IDF Went To War With Hamas Without A Plan, General Says
During a recent closed forum attended by IDF Chief of Staff Lt. Gen. Eyal Zamir and senior military leaders, a high-ranking reserve officer revealed that when war erupted on October 7, Israel’s Southern Command had no relevant operational plans in place, Ynet reports. Officers were left scrambling to draft entirely new strategies in the chaotic weeks that followed the Hamas onslaught.
The shocking admission comes just ahead of the anticipated publication of the Turgeman Committee’s findings, which reviewed the army’s internal probes into the lapses that allowed Hamas to carry out its devastating attack on southern Israel.
The reservist, a brigadier general currently serving in the Southern Command’s firepower division, said bluntly that the command “opened the war unprepared” and was forced to “create plans from scratch” during the first three weeks of the conflict, before Israel’s ground invasion commenced.
A veteran combat soldier, the officer had personally fought off terrorists in his Gaza-border community as a civilian before reporting for duty. In his address, he described a command hollowed by years of complacency and bureaucratic neglect. Despite multiple internal reviews calling for improved readiness, he said, successive commanders failed to act, leaving the division effectively blind when war erupted.
He took particular aim at Maj. Gen. Eliezer Toledano’s tenure from March 2021 to July 2023, calling it a time of “severe neglect and a lack of operational planning.” Speaking before hundreds of fellow officers, he mocked the irony of a slogan Toledano had hung across headquarters reading “Victory loves preparation,” remarking that “the opposite happened.”
Other participants at the event acknowledged that contingency plans that did exist—such as Operation Damocles, which envisioned massive strikes on Hamas’ tunnel network—proved useless once the fighting began and reality diverged from the models on paper.
“I ask for a full, transparent and honest war investigation so we can truly learn,” the brigadier general urged Lt. Gen. Zamir, while adding that both Zamir and current Southern Command chief Maj. Gen. Yaniv Asor had instituted “the best changes the command has seen in a year.”
Led by retired Maj. Gen. Sami Turgeman, the committee’s report is expected to expose grave deficiencies within the IDF’s self-assessments, particularly in Military Intelligence and the Operations Directorate, and to criticize Israel’s long-standing policy of containment toward Hamas rather than its elimination.
The IDF, asked about the officer’s remarks, refused to address them directly. “The army holds learning conferences that enable open, critical and professional dialogue,” it said in a statement, adding that it does not comment on “discussions held in closed operational forums.”
{Matzav.com}
