DETAINED IN JUDEA AND SAMARIA: Anti-Israel Congressional Candidate Brad Lander Taken Into Custody During Arab Olive Harvest
Brad Lander, the Democratic congressional candidate for New York’s 10th District and a vocal critic of Israel, was detained by Israeli security forces Wednesday while participating in an olive harvest with Palestinian Arab farmers near Bethlehem, according to accounts provided by Lander and the activist organization that organized the visit.
The former New York City comptroller was among approximately 90 participants, including American rabbis and Israeli activists, who traveled to the Arab village of Nahalin in Judea and Samaria to assist local farmers. The gathering was interrupted when Israeli soldiers and police arrived, declared the surrounding area a closed military zone, and ordered the participants to leave.
Lander publicized the incident on social media, accusing Israeli authorities of detaining people who were engaged in ordinary agricultural work.
“I’ve been detained by the IDF, along with a group of rabbis & volunteers. We were simply harvesting olives in a grove near Nehalim in the West Bank,” Lander wrote on social media.
He followed the announcement with a condemnation of Israel’s presence in Judea and Samaria, presenting the incident as an example of what he considers unjustified Israeli restrictions on Palestinian Arabs.
“The occupation is a crime under international law. Harvesting olives isn’t a crime under any law I know,” he added.
Lander’s initial account contained a geographical mistake. Although he identified the location as Nehalim, that name belongs to a Jewish moshav in central Israel, outside Judea and Samaria. The incident reportedly occurred near Nahalin, an Arab village southwest of Bethlehem.
The operation was organized through the “Protect the Harvest” initiative, which brings Israeli and international volunteers to agricultural areas in Judea and Samaria during the annual olive-picking season.
Rabbis for Human Rights, a left-wing Israeli organization involved in the initiative, said the group included visiting American rabbis, Israeli volunteers, and local Arab farmers.
According to the organization, the farmers had been prevented from reaching their olive groves since the Hamas massacre of October 7, 2023, and the volunteers had come to help them harvest their crops.
The organization said participants had been working for approximately two hours when IDF soldiers, Israeli police, and Border Police officers arrived and informed them that the location had been designated a closed military zone for the next 24 hours.
The activists maintained that they complied with the instructions and began leaving the area, but security personnel nevertheless detained members of the group, examined identification documents, and photographed the passports of foreign participants.
The Israeli volunteers and international visitors were subsequently separated and taken away in different vehicles for additional questioning and processing.
Among those detained was Yehoshua Schoffman, a former Israeli deputy attorney general who had joined the harvesting activity.
“I was just told that I am being detained on suspicion of harvesting olives. On the way to a police station,” Schoffman wrote on social media.
Schoffman said dozens of Israelis and American rabbis had participated in the outing and disputed any suggestion that the group had provoked a confrontation with Israeli authorities.
“There was no confrontation whatsoever with settlers or with the security forces,” he emphasized.
Lander was transported to a police station in Beitar Illit, where he was questioned and later released under caution. Other foreign participants were reportedly taken to Camp Etzion, an Israeli military installation near Bethlehem.
Authorities did not immediately disclose how long Lander had been held, and the initial reports did not establish whether any criminal charges would follow.
The congressional candidate had announced earlier in the week that he intended to participate in the harvesting initiative as part of his advocacy concerning Israeli policies in Judea and Samaria.
He described the trip as an opportunity to support Palestinian Arab farmers while drawing public attention to what he considers restrictions on their access to agricultural land and threats to their communities.
Lander, who has frequently criticized Israeli government policies, is seeking to represent a congressional district that includes substantial portions of Manhattan and Brooklyn.
His involvement in the demonstration comes as the annual olive harvest continues to generate tensions across Judea and Samaria, with Israeli officials and Jewish residents reporting a series of violent incidents involving Palestinian Arabs in agricultural areas.
Last Friday, Arab rioters near al-Mughayyir and Abu Falah in the Binyamin region allegedly attacked Jewish residents by throwing rocks and fireworks and setting fire to Jewish-owned farmland. Several Israelis sustained minor injuries during the disturbances.
The Binyamin Regional Council accused the participants of using the olive harvest as an opportunity to instigate violence against Jewish farmers and residents.
Earlier this month, the council reported another incident near Maoz Tzur in which three Palestinian Arabs participating in an olive harvest allegedly assaulted an Israeli farmer, injured his head, and attempted to take possession of his firearm.
The council has warned that agricultural activities can be exploited to facilitate attacks and has called for increased security measures to protect Jewish communities and farmland.
Those incidents were separate from Wednesday’s activity near Nahalin, and no evidence was presented in the initial reports linking Lander or the volunteers accompanying him to the earlier violence.
The detention also drew criticism from Israeli opposition lawmaker Gilad Kariv, who urged senior military officials to reconsider the use of closed military zone orders against volunteers participating in olive harvesting.
Kariv, a Reform rabbi who has previously worked with Rabbis for Human Rights, contacted senior Israeli officials, including Foreign Minister Gideon Sa’ar, to raise concerns about the treatment of the participants and the diplomatic implications of detaining American visitors, including a candidate for Congress.
Anton Goodman, the acting executive director of Rabbis for Human Rights, likewise criticized the military’s intervention.
“We came to accompany farmers to land they had been unable to access for three years, and after two hours of peaceful olive harvesting, large numbers of troops arrived and closed off the area. No one could have known about this order in advance. Instead of protecting people working their land, the army is keeping them away from it and detaining those who came to accompany them for identification,” Goodman said.
The incident has attracted attention in New York, where Lander is campaigning for the congressional seat previously held by Rep. Dan Goldman, whom he defeated in the Democratic primary earlier this year.
Lander is also a political ally of New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and has repeatedly criticized Israel’s military operations in Gaza. He has called for ending American military assistance to Israel and has made opposition to Israeli policies a prominent part of his political platform.
The episode comes amid broader tensions surrounding this year’s olive harvest. Israeli police recently detained ten individuals in connection with suspected attacks against Palestinian farmers, foreign visitors, and journalists in Judea and Samaria, including an assault that injured an American photojournalist.
As of Wednesday afternoon, Israeli authorities had not publicly provided a detailed explanation of the specific security considerations behind the closure of the agricultural area near Nahalin.
Lander was subsequently released with a warning, while the status of several other participants remained under review. Israeli media reported that authorities were considering deportation proceedings against some of the foreign activists.
The incident has added another international dimension to the dispute over Israeli security operations in Judea and Samaria, with an American congressional candidate now directly involved in a confrontation over access to agricultural land and the military’s authority to restrict activity in sensitive areas.
