Kiddush Hashem: Israeli Chess Teams Forfeit Matches Rather Than Play on Yom Kippur
Israel’s men’s and women’s national chess teams accepted automatic 4-0 defeats at the Chess Olympiad in Samarkand, Uzbekistan, on Monday after declining to compete on Yom Kippur, despite earlier efforts to have their matches rescheduled so the players could observe the holiest day of the Jewish calendar.
The Israeli teams had gotten off to strong starts at the international competition before the scheduling dispute resulted in the men forfeiting their match against the Netherlands and the women forfeiting against Bulgaria.
The Israel Chess Federation had already contacted FIDE, the International Chess Federation, in January after discovering that the Olympiad schedule would conflict with Yom Kippur.
According to the Israeli federation, FIDE agreed in writing that Israel’s matches on Erev Yom Kippur would be moved earlier so they could conclude before the start of the fast, while matches scheduled for Yom Kippur itself would be postponed until after the fast had ended.
That agreement, however, was not formally incorporated into the tournament regulations. Instead, changes to Israel’s match times were left dependent upon arrangements with whichever national teams Israel was ultimately drawn to face.
A day earlier, Colombia and Singapore agreed to begin their respective matches against Israel earlier, allowing the Israeli players to compete without interfering with their Yom Kippur observance. On Monday, however, no such arrangement was reached for Israel’s matches against the Netherlands and Bulgaria. With the Israeli players refusing to compete on Yom Kippur, FIDE recorded 4-0 forfeits against both Israeli teams.
“We are very angry that FIDE did not honor the commitments it made,” said Israel Chess Federation chairman Dr. Zvika Barkai. “Instead of putting it into the tournament regulations, they planned to speak with the teams we would be drawn against because they did not want to create discussion and attention around the event. In practice, they did almost nothing, and we are very angry with them over this.”
“The Singaporeans and Colombians displayed sportsmanship and agreed to move the matches earlier. We are extremely grateful to them, and we will know how to repay them for the sporting gesture,” he said.
The situation was different when Monday’s matches against the Netherlands in the men’s competition and Bulgaria in the women’s competition approached. According to the Israeli federation, the Dutch team was prepared to move its match to another time, but the proposed change was not approved, while the Bulgarian team opposed changing the scheduled time.
“FIDE did not require them to abide by what had been agreed with us in advance and caused us significant damage,” said Israel Chess Federation CEO Gil Boruchovsky. “FIDE did nothing to minimize the damage it caused. They could at least have tried to prevent a 4-0 result from being recorded, which will hurt us badly in the rankings going forward. We will consider our next steps — this will not pass quietly.”
Israeli chess officials stressed that both national teams entered the Olympiad in strong form and had performed well enough before the forfeitures to remain in contention for a high finish.
“The Israeli teams have performed very well thus far at the Olympiad and will continue fighting with all their strength and ability to finish around 15th place,” the federation said.
Barkai said Israeli officials recognize the logistical complications involved in adjusting an international tournament schedule around Yom Kippur, but argued that FIDE should nevertheless have followed through on the arrangements previously made with the Israeli federation.
“We understand the difficulty involved in allowing exceptions for us because of the restrictions of Yom Kippur. We hold up the sporting conduct of the Singaporeans and Colombians as an example and look with great disappointment at the response of the Dutch and Bulgarian federations,” he said. “The relationship between the Israeli federation and FIDE has been excellent and effective over the years. Precisely because of that, we expected much more from FIDE — to be a responsible body that honors the agreements made with us — and we were disappointed.”
The Israel Chess Federation is now considering possible legal action over the episode.
“After the Olympiad, we will consider our next steps,” federation officials said. Israeli officials are expected to seek compensation from FIDE for what they contend was the damage caused to the teams by the two automatic defeats.
Despite the controversy, the Israeli federation said it intends to maintain a welcoming approach toward the international chess community. In November, Israel is scheduled to host the Jerusalem Open, and chess players from around the world are being invited to participate. Organizers expect the tournament to draw approximately 450 players representing dozens of countries.
{Matzav.com}
