Rishon LeTzion Rav Dovid Yosef Responds to Bnei Brak Rabbonim: “No One Will Teach Me Hashkafah”
Rishon LeTzion Rav Dovid Yosef strongly defended the Chief Rabbinate examinations and sharply criticized both the High Court and a recent letter signed by rabbonim in Bnei Brak, as he urged avreichim to proceed with the exams without hesitation.
Speaking during his weekly shiur on Motzoei Shabbos, Rav Yosef addressed the ongoing controversy surrounding the Chief Rabbinate of Israel’s certification exams. He spoke forcefully against the Israeli High Court (Bagatz) over its ruling and dismissed calls by certain rabbonim to boycott the exams.
Referring to a letter published Friday, he expressed frustration that it had been issued without consulting him. “There are those—I don’t know—‘Shamoa bein acheichem u’shefatetem tzedek’—they sign proclamations to cancel all the exams without hearing the other side, without hearing what is being done.”
Rav Yosef emphasized that the integrity of the system would remain intact. “Everything that existed throughout the generations will continue. No one who is not worthy of receiving certification—whether full rabbanus certification or a lower level—will receive such a certificate. It won’t help them. I take responsibility together with my colleague, the Chief Rabbi, Rav Kalman Ber. We know what we are doing. I carry the responsibility on my shoulders. There are 13,000 avreichim taking these exams.”
He also stressed his commitment to maintaining halachic standards. “My father devoted his entire life to the study of halachah, and today we see more and more people learning halachah. On one hand, we want to strengthen this, but on the other hand, we will not give up even a kutzo shel yud. Let it be clear—no one will teach me hashkafah. We will not give up even a kutzoshel yud. B’ezras Hashem, everything will fall into place.”
Addressing the broader issue, Rav Yosef elaborated on the legal challenge brought before the court. “B’ezras Hashem, we intend to hold the exams. I don’t yet know what will be due to the war, but we are speaking about the end of bein hazmanim. There is a group of women who filed a petition to Bagatz. It has been going on for years. The court ruled that the Rabbinate must examine women. Either we examine women, or we will be forced to stop all exams. At present, six women have registered to be tested on the laws of mourning.”
He sharply criticized the court’s approach. “I want to say some very clear things. First of all, the conduct of Bagatz toward anything sacred—we are familiar with it. They are always against us. They do not like Orthodox Jews, including judges who call themselves religious. They hate us, they are biased all along the way, and they rule against us.”
Rav Yosef called for public protest, though he acknowledged current limitations due to the security situation. “I think we need to hold a major protest against them, a real protest. But right now we are in a מצב של מלחמה. There will yet be a time—we will not remain silent. It is impossible to stay silent when they try to secularize the state. In every matter where we rule according to halachah, they rule against us. We will still hold a major protest. We also have the issue of the Kosel—we will not be silent.”
Returning to the controversy over the rabbonim’s letter, he reiterated his position. “Now, regarding the matter itself—I heard that recently some rabbonim issued a letter not to take the exams, to punish ourselves by not participating. I want to say clearly: I am here, I bear the responsibility. There are 13,000 avreichim taking these exams. I examined everything carefully, weighed the situation, and took several very important steps. Based on those actions, I state unequivocally: everything that existed throughout the generations will continue.”
He continued: “No one unworthy—according to our hashkafah and according to halachah—will receive certification. Not Bagatz and nothing else will change that. There is no reason to worry, no concern that anyone unworthy will receive certification. These matters are clear.”
Rav Yosef expressed surprise that some rabbonim signed the letter without clarification. “I am very surprised how rabbonim sign such a letter. Some gedolei Torah approached me to ask what we are doing, and once I explained, they were reassured. They understand that we know what we are doing and that everything will be fine. But there are those—I don’t know—again, ‘Shamoa bein acheichem u’shefatetem tzedek’—they sign proclamations without hearing the other side.”
He concluded with a direct message to avreichim: “I tell you, I take responsibility together with my colleague, the Chief Rabbi Rav Kalman Ber—we know what we are doing. I repeat: whoever is not worthy will not receive certification, and with Hashem’s help we will continue.”
In closing, he urged participation in the exams. “I call on all avreichim not to be afraid of various claims made by those who do not know the facts. Go take the exams, and we will merit to be mekadeish Sheim Shamayim. Amen kein yehi ratzon, amen, amen, amen.”
{Matzav.com}
