SHOCKING: “UNTIE THE TERRORIST”: Israeli Heroes Say Flydubai Crew Demanded They Free Attacker After Midair Battle — Prompting Fears of a Wider Plot
Israeli passengers who overpowered the alleged terrorist co-pilot aboard Flydubai Flight FZ1073 say they faced another frightening confrontation moments later when members of the cabin crew demanded that they untie and release the attacker, leaving the Israelis wondering whether anyone else aboard the aircraft might be involved, the NY Post reports.
The extraordinary new account adds another layer to the September 30 attempted attack aboard the Dubai-to-Tel Aviv flight, during which Omani co-pilot Hamam al-Hammami allegedly attacked Captain Smit Machchhar with an emergency crash axe and sent the Boeing 737 MAX into a catastrophic plunge before passengers and other pilots regained control.
“They were asking us to untie the terrorist — we had no idea why,” said banking executive Tzvika Manes, one of the three civilians who took down the would-be hijacker.
“They were saying to free the terrorist — we got instantly suspicious of them,” said real estate professional Daniel Schlichter, who was sitting in the second row, close to the cockpit .
Manes, 40, had been returning from a family vacation in Japan with his wife and three daughters, ages 11, 7 and 6, when the flight suddenly turned into a battle for survival.
According to authorities and passenger accounts, al-Hammami attacked Machchhar from behind inside the cockpit after asking for an opportunity to pray. Armed with an emergency crash axe kept aboard the aircraft, he repeatedly struck the captain as the plane began a terrifying descent.
Machchhar, despite suffering serious injuries and impaired vision, managed after repeated efforts to unlock the cockpit door. That decision proved critical, giving those outside access to the cockpit and an opportunity to stop the attack.
Manes, Israeli plumber Yaniv Hayoun and Asaf Rajuan rushed forward and fought al-Hammami, eventually overpowering him. Other passengers also became involved as the chaotic struggle unfolded near the cockpit.
At the same time, the aircraft was dropping at an extraordinary rate. Flight data examined since the incident indicates that FZ1073 lost roughly 16,000 feet in approximately 30 seconds at the most extreme stage of its descent, subjecting those aboard to powerful negative G-forces.
Hayoun, who had no professional flight training, reached the controls and helped stabilize the aircraft using knowledge he remembered from watching the television program “Air Disasters.” Two Flydubai pilots who were traveling aboard the flight as passengers subsequently entered the cockpit and assumed control of the jet.
Meanwhile, the Israelis had to make certain that al-Hammami could not resume his attack. They forced him face-down and secured his hands behind his back, initially using zip ties and later reinforcing the restraints with headphone wires Schlichter collected from passengers around the cabin.
As he was subdued, Hayoun heard the terrorist cry, “Kill me, kill me” — apparently because he failed in his Jihadist mission, Manes said.
It was at that point, according to Manes and Schlichter, that the confrontation with members of the Flydubai cabin crew began.
Some crew members insisted that the restrained co-pilot be untied. After what the passengers had just witnessed, the request immediately raised suspicions among the Israelis, who refused to allow al-Hammami to be released under any circumstances.
“They said, ‘You are not God, you are not going to kill him,’” Manes recalled. “We didn’t want to kill him, we just wanted him not to kill us.”
The Israelis stressed that they were not trying to harm the restrained attacker unnecessarily. In fact, Schlichter and Manes said they gave the injured al-Hammami an oxygen mask while keeping him securely tied.
“We wanted him to live so he could be investigated,” Schlichter said.
The dispute then escalated into a struggle over who would control the area outside the cockpit. Cabin crew members maintained that they were responsible for the aircraft and needed to remain in the forward section.
The Israeli passengers, however, had no way at that moment to know whether the co-pilot had acted entirely alone. After hearing crew members demand that the man who had allegedly just tried to destroy the aircraft be released, they were unwilling to take any chances.
They ordered the cabin crew away from the cockpit and told them to sit several rows farther back in the aircraft.
“We told them, “Now the policy is we’re in charge and you do what we say,’ ” Manes said.
“We didn’t know what to think, we were in a suspicious mode for every steward.”
Schlichter and a group of other passengers escorted the crew members to approximately the fifth or sixth row, putting distance between them and the cockpit.
“We shouted at them and told them to sit down,” said Schlichter, who has two children and two granddaughters.
The passengers then recruited a physically imposing passenger to stand guard near the cockpit and ensure that nobody entered without their approval, Manes said.
By then, the two Flydubai pilots who had been traveling aboard the aircraft had reached the cockpit and were handling the flight. Their presence was another of the crucial circumstances that allowed the crippled aircraft to reach safety after Machchhar was incapacitated.
