Mystery in Haifa: Chabad Says Sefer Torah Stolen, Police Say It Was Found
A baffling dispute has emerged over the disappearance of a Sefer Torah from a Chabad house in Haifa’s German Colony, with police saying the missing Torah was located while the Chabad house insists that its only kosher Sefer Torah was stolen and remains missing — just three days before Rosh Hashanah.
Earlier this week, police initially announced that they had opened an investigation into the suspected theft of a Sefer Torah. That announcement was subsequently deleted, and police issued an update saying the Torah had been located and returned and that the incident apparently was not a theft.
But Rav Ben Tzion Gagula of the Chabad house told B’Chadrei Charedim that the police account does not reflect what happened.
“There was a theft, and the Sefer Torah was not returned,” Rav Gagula said. “The Sefer Torah that disappeared was the only kosher Sefer Torah in the shul. We are three days before Rosh Hashanah and we have no Sefer Torah.”
The Torah disappeared over this past Shabbos. Before Shabbos began, the mashgiach kashrus at a nearby hotel arrived at the shul accompanied by two guests.
“He put a new cloth on the Sefer Torah. The old cloth was torn. He found a donor who donated a cloth and put it on the Sefer Torah,” Rav Gagula related.
Contrary to the wording of the initial police announcement, the shul is not located inside the hotel. It stands across from the hotel and is also made available to hotel guests who need a place to daven.
“We give them the Chabad house so that they have a place to daven. It works in an organized manner with the hotel’s security. We gave them a key. They come, open and close,” Rav Gagula explained.
By the following morning, the Sefer Torah was gone.
“The door was locked, everything was locked,” Rav Gagula said. “Apparently they came in through the window.”
He said that when police officers arrived, they observed indications that appeared consistent with someone having entered through the window.
“The policewoman saw signs of a break-in in the area of the window, and there was also a muddy footprint near the window,” he said.
Police subsequently issued a public statement saying officers from the Haifa station had opened an investigation into the suspected theft of a Sefer Torah and were working to locate both the suspect and the missing Torah.
A short time later, however, that statement disappeared. A new police update said the incident apparently had not been a theft and that the Sefer Torah had been located and returned.
Officials at the Chabad house said they were stunned by the announcement.
“There was no such thing,” Rav Gagula said. “The Sefer Torah was not returned and we are at a loss.”
He said the police announcement has made the effort to recover the missing Sefer Torah substantially more difficult because members of the public now believe there is nothing left to search for.
“It ruined the entire issue of getting the Sefer Torah back. People read that the Sefer Torah was returned and think the story is over. If they hadn’t publicized that the Sefer Torah was returned, all the media would have applied pressure and maybe it would have been found already.”
At the same time, Rav Gagula said investigators themselves appear to still be actively working on the case despite the police spokesperson’s public account.
“From the investigators’ standpoint, they are continuing to work. They call me, ask questions, investigate people and look at security cameras,” he said. “That is to say, from the standpoint of the investigation there is activity, but the spokesperson’s office wrote as though there is nothing.”
With Rosh Hashanah only days away, the Chabad house is now attempting both to cope with the disappearance and to strengthen security at the shul. Plans being considered include installing additional surveillance cameras, bars and other security measures, along with purchasing a special safe for the Sefer Torah.
“We are trying to get back up from this powerful and painful blow,” Rav Gagula said. “This is the only shul in the neighborhood, and it serves many Jews.”
The Chabad house is also appealing to anyone who might have information about the missing Sefer Torah to come forward.
“We ask anyone who can help — to help, in any way possible. Our goal now is both to find the Sefer Torah and to secure the place so that something like this does not happen again.”
Israel Police, however, strongly disputed several elements of the Chabad house’s account in a statement.
“Contrary to what has been claimed, when the police officers arrived at the scene upon receiving the complaint, no evidence of a break-in at the shul was found, security footage in the area was examined and nothing indicating a break-in emerged.
“In addition, a key to the shul intended for use by hotel guests was found at the hotel, and there is no record or supervision of its use. It was also found that there is one camera inside the shul that is not connected.
“An examination conducted by police at the hotel located one Sefer Torah that, according to testimony, belongs to the shul. The complainant was summoned to provide additional testimony, but at this stage claims that he is unable to come during the coming month. The investigation is continuing.”
