MEDIA MELTDOWN: BBC, NY Times, CNN and Others Blasted for Calling Flydubai Attack a “Brawl” and “Fight Between Pilots”
Some of the world’s most prominent news organizations are facing a wave of criticism over their initial coverage of the attempted takeover of Flydubai Flight FZ1073, with critics accusing them of dramatically understating an incident in which a co-pilot allegedly stabbed the captain and tried to bring down an aircraft carrying 174 people, most of them Israelis.
As the horrifying details emerged Wednesday, early headlines and reports from the BBC, The New York Times, CNN, The Guardian, Sky News, USA Today and the Financial Times continued using descriptions including “fight between pilots,” “brawl,” “clash” and “altercation” — language that triggered furious reactions online as evidence increasingly pointed to an attempted hijacking and deliberate effort to crash the plane.
The Flydubai flight was traveling from Dubai to Tel Aviv when the Omani co-pilot allegedly attacked Indian captain Smit Machchhar inside the cockpit. Despite suffering serious stab wounds, Machchhar fought back and managed to release the cockpit door, enabling passengers and crew members to enter and overpower the attacker.
Flight-tracking data captured the terrifying descent as the Boeing 737 MAX 8 lost well over 14,000 feet in a matter of seconds. The aircraft also transmitted emergency codes, including the 7500 transponder code used internationally to signal unlawful interference or a possible hijacking.
Passengers and crew members eventually subdued the co-pilot, while off-duty pilots traveling aboard the flight took control of the aircraft and stabilized it. The plane was diverted to Tabuk, Saudi Arabia, where it landed safely.
Israeli fighter jets had meanwhile been scrambled as officials monitored what they feared was a hijacking in progress.
Despite those circumstances, some of the earliest international reporting portrayed what happened primarily as a dispute between the two men in the cockpit.
The BBC initially described the incident as a “physical altercation between the pilots,” while one of its early headlines characterized the episode simply as a fight between the pilots. The broadcaster subsequently updated its reporting as information about the stabbing, dramatic descent and passengers’ intervention became available.
The BBC also committed a bizarre on-air blunder while covering the unfolding drama, with a presenter mistakenly referring to Ben Gurion Airport as “Ben Gvir Airport.”
The presenter said the flight had been scheduled to land at “Ben Gvir Airport,” apparently confusing Ben Gurion Airport — named for Israel’s first prime minister, David Ben-Gurion — with National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir.
The New York Times similarly drew criticism for initially describing the flight as having been diverted “after a confrontation between the pilot and co-pilot.” Another version of its breaking coverage referred to an “altercation between the pilot and co-pilot,” while its live coverage carried a headline describing the pilots as having “clashed” in the cockpit.
Critics noted that some of that wording remained even as the Times itself was reporting that one pilot had stabbed the other, that the aircraft had lost altitude, that passengers had forced their way into the cockpit and that the attacker was accused of trying to interfere with the plane’s systems.
The Guardian likewise described the episode in early coverage as an “apparent brawl” between the pilots, even as subsequent details indicated that the confrontation was not a mutual fight but an alleged attack by one pilot upon the other.
The newspaper defended its handling of the rapidly developing story, saying that it reported information as facts became verifiable and would not present speculation as established fact. Its coverage was updated repeatedly as additional information emerged.
CNN also came under fire for using the term “violent altercation” while reporting on the incident, while Sky News told viewers that the pilots had gotten into a fight during the flight. USA Today referred to an “apparent pilot fight,” and the Financial Times used the phrase “cockpit brawl.”
Critics argued that the issue was not whether news organizations should have immediately labeled the incident terrorism before investigators established a motive. Rather, they contended that words such as “fight,” “clash” and “brawl” suggested a mutual confrontation and failed to accurately describe an alleged stabbing followed by an apparent attempt to seize control of an airliner.
Flydubai itself initially used restrained language, saying that an “altercation occurred in the flight deck” and emphasizing that investigators had not yet established why the incident occurred.
“At this early stage, the underlying reasons and motives behind this event are unknown and remain subject to a formal investigation,” the airline said.
It urged the public to “refrain from premature speculation while authorities gather the facts.”
There was another remarkable television error during coverage of the incident. Fox News briefly aired footage connected to the September 11, 2001 terror attacks while discussing the Flydubai drama, showing images from the crash site of United Airlines Flight 93 in Shanksville, Pennsylvania.
Fox News subsequently acknowledged the mistake.
“We apologize for any confusion,” host Brian Kilmeade said.
By then, firsthand accounts from passengers were painting a picture vastly different from the comparatively mild language of a “brawl” or “altercation.”
Passengers described a sudden, violent plunge that sent people and objects flying through the cabin, terrified families believing they were moments from death and a desperate rush toward the cockpit after the wounded captain managed to unlock its reinforced door.
One passenger recounted hearing his daughters scream, “We don’t want to die,” as the aircraft plunged.
Israeli passengers Yaniv Hayoun, Zvika Manes and Asaf Rajuan were among those who rushed to the cockpit and helped overpower the attacker. Hayoun also helped pull back on the aircraft’s controls as the plane descended, while Manes later described using headphone cords to help restrain the alleged attacker.
Dr. Shota Musayev then provided emergency medical treatment to the seriously wounded captain while reserve pilots aboard the aircraft assumed control and ultimately brought the plane safely into Tabuk.
Prime Minister Bibi Netanyahu subsequently said the co-pilot had “apparently tried to crash the plane with everyone on board.”
The precise motive remains the subject of an international investigation. Authorities are examining whether the co-pilot acted alone and whether terrorism or foreign involvement played a role. President Donald Trump said Thursday that, based on information he was receiving, there appeared to be a connection to Iran, although he stressed that the matter was still being investigated.
Whatever investigators ultimately determine about the motive, critics of the early media coverage say the basic events aboard FZ1073 no longer resemble the “brawl” that initially appeared in headlines around the world: the captain was stabbed, the aircraft transmitted a hijack-related emergency code, the plane plunged thousands of feet, and passengers and crew members had to overpower the alleged attacker before other pilots could regain control.
