United Nations Secretary-General Antonio Guterres expressed firm opposition on Tuesday to a newly introduced Israeli plan for overseeing humanitarian aid to Gaza, warning that it could drastically reduce the flow of life-saving supplies to civilians.
“This proposal risks further controlling and callously limiting aid down to the last calorie and grain of flour,” Guterres said during a press conference, according to Reuters. “Let me be clear: We will not participate in any arrangement that does not fully respect the humanitarian principles: humanity, impartiality, independence and neutrality.”
Humanitarian assistance into Gaza has been halted since March 2. Israel has made it clear that full aid access will not resume until Hamas releases the remaining hostages captured during its October 7, 2023, attack.
The IDF’s unit responsible for coordinating activities in the territories, known as COGAT, stated that it had shared a new aid oversight plan with international partners, including the United Nations. According to COGAT, the proposal is meant to improve transparency and ensure aid reaches the intended recipients.
“The mechanism is designed to support aid organizations, enhance oversight and accountability, and ensure that assistance reaches the civilian population in need, rather than being diverted and stolen by Hamas,” COGAT posted on X.
Despite this assertion, Jonathan Whittall, a senior United Nations humanitarian official in the region, publicly said there is no verifiable proof that humanitarian supplies have been misused or diverted to militant groups.
The Israeli military resumed its offensive against Hamas in Gaza last month after a temporary ceasefire collapsed when Hamas refused to release additional captives.
Guterres painted a bleak picture of the crisis, stating, “Gaza is a killing field – and civilians are in an endless death loop.”
He reiterated his demands for the “immediate and unconditional release of all hostages,” a sustainable truce, and open access for humanitarian operations.
Speaking forcefully against Israeli policy, Guterres denounced the continued sealing of Gaza’s border crossings and the blockade on humanitarian goods. “With crossing points into Gaza shut and aid blockaded, security is in shambles and our capacity to deliver has been strangled,” he said.
The Secretary-General also emphasized what he called Israel’s obligations under international law.
“As the occupying power, Israel has unequivocal obligations under international law – including international humanitarian law and international human rights law,” he said, asserting that Israel must ensure the population’s access to essential services like food and healthcare. “None of that is happening today,” he asserted.
Since the Hamas-led massacre on October 7, Guterres has been repeatedly critical of Israel’s military actions and policy decisions.
In the weeks following the attack, he stirred controversy by stating that Hamas’ brutal assault “did not happen in a vacuum,” which many perceived as shifting blame toward Israel.
After facing sharp backlash, Guterres insisted his comments had been misunderstood and reaffirmed his condemnation of Hamas’s actions.
Later, he mentioned Hamas’s use of sexual violence during the October 7 massacre in the same statement as reports of abuse against Palestinian detainees — a comparison that sparked additional outrage.
He would go on to imply an equivalency between the October 7 terror attack and the humanitarian situation unfolding in Gaza.
More recently, Guterres condemned Israel’s renewed military campaign in the Strip, saying he was “outraged” by the continuation of airstrikes.
That remark triggered a harsh response from Israeli officials. Foreign Ministry spokesperson Oren Marmorstein fired back, writing, “We are outraged that you, Antonio Guterres, are the Secretary-General of the UN.”
“Not a word about the fact that Hamas rejected two American proposals to extend the ceasefire and release more hostages—two proposals that Israel accepted,” Marmorstein continued.
He also slammed the Secretary-General for failing to address how Hamas has used aid shipments to rebuild its military infrastructure.
“Not a word about the fact that Hamas exploits the transfer of goods to Gaza to rebuild its war machine in order to further attack Israel.”
Marmorstein concluded with a scathing indictment of the UN’s own agencies, saying, “Not a word about UNRWA, which, under your leadership, employs Hamas terrorists, and its facilities were used by Hamas to hold hostages. Indeed, we are outraged by your moral bankruptcy.”
{Matzav.com}