Nick Shirley Fires Back At CBS News Reporter Suggesting Minnesota Daycare Centers Weren’t ‘Fraudulent’
Independent journalist Nick Shirley fired back at a CBS News reporter after a network video disputed Shirley’s claims that several Minnesota daycare centers he filmed were operating fraudulently.
The dispute centers on a video posted to CBS News’ X account by Jonah Kaplan, a reporter with the network’s Minneapolis affiliate, in which Kaplan said his review of nearly a dozen daycare locations highlighted by Shirley did not uncover evidence of fraud. The segment described the effort as CBS News offering “its own analysis” of the sites that appeared in Shirley’s viral reporting.
In the video, Kaplan acknowledged that some of the facilities had been cited for regulatory issues but argued that those findings should not be conflated with fraud. “We visited those sites too, as did state inspectors many times over the last six months, and we found the facts on the ground tell a different story,” Kaplan said. “Those daycares, many of them were written up for safety violations, things like maybe busted equipment or staff training issues, but that’s not the same as being fraudulent, so it’s important to put all of this into context.”
Kaplan’s post quickly drew criticism online, including from Shirley himself, who challenged the reporting and its presentation. Responding on X, Shirley wrote, “Why don’t you go to a daycare yourself, and you will see it first hand. Or you can just keep yapping on selfie mode.”
Fox News Digital reported that it contacted Kaplan and CBS News seeking comment, but did not receive a response.
Shirley’s original reporting consisted of a 42-minute video posted over the weekend on X and YouTube, documenting his visits to multiple daycare centers across Minnesota. In the footage, several locations appeared largely inactive despite continuing to receive millions of dollars in public funding.
Kaplan later expanded on CBS’ findings in a report that aired Tuesday on CBS Evening News, stating that all but two of the locations Shirley visited held active licenses. The report also noted that CBS News had “visited and called several of the day care centers on Monday but received no responses.”
State officials also moved to counter Shirley’s allegations. Minnesota Department of Children, Youth and Families Commissioner Tikki Brown said previous inspections had not produced evidence of fraud. “We are aware of a video that’s being circulated that has gained local and national attention about childcare centers in Minnesota,” Brown said during a Monday news conference. “While we have questions about some of the methods that were used in the video, we do take the concerns that the video raises about fraud very seriously.”
The controversy prompted a federal response as well. Following the viral spread of Shirley’s video, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services announced Tuesday that it would halt childcare payments to Minnesota.
{Matzav.com}
