Vice President JD Vance, today one of President Donald Trump’s closest political allies, privately sought contact with Hillary Clinton’s presidential campaign in 2016 and offered strategic advice aimed at stopping Trump from winning the White House, according to a newly published Vanity Fair investigation. Vance’s office strongly disputes the characterization that he was attempting to help Clinton win.
The revelation adds a previously unreported chapter to Vance’s well-known opposition to Trump during the 2016 campaign. While Vance’s public criticism of Trump at the time has long been documented, Vanity Fair reports that his efforts extended behind the scenes, where he sought access to senior Clinton campaign officials and offered specific recommendations for winning working-class voters in crucial Midwestern states.
According to Vanity Fair, Vance contacted an intermediary connected to the Clinton campaign and asked to be put in touch with Jake Sullivan, then one of Clinton’s senior policy advisers and later President Joe Biden’s national security adviser.
“JD called me and said, ‘Can you put me in touch with Jake Sullivan?’” the intermediary recalled.
When the intermediary initially indicated that Sullivan was too busy, Vance reportedly persisted.
“He called me again and he said, ‘I hate Hillary. But I hate Trump more. Trump can’t win. He can’t win. Hillary’s going to lose, but she doesn’t have to,’” the source told Vanity Fair.
Vance reportedly went beyond expressing his opposition to Trump and laid out a concrete strategy he believed Clinton should follow. He urged her campaign to devote immediate attention to Ohio, Michigan, Wisconsin and Pennsylvania — working-class states that would ultimately prove decisive in Trump’s victory.
According to the intermediary, Vance believed Clinton was failing to understand the frustration of voters in communities like his hometown of Middletown, Ohio. He urged her to spend less time appearing alongside celebrities and instead personally visit those communities and address issues that had alienated working-class voters.
The source said Vance specifically argued that Clinton should come to the Midwest rather than remain “down with Beyoncé in Miami” and should apologize for her vote authorizing the Iraq War. Vance believed that decision continued to resonate in communities where families had sent sons and fathers to fight overseas.
Clinton, then a senator from New York, had voted in 2002 to authorize the use of military force against Iraq. She later described that vote as a mistake.
Vanity Fair reports that Vance eventually succeeded in speaking directly with Sullivan roughly six weeks before the November 2016 election. A person close to Sullivan confirmed that a conversation occurred, although the source did not recall Vance specifically laying out his proposed strategy for Clinton’s campaign in the so-called Blue Wall states.
The source did, however, remember Vance focusing on the political damage caused by Clinton’s widely criticized “basket of deplorables” remark about some Trump supporters.
Vance reportedly believed Clinton needed to repair the damage quickly and urged the campaign to sharpen its focus.
“She’s got to focus,” Vance said, according to the source.
The Office of the Vice President pushed back forcefully against Vanity Fair’s portrayal of Vance’s actions, arguing that his discussions about working-class voters should not be interpreted as an effort to elect Clinton.
“A lot of people asked the Vice President for advice in 2016. He never worked for a campaign, but he urged both Republicans and Democrats to care about working class towns like Middletown, Ohio. We 100 percent reject the characterization that he was trying to help Hillary win,” Vance spokeswoman Taylor Van Kirk said.
The episode occurred during a period when Vance, fresh off the success of his memoir Hillbilly Elegy, was emerging as a nationally recognized commentator on working-class America and was also an outspoken conservative critic of Trump.
Vance repeatedly criticized Trump during the 2016 campaign. In an August 2016 NPR interview, he said he could not “stomach” Trump and described him as “toxic,” arguing that Trump was leading white working-class voters toward “a very dark place.” At one point, Vance said that if he believed Trump had a genuine chance of winning, he might have to “hold my nose and vote for Hillary Clinton.”
His criticism extended well beyond that interview. Vance famously described Trump as “cultural heroin” and, in a private message that later became public, wondered whether Trump might be “America’s Hitler.”
Vance ultimately did not vote for either Trump or Clinton in 2016. He has said he cast his ballot for independent conservative candidate Evan McMullin.
The newly reported contact with the Clinton campaign provides additional context for Vance’s subsequent political transformation. Vance eventually abandoned his opposition to Trump, embraced much of his political agenda and ran for the U.S. Senate from Ohio in 2022 with Trump’s endorsement.
After winning the Senate seat, Vance became one of Trump’s prominent allies in Washington. Trump selected him as his running mate in 2024, and Vance became vice president following their election victory.
Vance has publicly addressed his change of position over the years, saying his earlier assessment of Trump was wrong and pointing to Trump’s record in office as a major reason he reconsidered his views.
Vanity Fair’s report also quotes White House Chief of Staff Susie Wiles discussing Vance’s evolution. According to the profile, Wiles characterized the transformation as “political,” occurring as Vance moved toward a Senate run.
The newly disclosed episode is drawing attention because it indicates that Vance’s 2016 opposition to Trump included direct communication with figures in the campaign of Trump’s Democratic opponent. Vance’s office, however, rejects the contention that those conversations were undertaken for the purpose of helping Clinton defeat Trump.
Chris Whipple, the author of the Vanity Fair profile, also discussed his reporting with NPR, describing Vance as privately urging the Clinton camp to recognize its vulnerability among Midwestern working-class voters and to address the fallout from Clinton’s comments about Trump supporters.
Nearly a decade later, the political circumstances are dramatically different: Vance, who was fiercely critical of Trump during the 2016 election, now serves alongside President Trump as vice president of the United States.
{
Matzav.com}