A Department of Homeland Security investigation has uncovered that officials at FEMA, under Joe Biden’s administration, refused to assist disaster victims who displayed backing for President Donald Trump, according to findings released Tuesday.
The probe determined that this politically driven bias stretched across multiple disasters — from Hurricane Ida in 2021 through Hurricane Milton in 2024 — revealing a pattern of discrimination within the federal relief agency.
According to the DHS Privacy Office, FEMA staff “systematically bypassed” properties showing support for Trump or gun rights, collecting political data on residents in direct violation of the Privacy Act of 1974. The report condemned the actions as “a troubling overreach” that turned government disaster response into a political weapon.
DHS Secretary Kristi Noem sharply criticized the revelations, declaring, “The federal government was withholding aid from Americans based on their political beliefs — this should horrify every citizen.”
The 50-page report detailed instructions allegedly given to field workers to skip “homes advertising Trump.” In Florida alone, at least 20 households were reportedly denied immediate help following Hurricane Milton.
Investigators also found that FEMA employees gathered and stored information about survivors’ political leanings — a breach DHS said “demonstrated a failure to protect data integrity and fairness.”
The misconduct, the report noted, was not isolated to one disaster or region. Despite previous testimony from FEMA Administrator Deanne Criswell suggesting otherwise, investigators concluded the practice occurred repeatedly across several states.
The DHS findings said FEMA broke the Privacy Act by creating a secret database that linked personal details of aid applicants to their political beliefs.
Some FEMA workers reportedly defended their actions by saying “avoid homes advertising Trump” was shorthand for “avoid hostile homes.” Investigators dismissed that explanation, stating it had no foundation in FEMA policy or safety protocol.
The report emphasized that FEMA’s training materials never defined what qualified as a “hostile” situation, leaving employees to make judgment calls based on personal prejudice rather than official standards.
The inquiry outlined years of wrongdoing that included ignoring certain households, collecting unauthorized political data, and failing to report privacy breaches to DHS headquarters. Not a single privacy incident report was filed by FEMA between 2021 and 2024, despite clear evidence of improper data handling.
In response, Secretary Noem has referred the matter to the Justice Department for possible prosecution. She also ordered the DHS inspector general to conduct an additional review, suspended FEMA’s door-to-door survey initiative, and implemented tighter supervision of data-gathering practices.
The DHS report further recommends outlawing open-ended data entry that allows field workers to add political observations, as well as mandating retraining on lawful data-collection standards. FEMA will also be required to clearly define what constitutes genuine “safety” or “hostility” concerns to prevent political expression from being treated as a threat.
Critics say the revelations confirm what many have long suspected — that disaster response was being used as a political weapon against Trump supporters. DHS investigators warned that the scandal has already “eroded public trust” and endangered lives by slowing emergency assistance for partisan reasons.
“The American people expect FEMA to help all survivors — period,” Noem said. “We’re making sure this kind of abuse never happens again.”
{Matzav.com}