Harsh Rebuke Over Delays in Meron Probe: “Dragging Her Feet”
A sharp warning was issued today against Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara over her ongoing delay in deciding whether to reopen the criminal investigation into the 2021 Meron disaster, which claimed the lives of 45 men, boys, and children.
Retired judge Prof. Menachem Finkelstein, the Commissioner for Public Complaints Against State Representatives in the Courts, cautioned on Tuesday that time is running out and that the risk of the case becoming time-barred is growing. His remarks were reported by Ynet.
Finkelstein said the prolonged inaction harms not only the bereaved families who have waited years for accountability, but also the ability of the justice system to conduct any future prosecution fairly. “Unfortunately, it can be said that at this stage even a decision whether to open a criminal proceeding does not appear on the horizon. This state of affairs is unacceptable,” he warned.
The original criminal probe was halted after then–Attorney General Avichai Mandelblit stopped the process upon the establishment of the national commission of inquiry. That panel completed its work in March 2024 and formally recommended that the Attorney General consider renewing the criminal investigation. Yet no determination has been made since.
In her response to the commissioner, Baharav-Miara noted that following a petition to the High Court—which was dismissed—the State Prosecutor’s Office continues to review the commission’s findings with an expanded team. Finkelstein, however, said that was insufficient: “The time that has passed since the judgment in the petition requires, in my view, a significant acceleration of the actions taken.”
He also revealed a troubling detail: some materials submitted to the inquiry committee have still not been forwarded to the police or the prosecution, despite being essential for any investigation. Additional delays, he warned, could result in severe procedural harm—and may later serve as grounds to close the case.
“Past experience teaches that such delays may later serve as a significant factor in a decision not to open an investigation or not to file indictments,” he wrote. “This must be prevented, and action must be taken before the statute of limitations runs out.”
The national commission’s final report issued sweeping criticism of the authorities involved. “We found a corrupt culture within our own house. This harmful culture led to the terrible disaster on Mount Meron… This disaster could have been prevented, and it should have been prevented,” the panel wrote. It added that the police operated under “fixed assumptions,” including the belief that attendance could not be capped, and noted that “no serious staff work was ever done” to address crowd-control risks.
The report attributed personal responsibility to several senior officials, including Prime Minister Bibi Netanyahu; Knesset Speaker Amir Ohana, who at the time served as Minister of Public Security; and former Police Commissioner Kobi Shabtai.
{Matzav.com}
