OLD PROBE, NEW QUESTIONS: Federal Investigators Reportedly Found Evidence of Ilhan Omar Sham Marriage as Immigration Investigation Intensifies
Federal investigators reportedly uncovered evidence during a 2016 investigation suggesting that Democratic Rep. Ilhan Omar of Minnesota had entered into a fraudulent marriage with a man alleged to be her brother, but prosecutors did not pursue charges because the suspected conduct was considered too old to prosecute, according to a new report published Thursday.
The revelation comes as Omar faces renewed federal scrutiny over her immigration history, including an investigation that led Homeland Security agents to search her Washington, D.C., residence earlier this month. Investigators are examining whether Omar or members of her family provided false information in immigration documents, although no charges have been announced against the congresswoman.
According to the New York Post, the FBI and Department of Homeland Security investigated Omar’s marriage to Ahmed Nur Said Elmi in 2016, when she was pursuing a seat in the Minnesota Legislature. Investigators reportedly identified evidence raising questions about the legitimacy of the marriage, but prosecutors concluded that the five-year statute of limitations prevented them from pursuing certain potential criminal charges.
The precise nature of the evidence uncovered during that investigation has not been publicly disclosed, and the allegation that Elmi is Omar’s brother has not been independently established.
A person familiar with the earlier investigation told the newspaper that the “Biden US Attorney in Minnesota shut it down” after assuming office in 2021. That account has not been independently confirmed.
Omar has repeatedly denied accusations that she married Elmi to help him obtain legal immigration status, dismissing the claims as a racist conspiracy theory promoted by political opponents.
The latest report follows additional allegations published Wednesday concerning Omar’s former husband, Ahmed Hirsi, and Elmi’s arrival in Minnesota in 2009.
An acquaintance of Hirsi told the Post that Elmi moved into the household shared by Omar and Hirsi and was introduced as Omar’s brother from London. The source described Elmi as an “extremely feminine Somali guy” who “was walking around in tight female clothing, which is heavily frowned upon in the Somali community.”
According to the acquaintance, Hirsi identified Elmi as “it was his wife’s brother from London and that Ilhan had ‘embarrassed all of us by bringing him here’. Ahmed used very strong words and said it was ‘disgusting.’”
The source further claimed that Elmi’s presence became a subject of discussion within Minneapolis’s Somali community.
“All of the Somalis in Minneapolis were gossiping and trying to find out who this guy was,” the acquaintance said. “Then everyone realized it was … Ilhan’s brother. Everybody was shocked … [Hirsi] explained that she had married him legally to get him papers and that [Hirsi] was only Islamically married to her.”
The acquaintance also alleged that “Ahmed and Ilhan used to argue over her brother all the time” and said he “saw them arguing and shouting in public.”
Following Elmi’s departure from Minnesota around 2012, the source claimed that “Ahmed praised God for taking him away from his family.”
These accounts remain allegations attributed to an unnamed individual and have not been independently substantiated.
The renewed federal investigation escalated on October 12, when Homeland Security Investigations agents executed a court-authorized search warrant at Omar’s Washington residence. Authorities removed electronic devices and other materials as part of an ongoing criminal inquiry.
The Post reported that investigators seized Omar’s cellphone, personal computers, notebooks, and passport. Reuters separately reported that federal agents had collected her phone and issued more than a dozen subpoenas while examining possible immigration-related offenses.
The Justice Department has confirmed the existence of an ongoing criminal investigation but has not publicly identified any charges against Omar.
In a court filing this week, federal prosecutors asked a judge to keep the search warrant application sealed, arguing that investigators were still examining the seized evidence and had not determined whether criminal charges would be filed or against whom.
Another issue under examination concerns discrepancies in records identifying Omar’s year of birth.
Omar has said she obtained American citizenship in 2000, when she was 17, through the naturalization of her father, Nur Omar Mohamed. However, some records identify her birthdate as October 4, 1981, while others list October 4, 1982.
The distinction could be legally significant because the earlier birth year would mean Omar had already turned 18 when her father became a citizen, potentially affecting her eligibility for citizenship through him.
The Post previously reported that members of Omar’s staff contacted official biographical databases in 2019 to have her birth year listed as 1982 rather than 1981.
Omar’s campaign told the Associated Press in 2018 that she did not possess a birth certificate because her family had been displaced during Somalia’s civil war.
The investigation also raises questions about possible legal consequences if authorities establish that false information was submitted during the immigration process.
Federal criminal charges involving immigration fraud and false statements are subject to statutes of limitations, depending on the offense. Civil proceedings seeking to revoke citizenship obtained unlawfully or through material misrepresentation are not subject to the same general time restrictions.
Reuters reported earlier this month that federal authorities were examining whether Omar or relatives provided inaccurate information when they entered the United States as refugees in the 1990s or during subsequent citizenship proceedings.
Omar has strongly rejected the investigation, accusing the Trump administration of using federal law enforcement to target a political opponent.
“For ten years, Trump has targeted me with baseless lies and smear campaigns. This is just the latest escalation in his campaign of political intimidation,” Omar said following the search of her home.
President Donald Trump has denied personally directing the search, saying decisions about the investigation belong to the Justice Department.
{Matzav.com}
