NYT Called Out For Headline Calling Ayatollah Khamenei ‘Hard-Line Cleric’ Who Made Iran Into Regional Power
The New York Times drew sharp criticism on social media following its headline and obituary coverage of Iran’s supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, after news of his death.
The newspaper’s headline read, “Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, Hard-Line Cleric Who Made Iran a Regional Power, Is Dead at 86.” In the obituary, the Times characterized Khamenei as “avuncular and magnanimous.”
The article further stated, “With his spectacles, Palestinian kaffiyeh, long robes and silver beard, Ayatollah Khamenei cast himself as a religious scholar as well as a writer and translator of works on Islam. He affected an avuncular and magnanimous aloofness, running the country from a perch above the jousting of daily politics,” the NYT’s obituary read.
The framing prompted an immediate wave of criticism from political figures and commentators online.
Sen. Tim Sheehy, R-Montana, responded publicly and shared what he described as an alternative version of the headline.
Other critics objected to the tone of the obituary, arguing that Khamenei presided over a regime responsible for thousands of deaths. The Times’ own report referenced the government’s role in ordering the killing of protesters who spoke out against the regime in January and again in 2022.
Fox News contributor Joe Concha reacted succinctly, writing, “I give up…”
Washington Post columnist Marc Thiessen also weighed in, posting, “You can’t be serious.”
Judicial Watch president Tom Fitton responded with the phrase “mostly peaceful,” a remark widely seen as referencing CNN’s coverage of the 2020 Kenosha protests, when the network aired a chyron reading, “FIERY BUT MOSTLY PEACEFUL PROTESTS AFTER POLICE SHOOTING.”
News Nation’s Batya Ungar-Sargon added, “You don’t have the media enough.”
Jason Bedrick of the Heritage Foundation offered a blunt assessment, writing, “The NYT is garbage,” in response to the headline.
Amid the criticism, the New York Times’ communications team addressed the backlash in a post on X.
“The Times’s obituaries report and reflect lives in full, illuminating why, in our judgment, they were significant. We fairly and accurately include the newsworthy details of each life and death, and don’t treat them dishonestly to score points like you’re trying to do here,” the communications team wrote on X in response to the Libs of TikTok account’s criticism of the headline.
The Washington Post also encountered criticism for aspects of its obituary, which described Khamenei as “avuncular” and noted his “easy smile.”
“With his bushy white beard and easy smile, Ayatollah Khamenei cut a more avuncular figure in public than his perpetually scowling but much more revered mentor, and he was known to be fond of Persian poetry and classic Western novels, especially Victor Hugo’s ‘Les Misérables.’ But like the uncompromising Khomeini, he opposed moderates’ efforts to promote political and social reforms domestically and to secure rapprochement with the United States,” the Post’s obituary of the supreme leader said.
{Matzav.com}