Rav Shmuel Eliyahu: The General Strike Delays the Hostages’ Release and Strengthens Hamas
Rav Shmuel Eliyahu, Chief Rabbi of Tzfas and a member of the Chief Rabbinate Council, sharply criticized Sunday’s general strike, warning that it will not bring the hostages in Gaza closer to freedom but will only push their release further away.
Speaking in an interview with Radio Moreshet, Rav Eliyahu expressed empathy for the families’ suffering but insisted that the strike undermines Israel’s position. “There is no doubt that the last thing that will help bring about their release is today’s strike. The strike today only distances their release,” he said.
He explained that demonstrations and strikes provide Hamas with a sense of public and political pressure inside Israel, which in turn emboldens the terror group to harden its demands. “They are full of conditions and demands. They want to reach the line of Be’eri, Nir Oz, and Kfar Aza without one meter of Israeli control. They are demanding billions for rebuilding Gaza, and guarantees from the UN Security Council that we won’t attack them. What is that if not national suicide?”
Rav Eliyahu stressed that while his heart is with the families, the state must take a broader view. “It is difficult to stand before the families. Our hearts are with them; we truly love them and feel their pain. But the country needs to understand: the strike does not bring the release closer. It drives it further away. The more public pressure grows, the higher Hamas raises the price, making their demands impossible.”
He also noted that the Torah itself sets clear limits that cannot be crossed. “It is forbidden to release murderers. The Torah says: ‘Lo sikchu kofer lenefesh rotzeach’—you shall not take ransom for the life of a murderer. Every time terrorists were released in the past, we paid for it with blood many times over. Anyone who thinks that mass releases are a solution is ignoring the responsibility for the lives of other citizens who will be harmed in the future.”
Addressing Israel’s military strategy, Rav Eliyahu called for a decisive conclusion to the war. “The Torah says: do not fight a half-war. Fight until full victory, until the end. Anyone who thinks he is helping the hostages by striking is, in truth, harming them.”
{Matzav.com Israel}