New sanitation companies have begun operating across Bnei Brak following a prolonged garbage crisis that left piles of refuse and serious sanitation problems throughout the city. Municipal officials say the first signs of improvement are already visible in areas where the new contractors have started working.
The change follows a period in which, according to city officials, existing sanitation contractors deliberately scaled back their work as part of what the municipality describes as an organized “contractor revolt.” Officials say the dispute erupted over a municipal demand that digital monitoring systems be installed in sanitation and garbage trucks, allowing the city to track routes, working hours and completion of assigned cleaning tasks.
Municipal officials contend that some contractors intentionally reduced their services in response to the new oversight requirements, effectively leaving Bnei Brak residents caught in the middle of the dispute. The sanitation crisis reached a peak during the Tishrei holiday season, when large quantities of garbage accumulated on streets and around dumpsters. In some neighborhoods, the refuse remained well beyond the time by which contractors were supposed to have removed it.
During a City Council meeting, Deputy Mayor and Degel HaTorah chairman Menachem Shapira offered a stark description of conditions in the city.
“We are living in garbage. There are mountains of garbage, the cleanliness of the streets is catastrophic, and this is something that is impossible to live with,” he said.
Shapira said the municipality had spent recent months developing new work plans, establishing oversight mechanisms and creating the infrastructure needed to continuously monitor sanitation contractors. The digital tracking requirement, he explained, was intended to ensure that companies followed their assigned routes, schedules and cleaning targets.
According to municipal officials, however, the attempt to impose tighter supervision met resistance from contractors and failed to produce the immediate improvement city leaders had expected.
“We thought it would already work, but we were very disappointed,” Shapira said. “We cannot live with this catastrophe anymore.”
After extended efforts to resolve the situation, the municipality decided to bring additional sanitation companies into Bnei Brak. The goal is to reduce the city’s dependence on its existing contractors, introduce greater competition and give officials the ability to replace a company that fails to meet its obligations without disrupting garbage collection throughout the city.
“The central and most important thing happening now is that new companies are being added, in order to prevent a cartel and prevent a situation in which companies can hold us and control us,” Shapira told the council.
The new contractors have already begun operating, and municipal officials say several areas have shown an initial improvement. City officials cautioned, however, that it remains too early to determine whether those gains will last. The larger test will be whether Bnei Brak can establish consistent garbage collection and street cleaning across all of its neighborhoods.
Complicating the effort are concerns surrounding Bnei Brak’s financial situation. Municipal officials fear that cash-flow difficulties or future budget cuts could interfere with plans to expand sanitation operations, maintain the new monitoring systems or continue employing the additional contractors.
Shapira is calling for sanitation services to be protected from any potential budget reductions. He argued that after the municipality invested in the necessary infrastructure and succeeded in bringing new companies into the city, financial difficulties should not be allowed to derail the effort.
“Even if there are various difficulties, they must not harm sanitation,” he said. “If we have reached the point where the municipality has the mechanism and the tools, we have to make sure these processes are not stopped or stalled because of budgetary problems.”
The deputy mayor said clean streets must be treated as a basic municipal service rather than an expense that can be postponed when finances become tight.
“Today, this is simply no way to live. This is the bare minimum affecting residents, and therefore we will insist on it with all our strength,” he said.
Shapira added that Bnei Brak’s status as a major Torah center should give the city an additional reason to maintain particularly high standards of cleanliness.
“We need and want to be cleaner than anywhere else. We are supposed to be an example for every place and not be inferior to anyone,” he said.
Municipal officials are now hoping that the combination of new contractors, digital oversight and reduced reliance on the existing sanitation companies will finally bring the garbage crisis to an end. Although officials say improvements are already beginning to appear on Bnei Brak’s streets, the long-term outcome will depend on keeping the additional companies operating and ensuring that sufficient funding remains available.
{Matzav.com}