“IT’S A CHILLUL HASHEM”: Bnei Brak Sanitation Crisis Sparks Uproar as Deputy Mayor Demands Full Authority to Clean Up City
A growing sanitation crisis in Bnei Brak has triggered a confrontation within the city’s municipal leadership, with Deputy Mayor Akiva Stern warning that the deteriorating condition of the streets constitutes a chillul Hashem and demanding full managerial authority to overhaul the city’s sanitation operations.
Stern, a Degel HaTorah representative who serves as deputy mayor and holds the municipal sanitation portfolio, sent a sharply worded letter to City Manager Yisrael Ehrenstein, expressing frustration over the condition of the streets and insisting that he cannot be held responsible for the sanitation department without being given the authority necessary to manage it.
The dispute comes amid mounting complaints from residents about garbage collection, street cleanliness and the general appearance of Bnei Brak, one of the largest chareidi cities in Eretz Yisroel.
In his letter, Stern described the situation as unacceptable and called for immediate administrative changes to address the problem.
“Personally, I am pained by the state of cleanliness in the city,” Stern wrote. “A city of Torah must be clean, and this situation is a chillul Hashem, this is our obligation to the residents of the city.”
Stern is demanding that he be formally appointed to oversee the city’s entire sanitation operation, with full managerial powers to implement changes and ensure that the system functions properly.
He made clear that accepting public responsibility for the department without having the authority to direct its operations is an untenable arrangement.
“Without authority, there is no responsibility,” he declared.
Among his demands is the preparation of a comprehensive sanitation improvement plan to be presented to the City Council, outlining how the municipality intends to address the longstanding problems.
Stern is seeking specific answers regarding the expansion of street-sweeping operations, increased garbage collection and more frequent emptying of underground waste containers, particularly before and after Yomim Tovim, when the volume of household garbage increases considerably.
He also wants stronger inspection and oversight procedures to ensure that sanitation services reach every neighborhood and street, rather than leaving certain areas without adequate attention.
The issue was discussed at a City Council meeting Sunday, reflecting growing concern among municipal officials over the condition of the city and the increasingly vocal complaints from residents.
The controversy has also exposed the financial difficulties confronting Bnei Brak’s municipal government.
Approximately two weeks ago, Deputy Mayor Menachem Shapira, who serves as acting mayor and is also a senior Degel HaTorah official, publicly acknowledged the severity of the situation during an address to hundreds of yeshiva bochurim at the Asherichem conference.
“The situation of the Bnei Brak municipality is not the easiest right now, financially,” Shapira said, explaining that the city’s budgetary difficulties were visible in the condition of its streets.
He acknowledged that the accumulation of dirt and garbage had reached a point that could no longer be ignored.
“We are not going to give up on this issue, and I am certain that it will be resolved as quickly as possible,” Shapira declared.
“The city cannot look like this, it cannot remain like this, and it will not remain like this. The city, with Hashem’s help, will be clean and properly maintained.”
The growing controversy has also drawn the attention of MK Yaakov Asher, chairman of United Torah Judaism and a former mayor of Bnei Brak.
In an interview with Yated Ne’eman, Asher acknowledged that the city’s sanitation problems had become an embarrassment and said that major changes were necessary.
“The cleanliness and appearance of the streets do not honor what the city represents,” Asher said.
Asher pledged to pursue a substantial overhaul of Bnei Brak’s sanitation services following the upcoming Knesset elections, working in cooperation with Israel’s Environmental Protection Ministry and the municipal government.
He expressed confidence that a coordinated effort involving government assistance and local administrative changes could bring about a meaningful improvement.
“It can and must be done,” Asher said.
The dispute has placed additional pressure on Bnei Brak’s leadership to produce a practical solution, particularly as senior municipal officials themselves publicly acknowledge the severity of the problem.
Stern’s demand for expanded authority now leaves the municipality facing a decision over whether to restructure management of its sanitation department and place its operations directly under his control.
The municipality has not publicly announced whether it intends to grant Stern the powers he is requesting.
{Matzav.com}
