Former Chashmonaim Recruitment Chief: Arresting Yeshiva Students Is Undermining Chareidi Enlistment
A former senior officer responsible for recruiting chareidim into the IDF says the arrest of yeshivah students over the draft is having the opposite effect of what policymakers intend, warning that the policy is discouraging enlistment rather than increasing it.
In an interview with Kikar HaShabbat, Sgt. Maj. (res.) Elchanan Wasserman, who previously served as head of recruitment for the IDF’s Chashmonaim Brigade and now directs the Derech Yoav preparatory academies, praised the continued growth of the chareidi military framework but cautioned that the arrest of bnei Torah is inflicting serious damage on recruitment efforts.
“The arrests are taking us on a 100-meter sprint—but in reverse,” Wasserman said. “They are not helping recruit chareidim; they are preventing chareidim from enlisting.”
According to Wasserman, the arrests create deep divisions within the chareidi community, weaken the morale of soldiers already serving, and discourage potential recruits from even reporting to recruitment offices. During the interview, he also discussed the population the Chashmonaim Brigade is intended to serve, outlined his preferred approach to a draft law without enlistment quotas, and sharply criticized opposition politicians for politicizing the issue.
Asked whether the Chashmonaim Brigade should be viewed as a success, Wasserman answered unequivocally that it has exceeded expectations.
“It is a tremendous success. It started as a success and continues to be a success, and we still have a long way to go,” he said. “There was never a specific target number of soldiers we had to reach. The very establishment of the brigade was a success, and with every recruitment cycle it continues to grow.”
Wasserman stressed that the brigade is not intended for full-time yeshivah students but for young chareidi men seeking a different path while remaining part of the chareidi community.
“Yeshivah students remain in yeshivah. We are talking about young men who feel they are part of the chareidi world but are not suited to spending three sedorim a day in the bais medrash.”
Addressing claims that the IDF showed little interest in recruiting chareidim before the outbreak of the current war, Wasserman said the military’s priorities have changed significantly.
“I don’t know if before that it didn’t want them. The army wasn’t recruiting based on one sector or another. Since the war, the army not only wants chareidim—it needs chareidim, and it is making major efforts to make that possible.”
Turning to the debate over proposed draft legislation, Wasserman said any solution should begin by recognizing the unique status of dedicated Torah scholars while expanding opportunities for other chareidim who wish to serve.
“Let’s begin with the premise that Torah scholars are outside the equation. We need to allow the preparatory academies and chareidi hesder yeshivos to grow. Let’s allow that solution to develop. I don’t want quotas for Torah learners because that will only generate opposition. But we need to ensure that yeshivah bochurim are truly yeshivah bochurim. There should not be quotas for yeshivah bochurim, but there should be close oversight.”
Drawing on his experience overseeing recruitment for the brigade, Wasserman reiterated that arresting yeshivah students is harming, not helping, the enlistment process.
“These arrests are taking us on a 100-meter sprint—but in reverse. They are not helping recruit chareidim; they are preventing chareidi recruitment,” he said. “Imagine a soldier in the brigade whose brother has been arrested. That creates an internal conflict. The arrests will not contribute to recruiting chareidim.”
He added that the consequences are already visible.
“Every recruitment cycle, we had additional candidates who simply did not report because of the arrests. Even when we speak with soldiers in the brigade, they ask, ‘Why?’ It creates a division between the chareidi soldier and the chareidi yeshivah student. We want everyone to remain chareidi. When you arrest a chareidi, other chareidim no longer feel comfortable.”
Wasserman concluded by accusing some opposition lawmakers of using the draft issue primarily as a political weapon rather than sincerely seeking greater chareidi enlistment.
“There is a way to recruit chareidim, and this is not it,” he said. “Many of them want to be right rather than wise. There is no real desire here to recruit chareidim into the army; there is a desire to use the issue as a political weapon because it is an incredible political tool.”
{Matzav.com}
