NYPD Probes Subway Assault on Orthodox Jews During Chanukah
A frightening confrontation on a Brooklyn subway line this week left a group of young Jewish men shaken, after two men were captured on video issuing death threats and physically accosting them during a late-night ride.
The incident occurred Monday night as eight boys and young men were traveling back to Chabad Lubavitch headquarters in Brooklyn following a Chanukah celebration in Union Square. According to one of the victims, the trouble began even before they boarded the train.
Mendy Asraf, a 20-year-old yeshiva student visiting from Israel, said the attackers — whom he described as a father-and-son pair — first confronted the group while they were transferring at the Franklin Avenue stop.
“They yelled at me, and the son said, ‘I’ll kill you,’” Asraf told The NY Post.
Asraf said the men shouted explicit antisemitic slurs at the group, including yelling “[Curse] the Jews,” before following them onto the No. 3 train.
Once aboard, the harassment escalated. Social media footage shows one of the attackers grabbing a Jewish man by the collar of his coat, while the other pointed his fingers like a gun at the victim’s head and shouted, “I’ll kill you.”
The situation worsened after one of the Jewish men began recording the encounter, Asraf said.
“I was really afraid. When he made his fingers the sign of a gun towards me, I was really afraid. I didn’t know what he had in his pockets,” he said.
Video from the scene captures the fear and confusion inside the subway car, with passengers reacting nervously. Some attempted to de-escalate the situation, including one straphanger who can be heard pleading, “Chill!”
Despite those efforts, the group felt unsafe remaining on the train. Asraf said they exited at the next stop, Nordstrom Avenue, and ran to the nearest police precinct to report the incident.
“I thought it could be a very dangerous situation,” he said, adding that he and the others feared for their lives.
Police confirmed that they received a report of the alleged assault around 8:41 p.m. from two of the victims.
“While on board, the unidentified individuals initiated a verbal dispute with two victims, grabbed them by their jackets, and made verbal threats,” police said.
Authorities said the two suspects seen in the video had not been publicly identified as of Tuesday. No injuries were reported.
Asraf said he believes the group was targeted because they were visibly Jewish, noting that they were carrying menorahs as part of their Hanukkah outreach.
“We look like religious Jews,” Asraf said. “They recognized our appearance along with the menorahs.”
Police said the incident is being investigated as a hate crime.
MTA Chair and CEO Janno Lieber said the transit authority is cooperating fully with the investigation.
“The NYPD has access to video from train cars and stations to identify and apprehend the perpetrators, who should face maximum consequences from the justice system,” Lieber said in a statement. “This kind of hateful behavior has no place on the subway or anywhere, and is deeply offensive to New Yorkers.”
The encounter has left Asraf and his family deeply unsettled, particularly in light of the deadly terrorist attack at a Chanukah celebration in Australia’s Bondi Beach on Sunday that killed 15 people and wounded dozens, including children.
“After Sydney, it’s not realistic to try to even fight with these people because you don’t know what they have in their pockets,” Asraf said.
He added that his mother had warned him before he came to New York to study in yeshiva.
“It’s going to be dangerous — keep your eyes open,” she told him.
Now four months into his studies in the city, Asraf said the level of antisemitism he experienced this week was unlike anything he had encountered before.
“I felt a little antisemitism, but nothing like this.”
{Matzav.com}