NYC Mayor Eric Adams is unfit to govern and has surrounded himself with an incompetent leadership team at the NYPD, charged former interim commissioner Tom Donlon in a searing interview with The NY Post on Thursday. Donlon, who recently filed a scathing federal lawsuit accusing top NYPD brass of criminal misconduct, held nothing back in his first public remarks since taking legal action.
Speaking candidly during an hour-long sit-down, Donlon slammed Adams as “feckless” and said his short stint overseeing the NYPD exposed deep dysfunction within the upper ranks of the department. “The way he handles the city, I would say that he’s morally corrupt,” Donlon said.
“I don’t think he’s morally qualified” to hold office, he continued, going on to say that Adams should “absolutely” not seek another term.
Donlon, a respected former FBI official brought in after Edward Caban resigned under a cloud of federal investigation, said he was given the impossible task of leading a department whose senior officials ignored him and undermined his authority. He accused those officials of sabotaging his leadership and cozying up to Adams behind his back, while the mayor dismissed his concerns.
“He’s leaderless and feckless. He’s not structured,” said Donlon. “Those guys I dealt with in the PD, they weren’t structured.”
In the lawsuit filed Wednesday, Donlon alleged that Adams and his inner circle turned the NYPD into a fiefdom of favoritism, where loyalty trumped merit and corruption flourished unchecked. He’s calling for federal oversight of the entire department.
As Donlon leveled these accusations, Adams was simultaneously outside City Hall celebrating endorsements from over a dozen law enforcement unions for his re-election campaign—a stark contrast to the blistering critique unfolding elsewhere in Manhattan.
After Adams replaced Donlon with Jessica Tisch as the new police commissioner last November, the embattled ex-commissioner was shifted to the mayor’s Office of Public Safety. Tisch has since been praised for implementing reforms and asserting control.
“The fact is she was given a lot more power than I had,” Donlon said on Thursday.
He rejected any notion that the timing of his lawsuit was politically motivated. Donlon claimed he always intended to reveal the misconduct he witnessed, but his plans accelerated after his dismissal—especially following his wife’s arrest in what he believes was retaliation. She has also filed a legal claim against the city.
Donlon said the Adams administration made a strategic mistake by removing him when it did. “He doesn’t look five steps ahead,” Donlon remarked. “If he was smart, he would have left me there and just shut his mouth and just continue on with his election.”
In court papers submitted to Manhattan federal court, Donlon said he was merely a figurehead while a corrupt group of insiders pulled the strings behind the scenes. They allegedly used his name and authority to advance their own agendas, handing out unearned promotions and overtime to allies.
Donlon claimed Adams knowingly looked the other way. On his very first day, the mayor reportedly told him to “back off these guys.”
“He couldn’t care less, he wouldn’t say a word,” Donlon told The Post of Adams.
The lawsuit describes a culture of unchecked misconduct led by former Chief of Department Jeffrey Maddrey, his successor John Chell, current Deputy Mayor for Public Safety Kaz Daughtry, and Tarik Sheppard, who previously served as deputy commissioner for public information—all individuals closely tied to Adams.
Donlon said these officials used their positions to push favored candidates into promotions and hand out overtime benefits for political loyalty. “Kaz was a loose cannon, Chell was a loose cannon too. Maddrey was walking around trying to cut a deal for himself,” he said.
“I knew these clowns that I was working with didn’t like the feds, and they wanted to operate in their own world,” Donlon added. “Actually, they’re embarrassing themselves and the mayor doesn’t even understand that.”
He recounted a humiliating moment during a surprise promotion ceremony arranged by Sheppard. According to Donlon, Sheppard blindsided him with no prior notice or briefing, leaving him unprepared and flustered.
“It was done to embarrass me, make me look foolish,” Donlon said.
As the meeting ended, Donlon said he overheard Sheppard mock him under his breath: “Look at him, he doesn’t even know where to sit.”
None of the individuals named in the lawsuit, including Sheppard, Maddrey, Chell, or Daughtry, have publicly responded to the allegations.
City Hall spokesperson Kayla Mamelak dismissed Donlon as a bitter ex-official with a grudge, calling him “a disgruntled former employee” and “ineffective” in his brief tenure.
“Tom Donlon should have put in as much effort serving the people of New York City as interim police commissioner as he did putting together this baseless lawsuit,” Mamelak said Thursday.
This sharply critical tone differs drastically from the admiration Donlon received when first tapped to lead the NYPD—even after a federal search of his home for old classified materials. At the time, officials rallied behind him and even enlisted the support of Joseph Pistone, the famed FBI agent known as “Donnie Brasco.”
“I don’t have enough good things to say about the guy,” Pistone said at the time.
In response to the suit, Adams has since described Donlon publicly as a disgruntled former employee.
Other police figures have echoed the administration’s pushback, with some questioning Donlon’s mental acuity. “Yes, he was showing many signs of cognitive issues that he wasn’t up to the task of being police commissioner,” Sheppard claimed on Pix11 Wednesday night.
Donlon, appearing sharp and composed during his interview with The Post, categorically rejected that accusation.
His lawyer, John Scola, blasted the administration’s response. “The NYPD and City Hall keep calling Commissioner Donlon’s complaint ‘baseless,’ yet they refuse to address the detailed allegations—rampant fraud, meritless promotions, death threats, and obstruction of justice. Instead of attacking whistleblowers, the City should be cleaning its own house.”
{Matzav.com}