The confrontation with the cabin crew eventually subsided. Once the crew members began to “understand that this was a special case,” Schlichter said, they turned their attention to caring for frightened passengers, distributing blankets and water throughout the cabin.
There has been no allegation by investigators that members of the Flydubai cabin crew were involved in al-Hammami’s alleged plot, and no evidence of such involvement has publicly emerged. The passengers’ account instead describes their suspicions during the confusion immediately after a violent terrorist attack, when they had no way of knowing whether the co-pilot was acting alone.
Flydubai has declined to discuss the crew’s conduct while investigations remain underway.
“We remain fully committed to supporting the ongoing investigation and are in close coordination with the relevant government authorities and regulators,” it said in a statement.
The United Arab Emirates has formally characterized al-Hammami’s alleged actions as an attempted terrorist act. Authorities in several countries are now examining his background and how he was permitted to serve as a co-pilot on flights to Israel despite reports that concerns about his extremist views had previously resulted in restrictions on his flying in Oman.
Investigators are also examining whether al-Hammami acted alone or had assistance from an extremist organization. Israeli officials have said the initial evidence points toward a lone attacker, although that assessment has not ended the broader investigation.
The episode has also triggered a major examination of aviation-security procedures in Israel after it emerged that the UAE had transmitted passenger and crew information, including names and nationalities, to Israeli authorities before the flight. Questions are now being asked about why an Omani national who had reportedly previously raised extremism concerns was not flagged before being permitted to repeatedly operate flights to Israel.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has ordered a broad review of security procedures governing foreign civilian flights to Israel, while Israeli authorities have moved to tighten restrictions involving flight crews holding citizenship in countries without diplomatic relations with Israel.
For Manes, however, the institutional questions came later. During the crisis itself, his attention remained on al-Hammami and on ensuring that the attacker could not again threaten his family or anyone else aboard.
“I stayed with the terrorist until we landed safely in Tabuk, Saudi Arabia. After that I hugged my daughters and told them they were going to be OK, and that they are heroes,” Manes said.
Once the aircraft was safely on the ground in Tabuk, Saudi Arabia, the adrenaline that had carried passengers through the emergency began to disappear. Some suffered panic attacks. Others began crying as the enormity of what they had survived sank in.
For many, the trauma was compounded by the prospect of boarding another Flydubai aircraft for the journey home.
“They didn’t want to fly back to Israel on another flydubai flight. Many wouldn’t step foot on the plane until they were personally told by the Mossad that the pilots had been cleared,” he said.
Manes, CEO of Barak Capital Underwriting, described himself as a “regular finance guy” who never imagined being thrown into a violent midair fight with the lives of his wife and young daughters hanging in the balance.
He said it was hearing his children that caused him to act.
“When I heard my daughters crying ‘Father I don’t want to die’ — that was the trigger for me to run and fight, I wasn’t thinking of anything, it was just fight or flight,” Manes said.
The struggle itself was brutal. The passengers did not know whether al-Hammami still had possession of a weapon as they fought him at close quarters.
“Punches were flying, we were kicking him, we didn’t know if he still had his knife, we couldn’t see it,” Manes said. “None of us were fighters or heroes, we were just normal guys who wanted to save our families.”
Schlichter, 59, who was also returning from a vacation in Japan with his wife, remembered the terrifying sounds filling the aircraft during the crisis.
“It was sounds you only hear in a movie,” Schlichter said.
Manes emerged from the ordeal covered in bruises. Beyond the physical fight, he described the almost indescribable sensation aboard the aircraft as it plunged thousands of feet.
“The G-Force was like something I never felt like in my life, it felt like everything was soaking, it was a crazy feeling,” he said.
Schlichter said that during the plunge, he became convinced that he was about to die.
“It was the longest minute I’ll ever have in my life, I remember everything, I remember clearly thinking about 9/11, then I thought about my children, my family, how awful it would be for them to hear what happened,” he said.
The aircraft ultimately survived through a remarkable convergence of events: Machchhar remained conscious long enough to open the cockpit door despite his wounds; passengers were close enough to intervene; Hayoun was able to help stabilize the jet; two qualified Flydubai pilots happened to be traveling aboard and could assume command; and the attacker was restrained before he could regain access to the controls.
Both Manes and Schlichter said afterward that they struggled to comprehend how so many crucial pieces could have fallen into place at precisely the right time.
“Statistically this kind of miracle can not be happening, the chance that each one of us, especially would be on the same second where they had to be, I can’t even fathom how unlikely it is,” Schlichter said.
Manes had a simpler explanation.
“I believe that definitely we had divine protection,” Manes said. “Someone up there is watching over us.”
{Matzav.com}
