Two figures became the focal point of criticism during the heated two-hour Democratic mayoral debate in New York City: Andrew Cuomo, the dominant frontrunner, and Donald Trump.
Cuomo’s rivals on the debate stage—eight candidates eager to break his lead in the polls—hammered him over controversies that shadowed his resignation four years ago. The accusations ranged from sexual harassment claims to his management of the COVID-19 pandemic, which remains under federal scrutiny.
One of the harshest criticisms came from Michael Blake, a former state Assemblymember polling near the bottom of the field. “The people who don’t feel safe are the young women, mothers and grandmothers around Andrew Cuomo — that’s the greatest threat to public safety.”
With just 10 days left until early voting begins, the televised debate was a make-or-break opportunity for Cuomo’s opponents to land punches. They used the evening to aggressively go after the former governor, hoping to chip away at his commanding lead.
The lineup included Cuomo, Blake, City Comptroller Brad Lander, State Senators Zellnor Myrie and Jessica Ramos, former City Comptroller Scott Stringer, Assemblymember Zohran Mamdani, City Council Speaker Adrienne Adams, and businessman Whitney Tilson. The debate was hosted by POLITICO and WNBC.
The event was often chaotic, with candidates talking over each other as they competed to challenge Cuomo, who is seeking a political comeback after stepping down amid scandal.
Beyond Cuomo, the candidates also took aim at Trump’s influence in the city, condemning his immigration policies and his threats toward Columbia University, where he accused the administration of failing to protect Jewish students.
Brad Lander attempted to tie Cuomo to Trump by blasting both figures. “With all the corruption that’s in Washington, we can’t have corruption back here in New York City as well,” he said, referencing Cuomo’s lucrative $5 million book deal from the pandemic.
The attacks on Cuomo were relentless. Although he’s avoided most press and candidate events, Wednesday night marked a rare moment where he stood directly in the crosshairs, especially from Blake, who repeatedly landed pointed jabs.
Mamdani revived a controversial 2008 remark in which Cuomo used the phrase “shuck and jive” to describe then-candidate Barack Obama, accusing him of dodging responsibility. “Allergic to accountability,” Mamdani said, echoing the sentiment of many onstage.
Adrienne Adams was visibly stunned when Cuomo failed to identify a single political regret. She pressed him, saying, “No regrets when it comes to cutting Medicaid or health care? No regrets when it comes to cutting child care? No regrets when it comes to slow walking PPE and vaccinations in the season of Covid in Black and brown communities?”
Scott Stringer criticized Cuomo’s role in advancing a controversial bail reform law, while Cuomo pushed back, accusing his opponents of wanting to defund the police. He targeted Mamdani specifically, dismissing the assemblymember’s qualifications. “Mr. Trump would go through Mr. Mamdani like a hot knife through butter,” Cuomo said. “He would be Trump’s delight.”
Cuomo also turned his fire on Lander, accusing the comptroller of authorizing contracts tied to his wife’s connections. “Mr. Lander knows corruption,” Cuomo said. Lander swiftly responded, calling the allegation “a lie.”
Trump’s shadow loomed large over the debate. Though deeply unpopular in New York, his actions have continued to shape the race. Stringer once branded him “a schmuck,” while Cuomo labeled him “a bully.”
Current Mayor Eric Adams has opted to skip the Democratic primary altogether, announcing in April that he will pursue reelection as an independent. His perceived friendliness with Trump after the DOJ dropped a corruption case against him made remaining in the Democratic field politically risky.
Adams, who ran on a tough-on-crime message during the COVID era, was scarcely mentioned. However, Adrienne Adams expressed regret over having backed him in 2021.
Cuomo, meanwhile, hasn’t escaped the Trump-related fallout. A federal investigation into his handling of nursing home deaths during the pandemic was triggered by a House Republican referral accusing him of lying to Congress.
On stage, Cuomo denied the accusation. But when pressed about whether he had personally reviewed or edited the nursing home report, he sidestepped. “I was very aware of the report,” Cuomo said, drawing audible groans. “I stand by the report.”
The controversy over his decision to require nursing homes to admit COVID-positive patients has persisted. Cuomo has argued the policy followed federal guidelines, but the state attorney general and comptroller later reported his administration had undercounted thousands of nursing home fatalities.
Cuomo’s campaign has attempted to use the investigation to its advantage, portraying it as politically motivated. Last month, he released an ad pointing out that others under investigation by Trump’s Department of Justice include fellow Democrats, such as Attorney General Letitia James.
He stepped down in 2021 after a bombshell report from James’ office concluded he had harassed 11 women. Though he initially apologized, he later denied the allegations entirely. “I said at the time it was political and it was false.”
Despite lingering unpopularity and criticism of his past governance—particularly his record on homelessness and the subway—Cuomo remains a top-tier contender thanks to name recognition, union endorsements, and favorable polling. Some of the polling was conducted by a firm providing free services to his campaign.
Cuomo is benefiting from an expensive advertising blitz by a super PAC called Fix the City, which has spent more than $8 million on TV ads. The PAC has drawn financial support from Trump-aligned donors like William Ackman and from companies like DoorDash. The support has raised eyebrows from campaign finance watchdogs, who suspect illegal coordination.
“I work for the people of the state of New York, the people of the city of New York. I don’t care who gave me what,” Cuomo said. “I do what is right.”
His campaign message centers on restoring order to what he portrays as a city plagued by crime and homelessness—challenges he claims only he is capable of resolving.
Cuomo’s base overlaps with that of Eric Adams, drawing from blue-collar communities of color and Jewish neighborhoods, both crucial demographics in a citywide race.
Zohran Mamdani has emerged as Cuomo’s most serious challenger, consistently ranking second in the polls. An Emerson College survey found him trailing Cuomo by single digits in a final ranked-choice round.
Mamdani has grown his profile through polished online videos and bold policy ideas, including government-operated supermarkets, universal child care, and fare-free buses. However, those proposals face steep financial hurdles and would require state approval.
He’s also pushing for a rent freeze and criticized Cuomo during the debate for failing to fully support taxing the wealthy during his time as governor.
Mamdani’s political positions, particularly his support for the BDS movement and criticism of Israel, have become a liability with Jewish voters. Cuomo has leaned into this divide, slamming Mamdani, Lander, and Adrienne Adams for what he calls weak support for Israel.
Outside NBC’s headquarters at 30 Rockefeller Plaza, a raucous crowd gathered ahead of the debate. Supporters of various candidates lined the sidewalks, chanting and waving signs.
Mamdani made a flashy entrance, arriving with a brass band called “Horns for Zohran,” playing “This Land is Your Land.”
Cuomo drew the biggest crowd, filled with union members from Laborers Local 79, the Hotel and Gaming Trades Council, and the carpenters union. But he kept them waiting.
“You sure he’s coming? We’re waiting for him,” one HTC member asked, scanning the crowd.
While other candidates were told to arrive before 5:30 p.m., Cuomo pulled up nearly an hour late in a Dodge Charger, stepping out to greet his cheering supporters.
{Matzav.com}