Attorney General Urges High Court to Order Netanyahu to Explain Why Ben Gvir Remains in Office; Minister Fires Back With Scathing Accusation
Israel’s Attorney General, Gali Baharav-Miara, on Thursday delivered a sharp response to petitions challenging the continued tenure of National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir, urging the High Court of Justice to issue a conditional order requiring Prime Minister Bibi Netanyahu to explain why he has not removed Ben Gvir from his post.
In a formal submission to the High Court of Justice, the attorney general argued that a conditional order is necessary to shift the burden onto the prime minister to justify his inaction, given what she described as a substantial factual record regarding Ben Gvir’s conduct since his appointment.
According to Baharav-Miara, Ben Gvir has “abused his position” in an effort to exert improper influence over the Israel Police in some of the most sensitive areas of law enforcement and criminal investigations, actions she said undermine fundamental democratic principles. She maintained that the prime minister has failed to put in place safeguards or mechanisms to ensure the professional, impartial, and nonpartisan functioning of the police, despite repeated warnings.
Her response followed claims by petitioners that Netanyahu is obligated to exercise his authority and dismiss the minister. Summarizing her position, the attorney general concluded that the court should issue an order compelling the prime minister to explain why Ben Gvir has not been removed from office.
In her filing, Baharav-Miara wrote that, in light of the extensive factual foundation concerning the minister’s conduct—both since his appointment and prior to it—combined with the absence of guarantees for the proper and equitable operation of the police, and Netanyahu’s failure to act, the issuance of a conditional order is required to transfer the burden of persuasion to the prime minister.
About a month ago, the attorney general sent Netanyahu a strongly worded letter warning of what she described as “sweeping and systematic political interference” in police work. She cautioned that the minister’s actions could cause tangible harm to police operations and significantly erode the rule of law.
She further warned that excessive political intervention in police activity, particularly when carried out by bypassing professional command structures, raises serious concerns about “critical harm to police independence.” Such actions, she added, do nothing to address the ongoing need to strengthen public trust in and backing for the police.
Ben Gvir responded with an unusually harsh statement, launching a personal attack on the attorney general. “Gali Baharav-Miara is a criminal who obstructed investigations in matters where the High Court ruled that she was in a conflict of interest,” he said. “She fabricates cases against elected officials, public servants, and senior officers, openly works to carry out a coup against a democratically elected government, to cancel laws, sabotage decisions, and derail appointments—and now the peak: an attempt to remove elected officials.”
He concluded by vowing to continue fighting what he described as her actions, saying he would not rest “until her conduct is investigated,” and adding, “Israel will not be a mafia state.”
{Matzav.com}
