Attorney General To Netanyahu: Zini’s Nomination as Shin Bet Chief Violates Law
Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara issued a legal opinion on Monday declaring the appointment of Major General David Zini to lead the Shin Bet as both unlawful and invalid.
Baharav-Miara argued that Prime Minister Netanyahu should not have played a role in this appointment due to a conflict of interest. She maintained that such a decision must be made collectively by the government. “Netanyahu acted contrary to the Supreme Court’s Decision, while deliberately violating the binding legal guidelines. Looking to the future, the Prime Minister must refrain from dealing the the appointment of the Shin Bet director or an acting director, whether directly or indirectly, at least until the investigations into the relevant cases conclude,” Miara stated.
She proposed that the process be removed from Netanyahu’s hands altogether and entrusted to another cabinet member. “To enable the functional continuity of the Shin Bet, and the proper appointment of the director at this moment, the legal solution is to transfer the authority to appoint the director to another minister, who will bring the candidate for the cabinet’s approval.”
In her analysis, Baharav-Miara cast doubt on the legitimacy of Zini’s candidacy, citing procedural concerns. “Given the significant flaws already attached to the dismissal and appointment processes, and the serious concern that the minister entrusted with the appointment will effectively serve as an extension of the Prime Minister. First, the appointment process must be conducted again from the beginning, applying strict rules to ensure that no foreign considerations influence it. Second, there is a real doubt whether Major General Zini can be appointed to the position.”
She emphasized the urgency of resolving the leadership vacuum in the Shin Bet but insisted it must be done properly. “Against the backdrop of the current security situation, there is a supreme national importance in appointing a permanent head of the Shin Bet as soon as possible, before Ronen Bar’s term ends. For this reason, it is essential to strictly uphold a legal, proper, and untainted process. An action involving a conflict of interest, in contradiction to the Supreme Court ruling and ignoring binding legal guidelines, is not only illegal but also delays the completion of the process and harms the achievement of this important security and political goal,” she concluded.
{Matzav.com Israel}