“A Deep injustice”: Tzedek Denounces “Extraordinarily Harsh” Sentence in Berkowitz Case
A wave of anguish and frustration swept through advocates and supporters today after Mordy Berkowitz was handed a six-year prison sentence, prompting the leadership of Tzedek to issue a sharply worded statement condemning what they described as a deeply unjust outcome.
The ruling came despite the judge openly acknowledging how impressed he was by the sweeping accountability campaign that Berkowitz launched over the past three years with Tzedek’s guidance.
In the Tzedek statement, Rabbi Moshe Margaretten expressed “great pain” at the sentencing, emphasizing that Berkowitz had already spent the past three years in strict home confinement while devoting himself to public education, outreach, and a national campaign urging people never to drink and drive. According to the organization, nearly 50,000 individuals signed pledges committing to change their behavior, a response Tzedek has described as unprecedented and a powerful kiddush Hashem. Yet prosecutors insisted on seeking a decade behind bars, a decision that Rabbi Margaretten said ignored the sincere repentance, the tangible impact of the campaign, and the pleas of those directly affected by the tragedy.
Tzedek noted with particular distress that the victims and their families had personally asked the court for mercy, urging leniency and expressing that additional prison time would not bring healing. The statement also pointed out that in a neighboring county, cases with similar circumstances have resulted in little to no incarceration, underscoring what they see as stark inconsistency and disproportionate punishment. “This sentence is extraordinarily harsh and deeply unfair,” Rabbi Margaretten wrote, adding that the outcome stands in sharp contrast to the transformative work Berkowitz has undertaken.
According to Tzedek, the judge repeatedly praised the accountability initiative, recognizing the sincerity and the scope of the public-safety effort. Nevertheless, the final sentence left the organization stunned. “Mordy has shown more responsibility, remorse, and dedication to protecting others than anyone could have demanded,” a Tzedek representative said. “What more could he possibly have done?” Their statement emphasized that Berkowitz’s campaign did not seek to excuse what happened, but to prevent other families from ever enduring similar heartbreak.
Rabbi Margaretten vowed that the fight is not over. “Tzedek will not stop until justice is done,” he wrote, assuring the community that all avenues will be pursued to challenge what the group sees as a miscarriage of justice. He urged the public to continue their tefillos, stating that with Hashem’s help, “we will succeed.” The organization maintains that this case is about more than one sentence—it is about whether sincere accountability, genuine change, and overwhelming communal support are recognized by the justice system or disregarded.
Rabbi Margaretten closed his message with a promise that this effort will continue until fairness is restored and justice is truly served.
{Matzav.com}
