Toldos Yehuda Stutchin Rebbe Rav Mottel Zilber: “The Mizrachnikim Know Much More Than Us” (Video)
In a fiery address, the Rebbe of Toldos Yehuda Stutchin, Rav Mottel Zilber, delivered unusually sharp remarks on the importance of learning penimiyus haTorah — the deeper dimensions of Torah — claiming that the Mizrachnikim and modern communities are far ahead of many chassidim in their understanding of these areas.
Speaking during a recent shiur chassidus in Yerushalayim, the Rebbe — known for his honesty and uncompromising pursuit of truth — expressed deep concern over what he described as a troubling gap in Torah knowledge: “This is a vast part of Torah, and we have no right to hide ourselves from entire sections of it. And who does involve themselves in this? The Mizrachnikim and the modern, they know far more than we do. They study these topics, they call it ‘Machshevet Yisrael’ (Jewish thought), they become knowledgeable in them, they live them, and they understand them deeply. But a chassidic Jew,” the Rebbe added, “when you speak to him, it will often become clear that he is an am ha’aretz (ignorant) in these matters.”
WATCH:
The Rebbe stressed that while the chareidi world often focuses primarily on nigleh — the revealed aspects of Torah — many within the modern and dati leumi (national-religious) communities dedicate significant time and resources to exploring penimiyus haTorah (the inner dimensions of Torah), Jewish philosophy, and Machsheves Yisroel (Jewish thought). According to him, this leaves many chassidim lacking depth in areas critical to avodas Hashem and yiras Shomayim.
His remarks come within the broader framework of longstanding calls from gedolei Yisroel to prioritize learning the inner dimensions of Torah. The Vilna Gaon emphasized that true understanding of Torah begins with nistar (hidden teachings) before one can fully grasp the rest of its wisdom.
The Baal HaTanya famously wrote that “knowing the order of creation and the process of hishtalshelus (the chain of spiritual descent)… is also a great and lofty mitzvah, and indeed surpasses many others.”
{Matzav.com}