IDF Representative Admits in Knesset: Chareidi Draft Law “Far From Meeting Needs,” Won’t Solve Manpower Shortage
A discussion in the Knesset’s Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee exposed sharp gaps between political promises surrounding the chareidi draft law and the Israel Defense Forces’ actual manpower requirements.
During the heated session, Brig. Gen. Shay Taib, head of the Planning and Manpower Administration Division of the Israel Defense Forces, acknowledged that the targets proposed in the draft law fall well short of what the army needs.
Taib told lawmakers that even if the proposed framework is fully implemented, it will not provide an effective response to the IDF’s immediate manpower shortage. “The answer is still no — far from it,” he said bluntly, rejecting claims that the legislation would resolve the crisis in combat personnel.
According to data presented to the committee, the IDF expects to recruit approximately 10,000 chareidi men over the next two years. However, Taib conceded that a significant portion of those recruits would likely enlist anyway through existing general-track units. He described the political goal of having 35 percent of chareidi recruits serve as combat soldiers as “a very complex event,” noting that many recruits arrive at older ages or with various limitations that complicate combat placement.
One of Taib’s most striking statements concerned the timeline for creating a full chareidi brigade. Even under optimal conditions, he said, the IDF would only be able to establish such a brigade by 2030. “And even then,” he emphasized, “it will not replace the reserve forces.”
Addressing internal concerns within the military, Taib warned against what he termed “symbolic recruitment.” Without a rigorous screening mechanism to ensure that recruits meet the necessary physical and personal criteria, he cautioned, the targets would remain theoretical. Among the tougher alternatives raised was a proposal requiring that at least 50 percent of recruits be under the age of 21, a condition that would directly affect yeshiva students in the traditional post-yeshiva and shidduch-age brackets.
{Matzav.com}
