Zohran Mamdani, the socialist candidate currently leading the New York City mayoral race, is facing accusations of trying to rebrand his anti-police record by entertaining the idea of keeping current NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch — a law-and-order figure with starkly opposing views — if he wins office.
The unusual move to publicly and privately consider retaining Tisch appears to be part of a broader effort to calm establishment figures unnerved by Mamdani’s radical past, particularly as he now heads into the general election with momentum after defeating Andrew Cuomo in the Democratic primary.
Despite their polar opposite views on key policing issues such as bail reform and discovery laws, Mamdani has not ruled out the possibility of retaining Tisch, even as his earlier rhetoric was saturated with anti-police sentiment.
“He’s laundering his radical stances, that’s what he’s doing,” said political consultant Ken Frydman.
“But he needs his defund-the-police voters to turn out again and cop-hating Tiffany Cabán is lurking,” Frydman added, referencing another outspoken socialist on the City Council who has been floated as a possible police commissioner pick under Mamdani.
Jessica Tisch, the current commissioner and a billionaire heiress with a reputation for competence, has largely remained above the political drama even as her name becomes a political lightning rod.
She was tapped by Mayor Eric Adams last November in an effort to restore public confidence in the NYPD — and in Adams himself — after three previous commissioners left amid controversy and dysfunction.
The choice proved so effective that Brad Lander, another progressive mayoral hopeful who had previously supported defunding the police, announced he would also keep Tisch in place if he won.
That endorsement arguably paved the way for Mamdani’s own strategic positioning, as he began signaling openness to Tisch’s continued leadership while offering her reserved praise.
Kathy Wylde, who leads the influential Partnership for New York City, confirmed she advised Mamdani to consider keeping Tisch on board.
“I believe that it’s premature to make any personnel commitments at this time, but it’s a consideration that is real — and it’s in keeping with the city that we’re fighting for,” Mamdani said recently when asked about his intentions regarding Tisch.
Still, pairing Mamdani and Tisch would mark an unlikely alliance, given their stark differences in both ideology and personal backgrounds.
Before launching his mayoral campaign, Mamdani frequently posted harsh condemnations of the NYPD, accusing the department of systemic abuse and corruption.
“There is no negotiating with an institution this wicked & corrupt,” he tweeted about the NYPD in 2020.
“Defund it. Dismantle it. End the cycle of violence.”
Since entering the race for mayor, Mamdani has attempted to moderate those positions, acknowledging that police do play a role in maintaining public safety.
Nonetheless, Mamdani — who currently represents Queens in the state assembly — remains a staunch advocate of sweeping criminal justice reforms like bail reform, changes to discovery requirements, and the Raise the Age law, all of which Tisch has said are contributing to spikes in crime and recidivism.
“I will not vote for any budget that rolls back bail reform, discovery reform, or Raise the Age,” Mamdani tweeted in 2022.
While some believe Tisch could help temper Mamdani’s most controversial instincts, Democratic strategist Hank Sheinkopf warned that her influence would be limited under a mayor who ultimately controls her position.
Her greatest value at the moment, Sheinkopf argued, might be as a symbol of stability for officers anxious about the future.
“Here you have the opponent of [Adams] saying he wouldn’t change the department, but his rhetoric says otherwise,” Sheinkopf noted. “Police officers are in panic and they will leave in droves — Tisch is the only way to stop that.”
Still, others argue that keeping Tisch could backfire politically for Mamdani.
“Mamdani will get clobbered by his cop-hating groupies if he retains Tisch as police commissioner,” said Frydman. “If he doesn’t retain her, Mamdani risks serious crime increasing and getting blamed for the spike.
“Checkmate.”
Mayor Adams, meanwhile, is continuing to promote Tisch’s leadership as proof that his administration has delivered results.
His latest campaign ad features Tisch speaking at a public event last week where she credited Adams for the city’s drop in major crimes.
“Not only did we ignore the noise from the Mamdanis of the world who recklessly called to defund the police, but we doubled down on our support,” Adams posted on X.
When The Post reached out to Tisch for a comment, the NYPD press office responded with the exact quote used in the mayor’s campaign ad.
“When the critics called to cut funding — he chose to cut crime,” Tisch said about Adams last week. “When the pressure came to back down — he chose to double down. And when others tried to make headlines — he chose to make a difference.”
{Matzav.com}