Building on Miracles Instead of Engineers: Beit Shemesh Trailer Park on the Brink of Disaster
A temporary classroom structure in Beit Shemesh collapsed suddenly on Sunday, injuring four young girls and exposing a disturbing reality: many of the city’s educational institutions are operating out of makeshift, unsafe buildings. The incident has reignited public outrage over the lack of oversight and safety enforcement in one of Israel’s fastest-growing cities.
The collapse occurred on Ben Azai Street, where a lightweight prefab building used as a special education kindergarten gave way without warning. One girl was moderately injured and three sustained light injuries. Beyond the physical harm, residents say the incident symbolizes a much deeper failure — an ongoing pattern of negligence and dangerous shortcuts in construction across Beit Shemesh.
A visit to several school sites in the city revealed alarming conditions: flimsy modular classrooms stacked on top of each other, supported by thin, shaky columns; access to upper floors via suspended metal staircases bolted to iron poles; and sharp, exposed metal bars perilously close to play areas. Parents described the situation as a ticking time bomb.
“There are hundreds of school buildings like this all over Beit Shemesh,” said Chaim, a local resident. “They’re thrown together hastily to meet demand, often without permits or proper inspections. It’s become normal to have classrooms standing on stilts. They’re literally gambling with our children’s safety.”
Parents who arrived at the scene of the collapse were shocked to find that even as city engineers and emergency personnel worked nearby, other similarly unstable structures remained in use just meters away. “They saw another building just like it — unsafe, packed with children — and didn’t order it shut down immediately,” one parent fumed. “This isn’t just negligence. It’s abandonment.”
Simcha, a United Hatzalah medic and father of a child who attends the affected school, recalled the chaos of the rescue. “Like every morning, I dropped off my son and went to work. Then I got a message about ‘danger to life’ and rushed over. We had to stop bleeding, cut the power, and rescue four girls. It was a miracle no one was trapped underneath. My son sometimes plays right there. It could’ve ended much worse.”
Opposition council member Tami Zusman condemned what she described as systemic failure. “The chareidi community already experienced the tragedy of Meron. Here in Beit Shemesh, we’re seeing the same recipe for disaster — zero transparency, zero planning, and zero accountability,” she said. “If a structure is unsafe, it must be closed. If it’s illegal, it must be demolished. The engineering department simply can’t keep up. We’re courting another tragedy.”
Despite orders from the city engineer to evacuate the damaged structure, the broader issue remains unresolved. Across Beit Shemesh, precarious metal stairways, makeshift supports, and trailers stacked two stories high are still being used daily by hundreds of children. Residents warn that unless the city imposes strict engineering supervision and halts unsafe construction, another disaster is only a matter of time.
The Beit Shemesh Municipality issued a response stating that it is “conducting a thorough investigation with all relevant authorities regarding the circumstances of the incident.” The city confirmed that “the building in question was an unauthorized addition” and emphasized that it “acts consistently against illegal construction.” The municipal building supervision department, the statement added, recently received a national excellence award for effective enforcement.
The city further noted that “independent educational networks are not part of the regular public school system and work directly with the Ministry of Education for safety approvals.”
For now, residents say, that bureaucratic distinction offers little comfort. “You can’t build on miracles,” one parent said bitterly. “At some point, you have to build on engineers.”
{Matzav.com}
