mamdani nevertheless made clear during his conversation with Von that his inability to order Netanyahu’s arrest as mayor has not changed what he believes Washington should do.
His position amounts to a call for a major change in American foreign policy: joining the International Criminal Court and committing the federal government to enforcing its warrants, including the outstanding warrant against the Israeli prime minister.
WATCH:
{Matzav.com}
