OPEN DEFIANCE OF DAAS TORAH: Rav Yitzchok Yosef Blasts Ben Gvir Over Har Habayis Visits, Warns Against Supporting Him
Rav Yitzchok Yosef, the former Sephardic Chief Rabbi of Israel, has issued another sharp condemnation of National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir, accusing him of openly disregarding the psakim of Gedolei Yisroel by ascending Har Habayis and warning the public against giving political support to someone who acts in defiance of Daas Torah.
In his remarks, Rav Yosef criticized politicians who win over younger voters with fiery rhetoric and catchy slogans while accomplishing little of substance.
“There are people who talk and attract young people with all kinds of slogans, but what do they actually do? Nothing. Just talk, talk, and the young people get excited.”
Rav Yosef then turned directly to Ben Gvir’s repeated visits to Har Habayis, which he said were carried out in deliberate disregard of the clear psak of leading poskim prohibiting Jews from entering the sacred area.
“I have warned several times that it is forbidden to ascend the Temple Mount… The very next day, deliberately, that Ben Gvir went up to the Temple Mount, against the opinion of all the leading Torah sages from every community.
“How can anyone give power to a person like that, who openly, arrogantly, and contemptuously defies and disrespects all the leading Torah sages and ascends the Temple Mount like that? God forbid that anyone should support such a person.”
The issue of ascending Har Habayis has long been a serious halachic concern. The Chief Rabbinate of Israel has maintained a prohibition against entering the site because of the severe restrictions governing entry into areas of the Mokom Hamikdash while in a state of tumah. Numerous Gedolei Yisroel across the generations have strongly warned against ascending Har Habayis, even for individuals who claim to have undergone the necessary preparations.
Rav Yosef’s latest remarks come amid an escalating confrontation between Ben Gvir and the chareidi political parties, with the minister accusing their leadership of failing to protect the interests of bnei yeshiva during the ongoing military draft crisis.
In a sharply worded open letter addressed to the leadership of United Torah Judaism and other chareidi representatives, Ben Gvir accused them of attempting to shift responsibility for what he called their “colossal failure” to resolve the enlistment issue.
Ben Gvir argued that the chareidi parties had spent the past four years failing to secure meaningful protections for the Torah world, resulting in the suspension of funding for yeshivos, arrest warrants against bochurim who have not reported for military service, and continued uncertainty surrounding the status of bnei yeshiva.
He accused chareidi political representatives of making him a convenient target rather than acknowledging that “for four years they did nothing to take care of their community.”
The minister also criticized the chareidi parties’ dealings with Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara, claiming that their opposition to his efforts to remove her had contributed to the present situation.
“At the beginning of the term, I was the one who demanded that the Attorney General be dismissed, while you, the representatives of the Haredi parties, opposed it. You explained that you knew how to make deals with her. You thought you were smarter, and you gambled on her in order to obtain her approval for appointments – and now we have reached the current disgraceful situation.”
Addressing the draft controversy, Ben Gvir accused chareidi party leaders of pursuing what he termed the “ostrich policy of the community’s leadership.”
He maintained that the establishment of appropriate military service frameworks for young chareidi men who are not learning in yeshiva could have helped safeguard the position of those genuinely devoted to full-time Torah learning.
As an example of what he considered a workable approach, Ben Gvir pointed to specially adapted chareidi service programs in the Israel Police and Israel Prison Service, which he said have already accepted thousands of young men from the community.
He further accused chareidi politicians of refusing to support initiatives that could benefit their own constituents, citing legislation designed to permit gender-separated academic studies.
Ben Gvir also claimed that substantial private discussions had taken place between himself and chareidi representatives in an effort to coordinate political and communal matters.
According to the minister, he possesses sensitive information concerning criticism of chareidi political operatives expressed by senior rabbonim and admorim, but has refrained from making that material public.
“Every time the rabbinical courts approached me in anger over the political operatives, I could have used it, but I didn’t because I love you,” he wrote.
Concluding his letter, Ben Gvir accused chareidi party leaders of misleading their own voters by blaming him for the difficulties confronting the community.
“The truth is that you know perfectly well that everything I have written here is true. When you tell your public that I am to blame, you are primarily revealing just how much you despise them and insult their intelligence. The Haredi public deserves more respect from you, rather than being sold such low-grade lies.”
{Matzav.com}
