BROKEN PROMISES, NO MORE: Gerer Chossid Stands His Ground as Frantic Netanyahu Pleads for Chareidi Votes in Explosive Election-Night Phone Call
[Audio below.] An extraordinary recording of a telephone conversation between Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu and a Gerer chossid has become one of the most talked-about moments of Israel’s election, after the chossid calmly confronted the prime minister over four years of unfulfilled promises to the chareidi community, even as Netanyahu raised his voice and desperately sought help getting chareidi voters to the polls.
The conversation took place Tuesday evening, approximately 90 minutes before voting stations closed, when Netanyahu personally contacted Itche Dzalovsky, a Gerer chossid and well-known chareidi broadcaster who operates a popular telephone news hotline. The prime minister was deeply concerned about reports that significant numbers of chareidi voters, particularly within Ger, were staying home rather than supporting the parties aligned with his government.
What followed was a remarkable exchange in which Netanyahu repeatedly demanded to know whether chareidim would vote, while Dzalovsky refused to abandon the central issue: the government’s failure to deliver on its commitments concerning the military draft and the protection of the yeshiva world.
“Itche, what’s happening with the chareidim?” Netanyahu asked at the beginning of the conversation.
LISTEN:
https://matzav.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/AUDIO-2026-10-29-01-48-59.mp3Dzalovsky began explaining that the community was furious over the government’s handling of the draft issue and the promises that had gone unfulfilled.
Before he could finish, Netanyahu interrupted angrily, demanding to know whether chareidi voters understood the consequences of refusing to participate in the election.
“Tell me, are they crazy? Do they want a left-wing government?” Netanyahu exclaimed.
Dzalovsky remained composed.
“They want a government that will deliver on what it has repeatedly promised,” he responded.
Netanyahu’s agitation intensified. At one point, his wife, Sara Netanyahu, could be heard shouting in the background that everyone would die if the election went the wrong way.
The prime minister continued pressing Dzalovsky, warning that a government supported by Arab political parties would threaten the future of the Torah world.
“Do they want to die? They want to destroy the Torah world, and they’re not coming out? That’s what I want to know,” Netanyahu demanded.
Dzalovsky responded that the community’s objective was precisely to preserve its religious way of life.
“They want ultra-Orthodox Jews to be able to observe the Torah and its commandments to the depths of their souls, without having their religion trampled,” he explained.
Netanyahu repeatedly tried to steer the conversation back to the immediate electoral question, asking whether chareidim were actually heading to the polls.
But Dzalovsky insisted that the prime minister was overlooking the reason for their reluctance.
“But they’ve had four years of promises being broken consistently,” he said.
Netanyahu brushed aside the complaint, insisting that there was no time to revisit past commitments when the election was about to end.
“Fine, but that’s not the question right now. Are they going out to vote or not? That’s what I’m asking,” Netanyahu replied.
Dzalovsky delivered perhaps the most pointed assessment of the entire conversation.
“They’re not convinced there’s anyone who will keep his word.”
When Netanyahu asked him to repeat himself, Dzalovsky did so, making clear that the problem was a fundamental loss of confidence in the government’s assurances.
The Gerer chossid explained that after years of commitments that had not been fulfilled, it was extremely difficult to persuade people that another promise would be meaningful.
With the clock running down, Netanyahu asked whether anything could still be done to change the situation.
Dzalovsky suggested that the prime minister contact the Gedolei Yisroel, including members of the Moetzes Gedolei HaTorah and the Moetzes Chachmei HaTorah, and provide concrete guarantees that his commitments would be honored.
Netanyahu responded incredulously.
“I’m going to give them guarantees now, with an hour and a half left, tell me?”
Dzalovsky replied that accomplishing in 90 minutes what had not been accomplished over four years would indeed be extremely difficult.
As the conversation drew to a close, Netanyahu appeared to acknowledge that Dzalovsky was offering him little hope of a last-minute turnaround.
“So, in short, you’re telling me there’s nothing to be done, right?” the prime minister asked.
“That’s what I think. I think it’s really, really impossible,” Dzalovsky answered.
“Thank you, Itche. Goodbye,” Netanyahu said, ending the conversation.
The recording quickly circulated across Israeli media and social networks, attracting considerable attention because of the unusual spectacle of an ordinary chareidi broadcaster confronting the prime minister so directly.
The exchange also drew praise from Israeli television personality Guy Lerer of Channel 13, who said he was astonished by Dzalovsky’s willingness to challenge Netanyahu without becoming intimidated by the prime minister’s increasingly forceful tone.
Lerer wrote that he initially suspected the recording was artificially generated because the conversation seemed so extraordinary. After confirming its authenticity, he praised Dzalovsky for repeatedly returning to the government’s broken promises despite Netanyahu’s attempts to redirect the discussion.
According to Lerer’s account, Netanyahu had initially sought to deliver an election appeal through Dzalovsky’s chareidi news hotline. Dzalovsky declined to broadcast the requested statement, and the subsequent telephone conversation became the recording that spread throughout the country.
The incident occurred against the backdrop of deep frustration within Ger over the Netanyahu government’s handling of the military draft issue.
In the weeks preceding the election, Israeli media reported that Netanyahu’s political allies feared tens of thousands of Gerer chassidim might refrain from voting for United Torah Judaism, the party they had traditionally supported.
The dissatisfaction followed the government’s failure to enact legislation addressing the draft status of yeshiva bochurim, despite commitments made to the chareidi parties during the previous coalition negotiations.
Former Housing Minister Yitzchok Goldknopf, a senior Gerer representative, had already resigned from the government amid the dispute, reflecting the deterioration in relations between the chassidus and Netanyahu’s coalition.
Reports before Election Day indicated that Ger’s usual election mobilization efforts were largely absent, fueling concerns within Likud and United Torah Judaism that a significant bloc of dependable voters would remain at home.
{Matzav.com}
