AID WITH STRINGS ATTACHED: Newsom Demands Restrictions on U.S. Military Assistance to Israel, Accuses Netanyahu of Isolating Jewish State
California Governor Gavin Newsom is calling for conditions to be imposed on American military assistance to Israel, signaling a further shift in the Democratic Party’s approach to the Jewish state as he positions himself for a possible presidential campaign in 2028. Newsom accused Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu of damaging Israel’s international standing and undermining prospects for a Palestinian state.
The Democratic governor made the remarks Saturday during a campaign appearance in New Hampshire, where he spoke with the Washington Examiner about American foreign policy, Israel’s military operations in Gaza, and developments in Yehuda and Shomron.
“Aid has to be conditioned,” Newsom said, maintaining that the idea of restricting American assistance to Israel has gained substantial support among Democratic lawmakers.
Newsom argued that Netanyahu’s policies have severely weakened Israel’s relationships with other countries and eroded its standing among Americans, particularly as opposition to Israel’s military campaign against Hamas has grown within his party.
“Bibi Netanyahu has done a remarkable job of really isolating himself from the rest of the world and increasingly from the American people,” Newsom charged, adding that “the damage he’s done is incalculable.”
The California governor also described Israel’s war against Hamas in Gaza as a “moral catastrophe,” continuing his increasingly outspoken criticism of the Israeli government.
Despite advocating restrictions on American military assistance, Newsom stopped short of specifying which weapons or defense programs he would seek to limit. He acknowledged that a distinction could be made between defensive capabilities, including Israel’s Iron Dome missile defense system, and weapons used in offensive military operations.
His comments come amid a broader debate within the Democratic Party over whether Washington should continue supplying Israel with military assistance without attaching political or operational requirements.
Earlier this year, a majority of Democratic senators supported an effort to prevent an American weapons sale to Israel. A separate proposal in the House of Representatives attracted opposition from more than 100 Democrats in July, although the effort ultimately failed by a substantial margin.
Newsom’s latest statements reflect an evolution in his public position on Israel. Although he has repeatedly criticized Netanyahu, he has also emphasized his support for Israel and previously traveled to the country following the October 7, 2023, Hamas massacre.
During that visit, Newsom met with survivors of the terrorist attacks and expressed solidarity with Israelis affected by the atrocities.
In March, the governor faced criticism after describing Israel as an “apartheid state.” He subsequently distanced himself from that characterization and acknowledged that using the term had been a “regret.”
The renewed criticism comes as Newsom attracts growing attention as a potential contender for the Democratic presidential nomination in 2028. His appearances outside California, including in New Hampshire, have fueled speculation about his national political ambitions.
Newsom has nevertheless indicated that his own presidential plans could depend on whether former Vice President Kamala Harris enters the race. Last month, he said he would not seek the nomination if Harris decided to pursue another presidential campaign.
Harris has acknowledged that she is considering another White House bid and has likewise adopted an increasingly critical position toward Israel’s conduct during the Gaza war.
Speaking last week at the Asan Institute for Policy Studies in Seoul, South Korea, Harris faulted both the Biden administration, in which she served as vice president, and President Trump’s administration for failing to exert sufficient pressure on Israel over its military operations.
“Most recently, the failure to use our leverage to curtail the Israeli government’s horrific conduct in the war in Gaza, both under the current administration, which offers [Prime Minister Benjamin] Netanyahu a blank check, and our administration before, where we should have acted sooner and more forcefully,” Harris said.
Her remarks included an acknowledgment that the Biden administration should have taken stronger measures against Israel earlier in the conflict, a position that has become increasingly common among prominent Democrats seeking to appeal to voters critical of American support for Israeli military operations.
Harris has also criticized Netanyahu over the American confrontation with Iran, accusing the Israeli prime minister of influencing Trump’s decision to undertake military action against Tehran.
During remarks in April, Harris linked the conflict with Iran to rising gasoline prices in the United States and claimed that Netanyahu had drawn Washington into a war that Americans did not support.
“Trump entered a war – and he got pulled into it by Bibi Netanyahu, let’s be clear about that – that the American people didn’t want. Among the many consequences of it is jacking up the price of gas,” she said.
Harris’s statements about Israel have generated controversy since her unsuccessful 2024 presidential campaign, when she faced criticism over an exchange with an anti-Israel protester at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee.
During that event, a demonstrator accused Israel of committing genocide in Gaza before being escorted out. Harris subsequently addressed the disruption in language that critics interpreted as lending credibility to the accusation.
“Listen, what he’s talking about, it’s real. That’s not the subject that I came to discuss today, but it’s real and I respect his voice,” she said.
{Matzav.com}
