Netanyahu Mulls Action After Hamas Returns Hostage Remains
As reported earlier, Israeli authorities revealed on Tuesday morning that the remains handed over overnight by Hamas were not those of a new hostage, but rather the already-buried body of Ofir Tzarfati, an Israeli abducted and murdered during the October 7 attacks.
“After the completion of the identification process this morning, it was determined that last night remains belonging to the fallen hostage Ofir Tzarfati were returned — remains that had already been brought back from Gaza in a military operation about two years ago. The family has been notified,” the Prime Minister’s Office confirmed.
Officials said the handover violated the agreement with Hamas, and Prime Minister Bibi Netanyahu quickly called an emergency consultation with Israel’s defense leadership to determine the next course of action. “This constitutes a clear violation of the agreement by the terrorist organization Hamas. Prime Minister Netanyahu will hold a security consultation with the heads of the defense establishment to discuss Israel’s response to these violations,” the statement continued.
The casket had crossed into Israel under IDF supervision around midnight and was taken to the National Institute for Forensic Medicine in Abu Kabir. Hours later, the grim realization emerged that Hamas had handed over remains already buried in Israel.
Ofir Tzarfati had been kidnapped from the Nova Festival and murdered on October 7, 2023. His body was recovered by Israeli forces in November 2023, and additional remains were later returned in March 2024.
An Israeli official described the handover as a deliberate act of psychological warfare. “This cannot go without a response,” the source told The Jerusalem Post.
Netanyahu, who was en route to give court testimony when the discovery became public, immediately cut his appearance short to convene the security cabinet. Military officials are expected to present three potential responses — restricting humanitarian aid into Gaza, expanding ground operations, and carrying out additional targeted eliminations of Hamas leaders.
However, one senior security source warned, “Much depends on receiving a green light from the United States for imposing sanctions on Hamas. It is not certain that the U.S. will approve.”
According to Army Radio, IDF reservists claimed Hamas may have staged the discovery of the remains. The soldiers reported seeing a Hamas tractor digging near the “Yellow Line” ceasefire area in Shejaiya. They described how operatives appeared to bury remains taken from a nearby building, then summoned Red Cross personnel to “discover” them — an act caught by an IDF drone. “According to the fighters who spoke with us, the entire incident is documented by an IDF drone,” said Army Radio’s military correspondent Doron Kadosh.
Whether those remains were the same ones later returned to Israel has not yet been confirmed.
The shocking incident has left hostage families reeling. Bar, the daughter of Manny Godard, whose body remains in Gaza, said on Army Radio, “I’m thinking about the family – a family has to reopen the grave, and reopen the wound. It’s unimaginable. This abuse must stop. The mediators must use every leverage they can.”
The revelation triggered widespread outrage among Israeli politicians. “Hamas’s violations cannot remain without a harsh response – otherwise, we have done nothing and returned to October 6, [2023],” wrote Benny Gantz on . National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir declared, “The fact that Hamas continues to play games and not immediately hand over all the bodies of our fallen is in itself evidence that the terrorist organization is still standing on its feet. The time has come to break those legs once and for all.”
He continued, “Now we do not need to ‘exact a price from Hamas’ for the violations. We need to take its very existence and destroy it completely – in accordance with the central goal defined for the War of Redemption. Mr. Prime Minister, enough hesitation – give the order!”
Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich called for an immediate cabinet meeting “to formulate a firm and decisive package of responses and to ensure we stand by the main objective of the war: the destruction of Hamas and the removal of the threat posed by Gaza to the citizens of Israel.” He added, “We cannot allow Hamas to mock Israeli citizens and cynically play with the emotions of the families of the fallen hostages.”
The overnight handover was the first in nearly a week, coming just before a 48-hour deadline set by President Trump expired. “Hamas is going to have to start returning the bodies of the deceased hostages, including two Americans, quickly,” he said. “Let’s see what they do over the next 48 hours. I am watching this very closely.”
Meanwhile, Israeli officials are considering several possible retaliatory measures, including retaking ground in Gaza, resuming targeted assassinations, retrieving hostage remains by force, increasing diplomatic pressure, or fully ending the ceasefire agreement.
For the Tzarfati family — and for all of Israel — Hamas’s cruel deception has reopened wounds that never healed, turning what was meant to be a moment of closure into another chapter of torment.
