CABINET CLASH: Netanyahu Rules Out Ben Gvir for Defense and National Security Ministries Ahead of Elections
Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu has declared that Itamar Ben Gvir will neither become Israel’s next defense minister nor retain his current position as national security minister if Likud forms the next government, triggering an angry confrontation with Otzma Yehudit just days before Israel’s October 27 Knesset elections.
Netanyahu’s announcement represents a significant blow to Ben Gvir, who has made securing the Defense Ministry a central demand in his negotiations over a future coalition. It also raises questions about whether Otzma Yehudit, currently a key partner in Netanyahu’s governing bloc, will have a place in the next government.
The prime minister first addressed Ben Gvir’s demands during an interview with Army Radio on Wednesday, October 14, when he insisted that the Defense Ministry would remain under Likud control regardless of the national security minister’s ambitions.
“I know he wants it, but he doesn’t decide,” Netanyahu said, making clear that Ben Gvir would not determine the distribution of senior cabinet positions.
Netanyahu went further during a campaign appearance in Acre on Thursday, announcing that Likud would retain control of the Defense Ministry, the National Security Ministry and the Education Ministry in any government he establishes following the election.
The declaration was especially significant because Ben Gvir currently heads the National Security Ministry, which oversees the Israel Police and other internal security responsibilities. Netanyahu’s remarks effectively ruled out allowing him to continue in that position while also rejecting his demand for the defense portfolio.
Israel’s ambassador to the United States, Yechiel Leiter, subsequently reiterated the prime minister’s position during an interview with CNN, reinforcing the message that Netanyahu intends to keep the country’s principal security ministries in Likud hands.
Ben Gvir’s Otzma Yehudit party responded with an unusually sharp statement, accusing Netanyahu of preparing to abandon his existing right-wing coalition partners in favor of an agreement with former IDF chief of staff Gadi Eisenkot, who heads the opposition Yashar party.
“The cat is out of the bag,” Otzma Yehudit declared, arguing that Netanyahu’s announcement revealed a broader political strategy to exclude Ben Gvir from the next government.
The party said the prime minister’s statements strengthened its suspicion that “a decision has been made to exclude Ben Gvir and Otzma Yehudit from the next coalition, bring in Eisenkot instead, and hand these portfolios over to the left.”
Otzma Yehudit also issued a direct warning to Netanyahu that the composition of the next government would ultimately be determined by the election results rather than by his campaign declarations.
“Dear Prime Minister, only the people will decide,” the party said. “Strong Ben Gvir, strong Israel!”
The accusation that Netanyahu is preparing a coalition agreement with Eisenkot has not been substantiated. Both Netanyahu and Eisenkot have publicly denied that they are seeking to establish a unity government together.
Nevertheless, Ben Gvir has repeatedly suggested that Netanyahu is considering such an arrangement, warning that it would betray the expectations of right-wing voters who want the next government to maintain the policies of the existing coalition.
The dispute intensified after Ben Gvir announced in September that he would demand the Defense Ministry as a condition for joining another Netanyahu-led government.
He argued that Israel’s military leadership required a fundamental change in its strategic approach and said he wanted to introduce a more aggressive security doctrine focused on achieving decisive victories against the country’s enemies.
Ben Gvir also proposed appointing former Likud lawmaker Tally Gotliv, who joined Otzma Yehudit ahead of the election and occupies the second position on its candidate list, as justice minister.
Under his proposed arrangement, Otzma Yehudit MK Yitzhak Wasserlauf would succeed him as national security minister, allowing the party to retain control of that portfolio while expanding its influence into the Defense and Justice ministries.
Gotliv has said that, if appointed justice minister, she would seek the removal of Israel’s attorney general and pursue changes to the authority of the State Attorney’s Office.
Ben Gvir, meanwhile, has outlined a defense agenda that includes changes to the IDF’s rules of engagement, increased compensation for combat soldiers and revisions to the military’s ethical guidelines.
He has also called for expanded measures against Palestinian terrorist organizations, including disarming the Palestinian Authority and pursuing the arrest of senior figures accused of supporting terrorism.
