U.S. Middle East Envoy Steve Witkoff firmly rejected reports on Monday that Hamas had agreed to a new deal he proposed regarding hostages, urging the group to accept a temporary truce he said Israel is prepared to honor.
Earlier that day, various international news outlets quoted unnamed Hamas sources claiming the group had accepted an updated offer from Witkoff.
But Witkoff dismissed the notion of any agreement being reached, telling Axios, “What I have seen from Hamas is disappointing and completely unacceptable.”
Witkoff elaborated that “Israel will agree to a temporary ceasefire that would see half of the living and deceased hostages return, and lead to substantive negotiations to find a path to a permanent ceasefire, which I agreed to preside over.”
“That deal is on the table. Hamas should take it,” he said.
Meanwhile, a Palestinian official speaking to The Times of Israel accused Witkoff of reversing course after originally approving Hamas’s changes to the deal via an intermediary.
The official claimed that based on those early signals, Hamas believed it had received a green light from Witkoff, prompting media outlets to report that a breakthrough had been achieved.
However, according to the same source, Witkoff later retracted his approval and relayed that Hamas’s version of the agreement was not acceptable.
When asked about this accusation, Witkoff flatly denied the claim in a follow-up conversation with The Times of Israel, reiterating the same position he gave to Axios.
Witkoff has been negotiating through Palestinian-American political advocate Bishara Bahbah, who has been based in Doha over the past week. Bahbah played a key role in the backchannel that led to the recent release of American-Israeli hostage Edan Alexander.
But on Monday, Hebrew-language reports quoted anonymous Israeli officials blaming Bahbah for engaging in discussions with Hamas over terms that allegedly exceeded Witkoff’s approved proposal.
According to details of the potential agreement, roughly 10 living hostages and the remains of 10 deceased captives would be exchanged for hundreds of Palestinian prisoners, over the course of a two-month ceasefire. During that period, Hamas and Israel would conduct negotiations aimed at reaching a lasting truce, with the United States ensuring that Israel stays engaged at the negotiating table.
Hamas has reportedly requested written guarantees from mediators that Israel will follow through with talks aimed at a permanent ceasefire—something Netanyahu’s government had agreed to in the January hostage agreement but then walked away from, resuming the war in March.
The Palestinian official told The Times of Israel that Hamas remains open to a phased ceasefire but would release all hostages immediately if Israel committed to permanently ending the conflict.
“All of this talk about the phases is because of Netanyahu,” the official said.
Hamas is “prepared to return all of the hostages now if [Netanyahu] agrees to end the war,” the source added. Netanyahu has refused to accept such a proposal, arguing that it would leave Hamas in control of Gaza. However, polls repeatedly show most Israelis support the deal and believe Netanyahu is prolonging the war to preserve his political power, amid threats from coalition members to topple the government if he agrees to a permanent truce.
A source close to the talks told The Times of Israel that negotiations remain stalled, with mediators unable to create a framework that allows Hamas to present the deal as a step toward ending the war while giving Israel plausible deniability on that point.
Separately on Monday, Netanyahu made headlines when he said in a video message that he hoped to announce news about the hostages “today or tomorrow.”
The remark triggered an immediate wave of confusion and hopeful speculation among hostage families who interpreted it as a sign of imminent progress.
But Netanyahu’s office quickly released a clarification, explaining that he did not mean to suggest a breakthrough was near.
“The prime minister meant that we will not give up on freeing our hostages, and if we don’t achieve that, hopefully in the coming days, we will achieve it later on,” the statement read. “Hamas continues to cling to its refusal.”
Relatives of the hostages harshly criticized Netanyahu for raising false hopes.
“We feel like we’re being abused,” said a statement from hostage families that aired on Channel 12. “Every comment like this makes our already broken hearts leap. The expectation, when it comes to such a sensitive subject, is that they will show the minimum sensitivity and choose their words carefully.”
Einav Zangauker, whose son Matan is still being held in Gaza, wrote on social media, “Netanyahu is abusing us day and night, while my Matan is alone in the tunnel.”
In his video, Netanyahu also falsely claimed that the January hostage deal was secured only after he replaced the leaders of the Shin Bet and Mossad with Strategic Affairs Minister Ron Dermer. In reality, that personnel change didn’t occur until February. Moreover, Dermer played no role in the negotiations that led to the release of Edan Alexander—the only hostage freed since that reshuffle.
President Donald Trump has publicly stated his intention to end the Gaza conflict as soon as possible and permanently. Meanwhile, Netanyahu remains firm in his stance that the war must go on until Hamas is eliminated militarily and politically, the hostages are freed, Gaza is demilitarized, Hamas’s leadership is exiled, and Trump’s plan to relocate Gaza’s population is enacted.
Supporters of a ceasefire argue that the IDF has already achieved its primary objectives against Hamas and is now engaged in a prolonged insurgency that cannot be fully resolved without political change. Arab nations have proposed returning the Palestinian Authority to govern Gaza and are willing to support post-war rebuilding, provided they are formally invited. Netanyahu has consistently rejected this idea, equating the PA with Hamas.
Last week, Netanyahu ordered Israel’s negotiation team to return from Doha, citing Hamas’s unwillingness to accept Witkoff’s temporary ceasefire plan, which had been approved by Israel.
These developments are unfolding as Gaza continues to face a worsening humanitarian crisis. After 78 days of a total blockade, Israel eased restrictions slightly last week. A new aid delivery system, coordinated by the U.S. to bypass Hamas, was set to begin Monday, but logistical setbacks prevented it from launching as planned.
At present, armed groups in Gaza are still holding 58 hostages—57 of whom were taken during the Hamas-led massacre on October 7, 2023.
{Matzav.com}