Tamir Nimrodi, 18, Last Hostage with Unknown Fate, Confirmed Dead
The long search for answers about the fate of 18-year-old IDF soldier Tamir Nimrodi came to a heartbreaking end on Wednesday morning when his family confirmed that his body was among those handed over by Hamas overnight. Nimrodi, who was taken hostage from his base near the Erez Crossing on October 7, 2023, was identified following the transfer of several bodies to Israel, bringing closure to a two-year ordeal marked by uncertainty and anguish.
For nearly two years, Israel had described his condition as a matter of “grave concern.” The return of his remains on Tuesday night provided the first confirmation that he was killed while in captivity. Alongside Nimrodi, Hamas also returned the bodies of Eitan Levy and Uriel Baruch, as well as a fourth body that was later determined not to belong to any of the hostages.
In a deeply emotional interview with Channel 12, Tamir’s father, Alon Nimrodi, said he felt “fortunate” to finally have certainty about his son’s fate but emphasized that their family’s mission was not complete until all 21 of the remaining deceased hostages are brought back. “This is the moment that we so feared, the moment I refused to believe would come,” he said. “The whole time, I said if there was a 0.01% chance, I would burn the world for Tamir to come home alive and well, but unfortunately, we got the news this morning.”
When asked whether there was any relief in finally knowing, Alon said the family was struggling with a complex mix of sorrow and closure. “We, like every one of the hostage families, never had the ability to give up or relax for even a single moment,” he said. “For us, the journey ended in a terrible way — not like I had hoped — but there is a long struggle ahead for the release of 21 other hostages who are in the Gaza Strip, and we must continue to struggle until they all return home.”
He continued with painful honesty: “We feel fortunate – which is a terrible thing to say about your own son who was killed in Gaza, your eldest son who was kidnapped – but I mean to say that we are lucky to have received his body back.”
“In a certain sense, there is some relief, because there is now the certainty… there is a certain easing in knowing that our son has returned to us, even if it’s in this coffin,” he said before breaking down in tears.
Describing Tamir as his “hero,” Alon expressed immense pride in his son’s strength and spirit. He also thanked the IDF personnel who made it possible for the family to finally bring him home, saying they “allowed us to breathe right now.”
The Hostage Families Forum released a tribute highlighting Tamir’s devotion to his service. “During his service, he felt like he had found his purpose and had interviewed for officer training only a week before he was taken hostage. His friends and family say he was a social and caring man. Tamir was not supposed to be on base on October 7 but volunteered to stay for that weekend [which coincided with Simhat Torah] so his friends could celebrate the holiday at home with their families.”
After his abduction, a note written by Tamir was found in his room. It read: “Help as many people as possible, create a close social circle and don’t hurt anyone.”
He leaves behind his parents, Herut and Alon, and his sisters, Amit and Mika.
Tamir’s funeral will be held Thursday at 1 p.m. at the military cemetery in Kfar Saba. His father extended an open invitation: “Every person who Tamir touched a little come and pay final respects to my hero.”
The family released a statement Wednesday saying Tamir was “kidnapped cruelly from his base and murdered in Hamas captivity.” However, the Hostage Families Forum issued a separate statement asserting that he had been “killed by IDF bombings in captivity.”
The IDF said in its own statement that preliminary findings indicate Nimrodi was killed while being held by Hamas early in the war. “Final conclusions will be formulated after the completion of the examination of the circumstances of death” at the Abu Kabir forensic institute in Tel Aviv, the military said.
Nimrodi had served in COGAT’s Coordination and Liaison Administration to the Gaza Strip. Video footage from the attack showed him alongside Cpl. Nik Baizer and Sgt. Ron Sherman being forced by terrorists toward the base gate, dressed in shorts and T-shirts. The remains of Baizer and Sherman were later recovered by Israeli troops, who determined that both were killed in a nearby Israeli airstrike in November 2023.
{Matzav.com}