Rudy Giuliani said New York City still has the capacity to safely host massive public events if its leaders place confidence in law enforcement and base decisions on intelligence rather than fear, arguing that canceling celebrations in response to threats only emboldens enemies.
Speaking on Newsmax’s “Saturday Report” on Shabbos, the former mayor contrasted New York with Paris, which canceled live New Year’s Eve festivities this year amid ISIS-related concerns. Giuliani said the determining factor should be police preparedness, not political pressure or public anxiety.
“If it were me in New York, I would go ahead, but that’s because I know I have the greatest police department in the world,” Giuliani said, adding that the city is still being run by Mayor Eric Adams and not by “the communist who’s going to run it,” a reference to Mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani.
Giuliani expressed confidence in current police leadership, describing Police Commissioner Jessica Sarah Tisch as a “fine police commissioner in the right tradition,” and said he remains “very confident” in the city’s ability to safeguard large crowds.
“If New York can’t pull this off, nobody can,” Giuliani said.
He drew on his own experience overseeing security for Times Square during the turn of the millennium, when al-Qaida threats raised serious concerns nationwide. Giuliani recalled that despite warnings linked to Osama bin Laden and the decision by other cities to cancel events, New York proceeded after intensive preparation.
“We invested an enormous amount of money. We started our security a month before,” Giuliani said.
“For three days before, police officers were on the ground making sure there was nothing there. It was a very close decision.”
Giuliani said that choice followed close consultation with then-FBI Director Louis Freeh and a reliance on NYPD assessments rather than outside pressure.
“If the greatest police department in the world couldn’t deal with a bunch of horrible terrorists, then we were in terrible trouble,” he said.
“We’re much stronger, much smarter, much more moral than they are,” Giuliani added.
He warned, however, that future political leadership could undermine public safety, saying he is deeply concerned about Mamdani’s views and the people advising him.
“He isn’t surrounded by a single sensible adult moderate adviser,” Giuliani said.
“People focus on his being a communist and an antisemite, but he’s also a supporter of Islamic terrorism — he supports Hamas, he doesn’t condemn them.”
Giuliani also criticized Mamdani’s opposition to police sweeps of homeless encampments, arguing that ignoring quality-of-life enforcement leads directly to increased violence.
“Instead of taking care of the small things, you’re making the small things bigger,” Giuliani said. “You’re breeding violence on the streets of the city.”
Shifting briefly to a more upbeat subject, Giuliani voiced support for upcoming plans to commemorate America’s 250th anniversary, including special ceremonial ball drops in Times Square tied to both New Year’s Eve and Independence Day.
“It is important to celebrate our history, our tradition,” he said.
“Our culture is greater than any one person. If we take care of our part, we’ll squish out the immature, communist, terrorist-loving Jew haters,” Giuliani said.
Giuliani concluded by calling for unity, resolve, and vigilance as the nation enters a new year amid ongoing global security challenges.
{Matzav.com}