Israeli Prime Minister Bibi Netanyahu testified at his criminal trial on Monday, downplaying the significance of any cigars or champagne he received, saying it was minor compared to the vast supply owned by billionaire Hollywood producer, onetime confidant, and current state’s witness Arnon Milchan.
The defense is nearing completion of testimony for Case 1000, known as the “Illegal Gifts” case. Once these testimonies conclude, proceedings for Case 2000 will commence, followed by the prosecution’s cross-examination. In Case 1000, Netanyahu is accused of promoting legislation that would have benefited Milchan, allegedly receiving cigars and champagne valued at thousands of shekels in return.
The charges also allege that Netanyahu ordered Shlomo Filber—who was the Communications Ministry’s director-general in 2015 and who later turned state’s witness—to assist Milchan with regulatory challenges, specifically regarding a merger between media outlets Reshet and Keshet, where Milchan was contemplating an investment.
During his testimony, Netanyahu said that their friendship ended after Milchan was questioned by police in December 2016. On Monday, he firmly denied being involved in linking Filber and Milchan or facilitating any conversations between them. “I had no way to influence it,” he stated.
According to the indictment, Netanyahu abruptly assigned Filber to lead the Communications Ministry and then allegedly directed him to explore ways to assist Milchan. The indictment further claims Milchan and Filber were in contact after Filber’s appointment, with Netanyahu supposedly seeking to tighten his grip over Israeli media.
Netanyahu defended his actions, saying, “What interested me at the time was introducing range into the Israeli journalism sphere. We saw this yesterday [with coverage of the affidavit against Shin Bet Ronen Bar]. It is a monolith that hides things from people and serves as a massive danger to democracy. When you provide one narrative [only], that’s dangerous,” he said.
Israeli TV’s three major networks—Channels 11, 12, and 13—extensively aired reports on Netanyahu’s affidavit throughout much of Sunday afternoon and evening.
During the hearing, defense attorney Amit Hadad questioned Netanyahu about accusations that he encouraged Milchan to buy into Israeli news companies to gain editorial control.
Netanyahu responded that while he did care about the overall issue of media influence, he did not have a specific interest in Milchan’s plans. “Personnel is policy,” Netanyahu said in English.
He also blasted any suggestion of meddling in Milchan’s financial dealings as “absurd,” punctuating his rejection by adding, “This is crazy,” in English.
“I took two meetings with him, like I would with anyone else,” Netanyahu added, brushing off any notion of impropriety.
The indictment claims that between 2011 and 2016, Netanyahu accepted cigars valued at approximately NIS 267,254 (about $75,000) and champagne worth NIS 184,448 (around $52,000).
Hadad probed Netanyahu’s cigar consumption habits to test the plausibility of the charges. Netanyahu dismissed the prosecution’s assertion that he smoked five to six cigars daily as “crazy.”
“I smoke one cigar over the course of two days… I have no time otherwise,” Netanyahu explained.
The defense highlighted Netanyahu’s earlier police statements, where he said he personally paid for cigars his staff bought for him, aiming to dismantle the prosecution’s claim that the gifts formed a “supply line” of luxury goods. “There was no supply line” of cigars and champagne, Netanyahu insisted.
Netanyahu said that when Milchan visited, two to four times per year, he would casually offer cigars. “He would bring a box of cigars, open it up, and say, ‘Take, Bibi, take one.’”
When interrogated, police challenged Netanyahu, asking why the sheer cost of these gifts hadn’t raised red flags for him.
On Monday, Netanyahu mocked the line of questioning, comparing it to trivial concerns. “Asking how many cups of coffee you drink in your life, or how long your nails get… They [the prosecution] have nothing,” he said.
Netanyahu further testified that no receipts were ever given to him, implying that the gifts were too minor to require formal documentation. Hadad also revealed that during interrogations, police claimed to have receipts but refused to show them.
“That’s convenient, isn’t it?” Netanyahu remarked, adding, “When you’re trying to incriminate an innocent man, facts don’t matter.”
Growing increasingly animated, Netanyahu exclaimed, “You blew up the numbers [of money spent on cigars]! What are we sitting here for – bribery for basic press releases, and fraud and breach-of-trust for cigars? This is what we are wasting precious time for, stealing time from both the State and the judges!”
Netanyahu insisted that Milchan’s generosity wasn’t unique to him, pointing out that others also benefited from Milchan’s cigar stash. “Milchan had cigars in his basement for everyone – guests of his even said so – not just for me… When you’re framing someone, you need to know what you’re doing,” he charged.
Hadad later presented a video from an award ceremony in 2008, where Milchan was honored with a cigar as recognition “for your extensive contribution to the cigar industry.” When asked to comment, Netanyahu said the tribute suited Milchan perfectly. “This is what he does. To come and say that what he has in his various homes is all designated for me is ridiculous and so removed from reality. How can this be believed, let alone the basis for a charge? It’s ridiculous.”
Addressing the champagne allegations, Netanyahu joked that Milchan practically “swam in champagne,” and said that his wife, Sara, only received a small portion as a gift.
While the indictment cited 160 boxes of champagne as being delivered, Netanyahu downplayed the figure. “That is not even close to what I saw; I recall one box, and it was opened,” he said.
{Matzav.com}