Zohran Mamdani, the leading candidate in New York’s mayoral race, declined to acknowledge President Donald Trump’s role in brokering the Gaza ceasefire. Instead, he turned his criticism toward Israel, even as other Democrats offered only cautious or reluctant recognition of the president’s involvement.
Democrats across the state said they were “hopeful” about the ceasefire agreement that is expected to secure the release of the remaining hostages. Still, many used the opportunity to attack Trump, with one lawmaker likening him to a “broken clock.”
Asked about the deal, Mamdani accused Israel of committing atrocities. “I’m hopeful at the news of a possible ceasefire. I hope that it is lasting. I hope that it brings peace,” he said during an interview on 1010 WINS, before launching into a sharp denunciation of Israel.
“And amidst that hope, a recognition that it does not erase the tragedy that has taken hold over these past two years,” Mamdani added. “A tragedy with Hamas’ horrific war crime on October 7th and the Israeli government’s horrific war crimes since then leading to the genocide of Palestinians.”
Mamdani’s campaign pointed reporters to his radio interview when asked if he believed Trump should be credited for the peace deal. At no point in the broadcast did the candidate mention the president.
The remarks came during the same week Mamdani faced harsh criticism for his attacks on Israel on the two-year anniversary of the October 7 massacre.
The ceasefire agreement championed by Trump calls for hostages to be released in its opening phase, while Israeli troops withdraw from some areas of Gaza.
The development sparked celebrations among both Israelis and Palestinians, but left-leaning politicians were slow to applaud Trump’s role in the achievement.
“If the agreement succeeds in securing the release of the hostages, disarming Hamas, and ending the war, then of course the President deserves credit,” said Rep. Ritchie Torres (D-Bronx). “Even a broken clock like Donald Trump can be right twice a day.”
Assemblyman Jeffrey Dinowitz voiced enthusiasm about the deal, though he made clear his criticism of Trump remained. “I only wished it could have happened sooner,” he said, adding, “There’s very little good for which Trump can claim credit, only bad, but he certainly deserves some of the credit here.”
Other top Democrats sidestepped the matter. House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, when pressed on CNN about Trump’s role, avoided a direct answer, saying only, “It’s a very positive step in the right direction.”
Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, Governor Kathy Hochul, and mayoral contender Andrew Cuomo also praised the ceasefire itself but did not mention Trump in their remarks.
Republicans in New York, on the other hand, had no hesitation in applauding the president. “President Trump is a real dealmaker and leader and he’s not just negotiating an end to the Israel-Hamas war,” said Rep. Nicole Malliotakis (R-Staten Island/Brooklyn), highlighting his broader record of peace efforts.
Rep. Michael Lawler (R-Rockland/Westchester) also expressed gratitude, saying Trump deserved thanks “for leading this effort and working tirelessly to establish peace and bring the hostages home.”
Interestingly, Assemblyman Kalman Yeger, a Brooklyn Democrat, broke with his party and sided with Republicans. He said Trump deserves “much” credit for the breakthrough.
“The resilience of the Israeli people, the relentless focus of Prime Minister Netanyahu and his strong allies in the Knesset,” Yeger told The NY Post, “and the tremendous backing of a US President who recognized that no nation can survive if it gets on its knees to terror, combined for an unbreakable force that brought about the Hamas surrender and the hopeful quick return of the hostages.”
{Matzav.com}