During an interview with Walla on Thursday, Ben Gvir dismissed Netanyahu’s insistence that the Defense Ministry would remain with Likud, suggesting that the prime minister had made similar declarations in the past only to reverse course.
“He also said in the past that I won’t be a minister, and we saw what happened. I will get more seats, and I will be defense minister,” Ben Gvir said.
His remarks reflected his belief that a strong election showing for Otzma Yehudit would give him sufficient bargaining power to demand a senior ministry despite Netanyahu’s public objections.
Ben Gvir has also invoked his role in previous security cabinet deliberations to argue that his positions have influenced major Israeli military decisions.
He claimed that following the September 2024 elimination of Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah, Netanyahu personally thanked him for pressing the government to approve the operation.
According to Ben Gvir, the prime minister told him, “Thank you for insisting in the limited cabinet that this would go ahead.”
The confrontation comes amid broader tensions between Netanyahu and his right-wing coalition partners over the distribution of votes within their political bloc.
Earlier this month, Netanyahu appeared alongside Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich at a conference in Yerushalayim aimed at mobilizing religious Zionist voters ahead of the election.
The gathering, held October 8 under the banner of strengthening the right-wing camp, brought together prominent rabbonim, yeshiva leaders and political activists.
Ben Gvir was not invited to participate, a decision that intensified suspicions within Otzma Yehudit that Netanyahu was favoring Smotrich’s Religious Zionist Party at its expense.
Likud and Smotrich’s party also signed a surplus-vote agreement, an electoral arrangement that can help parties maximize their representation in the Knesset.
Otzma Yehudit complained that Likud had declined to enter a similar agreement with Ben Gvir’s party.
The political disagreements have become increasingly public as the election approaches, with Ben Gvir accusing Netanyahu of trying to attract voters away from Otzma Yehudit rather than focusing on expanding the right-wing bloc.
Speaking earlier in the week at a political conference organized by Ynet and Yedioth Ahronoth, Ben Gvir urged Netanyahu to seek additional support from voters currently backing Eisenkot rather than competing with his existing coalition allies.
“Instead of taking votes from me, go take votes from Eisenkot,” Ben Gvir said. “Don’t make that mistake. The bloc must be a fully right-wing bloc.”
He continued by warning Netanyahu against undermining Otzma Yehudit while simultaneously exploring potential arrangements with parties outside the existing coalition.
“Prime minister, do you want to form a right-wing government? Do you want to form a government that belongs to us? Go bring votes from outside the bloc, from Eisenkot. Don’t fight me. Don’t take votes from me.”
The approaching election has increased the importance of these disputes because neither Netanyahu’s political allies nor the principal opposition parties have demonstrated a clear path to securing the 61 Knesset seats required for a governing majority.
Recent surveys have indicated that both blocs could fall short of an outright majority, leaving smaller parties and post-election negotiations with a potentially decisive role in determining the next government.
That uncertainty could give Ben Gvir leverage if Netanyahu requires Otzma Yehudit’s support to assemble a coalition, even after publicly ruling out granting him the ministries he wants.
At the same time, Netanyahu’s insistence that Likud retain the major security portfolios suggests that he intends to limit the influence of coalition partners over defense and internal security policy.
The confrontation has also created an opening for Eisenkot, whose Yashar party has emerged as a significant force in the opposition.
Eisenkot, who previously served as IDF chief of staff, has presented himself as an experienced security figure capable of replacing Netanyahu and has sharply criticized the government’s handling of the war against Hamas.
During a campaign appearance near the Gaza border on Thursday, Eisenkot pledged that, if elected prime minister, he would dismantle Hamas’s military capabilities and remove the terrorist organization from power in Gaza within 18 months.
Netanyahu’s Likud party responded by questioning whether Eisenkot could implement such a policy while relying on the support of Arab political parties.
Despite their public disagreements, speculation about a possible post-election arrangement between Netanyahu and Eisenkot has continued, particularly because of the difficulty both political blocs may face in assembling a majority.
For Ben Gvir, the immediate challenge is to demonstrate that Otzma Yehudit will emerge from the October 27 election with enough seats to force Netanyahu to reconsider his position.
{Matzav.com}
